5 ms·
The 1% are getting richer and its not going to stop any time soon
- uasnew 9y agoPerhaps an easy way is to stop legal lobbying - and all this stops?
- travoc 9y agoYou’ll have to amend the constitution. Good luck.
- pimmen 9y agoLobbyists just make politicians’ work easier, even if the politicians would’ve received no money or compensation at all the politicians still like the service they provide. Politicians want, above all else, to stay in power. That’s their actual full time job. To do that you need key supporters, not just financiers for your campaign but blocks of voters, and the latter is the most precious of all and the one lobbyists can help politicians with. If the coal miners keep you elected you want to know what political moves will please them. Same thing with minorities, elderly and other demographic blocks; they want mutually exclusive things and lobbyists who represent these groups can tell you what would please the group they represent. So, if you make it illegal for these groups to meet politicians through lobbyists politicians will do their best to reach the voters instead. That’s basically the service Cambridge Analytica supplied, in a sense.
- notheguyouthink 9y agoDoes it? Generally speaking, you make money with money, right? So even if playing "fairly", it would seem the 1% will still get far more rich far faster than anyone else. Lobbying only slows that down some, if at all. Don't get me wrong, I think Lobbying in its current form is disgusting. Yet, directly I don't blame it for the wealth gap. I suppose you could argue that lawmakers might have a chance at proposing solutions if not for lobbying, so by taking lobbying away you eventually, somehow, fix the problem. Even with that said, I'm still more curious to talk about possible solutions to the problem directly, rather than hoping to foster an environment where someone else will fix the problem.
- vannevar 9y agoUnless there is some kind of political miracle and the governments of the developed world can devise a wealth tax that works, per Piketty, it won't stop until there is another major world war.
- cdmckay 9y agoIt’s not going to happen because the majority of the governments are run by the 1 percenters
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jerf 9y agoYes. I find the idea that we can solve this problem by giving more power/money to the .1% and they'll take that power/money and (step two of underpants gnome plan here) and then the .1% won't have so much power/money is kinda silly. In fact isn't it rather convenient that the solution that everyone proposes to money/power inequality is to give the .1% more money and power? Weird how that inequality just keeps going up, huh?
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoSo were the governments before World War I.
- EGreg 9y agoHow is a world war gonna help? The rich will have nanobots and AI that can counter any strategy by the plebes.
- greedo 9y agoWar is one of the "Great Levelers."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rhaps0dy 9y agoThe title should be "it's" because it's a contraction of "it is". But that's exactly how it's written in the headline :(
- curtis 9y agoI wonder how much of the "1%"'s wealth is in stock. My guess is most of it, at least in the United States. If you think that's a problem, and most of this wealth is in the stock market, then that may be a good argument for increasing the tax on capital gains. I don't expect that to happen anytime soon, though.
- dopamean 9y agoI think that is mostly it.
- skookumchuck 9y agoSince anyone can participate in the stock market for $100, anyone can get a piece of that action.
- horsemoney 9y agoIf you really take the 1% (not just those billionaires) then a lot of that is IRAs (which are stocks and bonds) as well as personal real estate. If you have an IRA plus a house worth a million bucks combined, congratulations, you're in the 1%. By the way, it's nonsense to think that those 1% control that wealth. They'll be lucky to save more than half of it when the next stock market correction is coming in, or when the Fed prints the value of long-term bonds into oblivion. Yeah, maybe they get to vote on some shareholder meeting, or they get to shoot trespassers on their lawn, that's their level of control.
- drharby 9y agoHa doy
- sctb 9y agoIf you won't start posting civilly and substantively we'll ban the account. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- drharby 9y agoI contend my past civil contributions which carry contrary perspectives have been nitpicked and warped out of context to a point that dialogues are nonexistent and astroturfing will continue to plagur these forums provided they are wrapped in the right words.
- horsemoney 9y agoThis is made to sound like something is being taken from the other 99%, but that's probably not true. First of all, most people down really own anything of value, if anything they owe. In proportion to practically anything else, stocks have gone up like crazy and those 1% own a lot of it. They also are explicitly and implicitly the creditors of that debt. Stocks going up creates even more debt via the wealth effect. The real redistribution from the bottom to the top will happen as follows: Stock market crashes, massive defaults on debt and massive dollar devaluation. Lots of IRAs will be fucked. Don't be left holding the bag!
- qaq 9y agoWhy articles about 1% keep getting illustrated with pictures of top 1% of billionaires? 1% are lawyers, Doctors, Senior Software Eng. etc. If we are talking about US top billionaires are in top 0.0000018%.
- lainga 9y agoThere's more clicks in "those dirty moneybags are getting richer at our expense!" than in "we're getting richer at the developing world's expense!"
- horsemoney 9y agoWhy do you think we're getting richer at their expense? They're getting richer by trading with us. I mean, it's not impossible to turn a profit from some developing nation, but most of the value in the markets is from developed countries. You can only make so much money off of low-end cheap foreign labor.
- qaq 9y ago40% of US GDP is financial services by being the emitter of world's reserve currency we get very large set of unique economic benefits that precisely let us to "to get richer at their expense"
- shivamroo 9y agoTrue
- emmanuel_1234 9y agoYes, it bugs me too. A lot of readers on HN, myself included, are part of the 1%, easily .1 or .01%. Having an education / the leisure to spend enough time to understand and be interested in the kind of topic that are discussed here, along with just having an internet connection probably puts you in the top 10%. For example, having a fixed salary in France, at minimum wage (~17,760EUR/y) puts you in the top 4% globally. Anything above minimum wage and you steadily climb to the top 1%. Poor people are a lot poorer than we think, and you're likely not among them if you're reading this.
- tici_88 9y agoI have a feeling the wealth distribution in the years prior to WWII was pretty similar to where we are or are headed. I wonder if there were comparable data/studies done back then.
- logfromblammo 9y agoHow about a secret society dedicated to calculating the de facto richest individual in the world every quarter, then judging them? The "winner" gets to live if they are judged to be a net benefit to humanity, and is assassinated if they are not. Previous winners are periodically re-checked to make sure they haven't fallen off the wagon. First the monarchs start to disappear, then the corrupt heads of state, and then rich people start spending their money to either escape the judgment, or to improve their public image in case they can't spend their way down to #2. If you try to tax it away, the rich will just hide their wealth and then buy off the tax inspectors that go looking for it.
- skookumchuck 9y agoTrotsky's "iron broom" was their effort to get rid of the 1% and confiscate all their wealth. That didn't work out too well for anyone.
- horsemoney 9y agoSo, the richest guy in the world can pay off the taxmen, but not the assassins? You're vastly underestimating the IRA.
- logfromblammo 9y agoThat's why it's secret. If you don't know who to pay off, you have to pay off everybody. And if you do that, you're either not going to be richest any more, or you'll get a reprieve for your generosity and philanthropy.
- horsemoney 9y agofair enough: *guys
- makecheck 9y agoIf you have tons of money to spare, you can afford to throw money “at the wall” and see what sticks. For every case of losing money, there’s probably a lot more that pays off, especially when a billionnaire can afford to have entire staff working to minimize the chance of bad investments. If a great opportunity arises, you can put much more into the pot (most people would have to put their whole life savings in). Also, any single problem isn’t likely to completely screw you, you just pay for it and move on. For many people, they are literally one step from bankruptcy and can’t have anything go wrong. Also, if you can afford even slightly nicer stuff, it is probably better-made and won’t require outright replacement. You can afford more insurances to avoid paying the full cost of what you do replace. (Most people will never do this.) And the rich have way, way more time. They probably aren’t figuring out how to juggle two jobs, taking many-hour commutes, etc., all of which gives even more opportunity. And that’s just off the top of my head, there’s probably more. You can’t even begin to equalize a system with so much advantage built in to one side. My guess is that it starts by giving people more time. Fix the “need two jobs” problem permanently. Make housing more affordable to minimize travel.
- horsemoney 9y ago>> For every case of losing money, there’s probably a lot more that pays off, especially when a billionnaire can afford to have entire staff working to minimize the chance of bad investments. Not true at all! Most businesses sink, even with the smartest people on board it's really hard to beat the S&P 500 longterm, that's why managed funds are suffering and also a big reason why stocks are overpriced right now. Everybody just buys into passive investing. It's gotta come down, but the best experts won't be able to time it. Think about it, if all it took was money to hire some experts to beat the market, why not make a product out of it to sell to everyone? Warren Buffet can't hold a candle to the capital commanded by middle-class retirement investors.
- skookumchuck 9y ago> And the rich have way, way more time. The ones who make the money tend to be workaholics. > If you have tons of money to spare, you can afford to throw money “at the wall” and see what sticks. You can afford it, sure, but you'll lose pots 'o money that way. > For every case of losing money, there’s probably a lot more that pays off, especially when a billionnaire can afford to have entire staff working to minimize the chance of bad investments. If your staff is so great, they'd be making the money themselves. Besides, anyone can hire such staff - that's what mutual funds are. Any billionaire I've read about made their investment decisions themselves. > My guess I recommend reading some biographies of wealthy people and how they got that way. Kennedy, Jobs, Gates, Carnegie, Buffet, Musk, Hearst, Getty, Walton, Bezos, take your pick, etc.
- shivamroo 9y agoWhy it is flagged?
- bassman9000 9y agoThese articles never mention how many of the 1% were in the 1% 5 years ago, and how many have left the 1%. Always focusing on the bracket, never the individual.
- RickJWagner 9y agoAs programmers, we tend to make a lot of money. If you feel guilty about it, give some to poor people. But please don't pollute Hacker News with articles.