5 ms·
Investments? When you buy a crypto currency, what are you investing in?
by criddell 9y ago
Investments? When you buy a crypto currency, what are you investing in?
- 908087 9y agoDelusional dreams of vast riches seems to be the common theme.
- alleghoryjones 9y agoThe dreams haven't been so delusional thus far.
- alehul 9y agoWhile you're being downvoted, I wouldn't necessarily disagree. On the stock market (which we consider a more legitimate investment), share price is entirely driven by perception and the amount of buyers vs sellers. This resembles cryptocurrencies as well. The difference, however, is that there is an underlying company you're betting on with a stock, and buyers often believe that a company will have more buyers in the future due to the company's performance and its actual returns. Cryptocurrencies are a much more volatile, short-term investment with virtually no regulations, and there's very rarely an underlying bet aside from "this sounds good and will sound good to other people too."
- wuliwong 9y agoThere maybe little in the way of special regulations for cryptocurrencies but certainly fraud is still illegal, no matter the specific industry or asset. I think when people say there are 'no regulations' it communicates an idea that theft, fraud and/or violating contracts are not prosecutable. Maybe that's my own flawed interpretation but I believe that's how it comes across to the average person.
- deadmetheny 9y agoHot air, quite literally in the case of mining pool server farm energy waste.
- wpietri 9y agoThank you for saying so. As far as I'm concerned, it's speculation, not investment. Investment has some sort of underlying productive asset which one gets a part of and that then hopefully pays returns. Speculation is betting money on price movements. As long as we're trying to rehabilitate financial terms, cryptocurrencies don't have "market caps". Stocks do, because they represent companies which could plausibly be purchased in one go for something near that number. But currencies and commodities don't have market caps, because buying up an entire currency a) doesn't make any sense (the value of a currency is in its continued circulation), and b) would wildly distort the price if even a fraction of the total were purchased.
- mtnGoat 9y agoisn't most investing speculative though?
- GFischer 9y agoInteresting question. I'd assume that it's not and that the Warren Buffets, pension funds and value investors outnumber significantly the day traders (which are trying to profit off the former) and speculators.
- duskwuff 9y agoNormally there's some sort of external factor that you're indirectly speculating on -- the success (or failure) of the company issuing a stock, for instance. With most cryptocurrencies, though, there's no economic fundamental underlying the price; speculation is the primary (and, in many cases, only) thing controlling the price. The fact that cryptocurrency markets aren't regulated -- and, in fact, are frequently manipulated by schemes that would be illegal in any other marketplace -- doesn't help, either...
- kolinko 9y agoIn case of the top ~100 cryptos/tokens, there is usually an external factor. Besides that, the distinction between speculation and investment is not as clear as you say. By your definition, there is no such thing as "investing in art" - only "art speculation". The definition of investment/speculation I prefer is whether the asset purchase is based on economic reasoning, or emotional reasoning. The latter is people buying "because the charts are growing", or "because the market is hot but will be hotter", or using technical analysis voodoo. If you have a basis for your purchase price that is not connected to historic price charts, you're an investor.
- jraines 9y agothe ability of a consensus protocol & its associated distributed system(s) to preserve an accurate history in the face of a multi-million (or billion) dollar bug bounty and/or state-level attack. You get a price that discounts the risk of failure on that front and the failure to win mindshare / real use. There are many strong arguments as to why that's a bad bet, but that's the bet IMO.
- cft 9y agoValue store, which will come in handy after US defaults on its debts.
- weavie 9y agoIn your opinion, what is the probability of that happening?
- cft 9y agoIn my opinion, it will happen around 2040 with almost certainty, but probably in the form of hyperinflation out of debt, rather than actual default.
- RivieraKid 9y agoValue store is not an investment. And a US default is extremely unlikely.
- deadmetheny 9y agoIn the extraordinarily unlikely chance of that happening you're going to want guns, ammunition, and a food supply, not digital Beanie Babies.
- mihaifm 9y agoIt's the same as with other investments. You're putting some money in, with the hope that the thing you buy will appreciate in the future. When you buy stocks what exactly do you buy? Some stake in a company? Nonsense. You're just hoping that company will do well and your stock will appreciate. Sure you can invest in commodities like oil or gold. Does that mean that an oil tank will be delivered to you door? No. You're just creating a virtual position with that commodity, hoping to close it later at a better price. Same with crypto currencies.
- perl4ever 9y agoIf I believe that shares of stocks generally come with votes, which allow you to control the company if you have enough of them...and I believe that oil or gold futures do indeed entitle you to take physical delivery, does that mean I should not invest in cryptocurrencies, because I inhabit a different reality than those who do?
- derimagia 9y agoA lot of cryptos have the same thing, with "votes"
- hyprCoin 9y agoFor platforms, I invest to get a discount on apps I intend to release. SONM falls into this category and is one of my largest holdings.
- lallysingh 9y agoJust like any currency - the goods that can be traded for it. Not useful as a currency in places with solid currencies like the US or EU, but some countries have poorly functioning currencies where cryptocurrencies provide some benefit. Also, it has value as a transfer currency, like when your own country limits how much money you can take out of the country. In places where you can move money easily, and the local currency is stable and generally usable, then it's basically a trading commodity like gold or oil.