4 ms·
"Banning guns" violates the USC and simply is not going to happen without a Constitutional amendment, which politically will never happen to 2A.
by pc86 9y ago
"Banning guns" violates the USC and simply is not going to happen without a Constitutional amendment, which politically will never happen to 2A.
- Retric 9y agoBanning gun clips is viable, even cartridges seem to be optional as ball and powder is clearly a gun. Single shot weapons are good enough for home defense and vastly reduce the impact of gun violence.
- pc86 9y agoBanning magazines based on what? Any magazine ban that effectively bans a class of weapon (e.g. nearly every type of handgun currently manufactured) is no different than banning handguns.
- Retric 9y agoYou can't buy a belt-fed machine gun, so banning types of guns and ammunition are both constitutional. They are fairly simple to manufacture a single shot hand gun, and they are still plenty useful to hunt wildlife with just look at history. The clip is a weapon of war, just look at the impact repeating rifles had on the civil war for example. As to the reasoning, a single bullet is a threat, but far less useful for mass shootings. So banning them would save thousands of american lives over time and it's also constitutional.
- megaman22 9y agoActually, you can buy a machine gun. It just requires a fuckload of money, time, and the willingness to go under the microscope by the ATF in order to obtain the necessary licenses.
- Retric 9y agoNot a new one. My next step is to change bullet diameters.
- vlehto 9y agoDid you know there are lots of hobbyists who cast their own bullets? Any diameter is doable to them.
- Retric 9y ago98% effective is still very useful.
- vlehto 9y agoIf hobbyist can do it, then its easy for mafia, street gangs and drug cartels. Do you want those people to have more power and fresh markets?
- Retric 9y agoStreet gangs are vastly less organized than you might think. Countries that ban guns have vastly less gun crime because these are not highly competent people.
- dogma1138 9y agoThat isn’t true, many countries where guns are very hard to obtain legally have horrible gun violence Mexico is a prime example. Some countries that banned guns and have very little gun violence also have something else in common and that is strict border / customs control e.g. The UK, Australia, Japan and South Korea all of which are islands or effectively an island since the N. Korea border isn’t exactly open. Mainland Europe while having less gun violence than the US isn’t exactly gun violence free far from be it and it’s a pretty commmon occurrence to have gangs shoot it out and even throw grenades at each other even in Norway since guns are easily smuggled through land from former soviet block countries and even from as far as Afghanistan.
- pc86 9y agoThe only reason you can't buy a belt fed machine gun is because it's a machine gun. It has nothing to do with the magazine, and survived a legal challenge because all the pre-existing firearms that matched that definition were grandfathered in (which coincidentally, is why you can still purchase a fully automatic M4 for something like $30,000).
- Retric 9y agoThe next step is to require a new bullet diameter when manufacturered which over a few decades would make all existing firearms useless. Net result vast reduction in gun violence, zero constitutional issues.
- pc86 9y agoYou do realize there are already tens of dozens, if not hundreds, of different bullet lengths, diameters, and pressures, right? I don't know why folks who want to ban guns outright need to live in this fairy tale world where all guns are evil, you only ever need one bullet, clips are magazines, and the Constitution is more of a gentle guideline than a law. If you want to ban guns I'll have that debate but at least pretend to care about rule of law and make the arguments from a point of law instead of "this gun is black and scary and I don't know anything about it so we should ban it based largely on cosmetic features."
- Eire_Banshee 9y agoYou think we just throw away all of those brass casings we use at the range...? Lol, big gun nuts are gonna have tens of thousands of shells around just waiting to be refilled.
- maxerickson 9y agoAnd determined individuals can always just manufacture or rechamber a weapon to use the new caliber. But you don't have to completely eliminate gun violence to claim a massive reduction...
- deleted 9y ago
- vlehto 9y agoIn U.S. you can buy belt fed machine gun. But you need a special licence. If you remove the full auto functionality of such gun, you can buy belt fed anything as much as you want without any licence. Single shot handgun is incredibly bad for hunting. Single shot rifle is useful and some people still use them for added challenge. But having a bolt action rifle with maybe three rounds in the magazine is much better for beginners, because if you miss and wound the animal, you can end the suffering with follow up shot. Clip is just a bent piece of metal. It's mostly out of favor by now. They we're used because that's insanely cheap and easy to manufacture. And currently could be manufactured in a garage with very cheap tooling. https://milsurpexchange.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/copy_313_sksclips.jpg https://milsurpexchange.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/copy_... Magazines are the modern option. It's practically a plastic box with spring inside. It has almost no strength requirements and magazines are some of the most easily 3D printed items around. http://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2011/09/21/welcome-to-the-future-print-yourself-an-ar-15-magazine-at-home/ http://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2011/09/21/welcome-to-the... Most firearms with no detachable magazine can be converted to accept a magazine relatively easily. How are you going to stop criminals from making the conversion and 3D printing the magazine?
- Retric 9y agoAltering a single shot gun to use any form of Magazine or Clip is vastly more challenging than manufacturing a Magazine or Clip. As to 3 shots, a revolver that can't be rapidly reloaded is the kind of compromise that's worth talking about. Cutting the number of bullets you can fire in 10 seconds by say 1/3 is in and of it's self a useful compromise. PS: Personally I don't think the full vs semi auto is generally a useful distinction because you quickly run out of ammunition in either case. However, limiting someone to say 6 shots per 30 seconds really world be a significant change.
- vlehto 9y ago>Altering a single shot gun to use any form of Magazine or Clip is vastly more challenging than manufacturing a Magazine or Clip. Requirements: usage of hand drill and screwing on 3D printed adapter. Only parts of a firearm that cannot be easily manufactured or endlessly modified in some random garage are the barrel and the chamber. >As to 3 shots, a revolver that can't be rapidly reloaded is the kind of compromise that's worth talking about. There are currently no revolver rifles manufactured. So it would be very bad deal for hunters. Then there are revolver speed loaders and half moon clips. Those things are bloody miraculous. The difference between those and magazines is so small that some cops still use revolvers. Have you looked at the statistics of how many people die in mass shootings and how many people die in single shootings? Also do you know how many shots is fired in average gunfight in US? >Personally I don't think the full vs semi auto is generally a useful distinction because you quickly run out of ammunition in either case We agree on this. I have shot full auto AK-47 and I could probably take out 6 people with single magazine while firing full auto because you easily waste about 5 rounds with every burst. Switch to semi auto and I could probably take out 25 people with that same magazine. Switching between targets usually takes equal amount of time regardless are you firing semi or full auto.
- Eire_Banshee 9y agoYou can buy a belt fed machine gun legally, btw. It will cost you a lot because there aren't a lot of NFA stamped automatic weapons left that were grandfathered in, but you can buy one pretty easy if you have the cash.
- AllegedAlec 9y ago> home defense But this is not what the second amendment is about. In the words of Hammilton: > This will not only lessen the call for military establishments, but if circumstances should at any time oblige the Government to form an army of any magnitude, that army can never be formidable to the liberties of the People, while there is a large body of citizens, little, if at all, inferior to them in discipline and the use of arms, who stand ready to defend their own rights, and those of their fellow-citizens.
- Retric 9y agoA sufficient population with single use firearms could still overthrow the government. It would take more people, but that's about it. Just look at all those peasant revolutions which lacked training or weapons of war to start with.
- AllegedAlec 9y agoSure. Technically, they don't need arms at all. That doesn't mean that the 'well-armed' part of 'well-armed militia' should just be ignored.
- Retric 9y agoWe don't included Davy Crockett nuclear rocket in 'well-armed' or even a FIM-92 Stinger. So, it's clearly not simply a question of all military weaponry as long as it's usable by infantry.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- amalcon 9y agoPeople make this mistake a lot (anti-gun people make it, too). The point was never that the American people would be able to repel an oppressive force using only their personal weaponry. That was ludicrous even back in the 1700's. The key point is that, when the rebels inevitably capture weaponry or receive foreign assistance in that form, they would be generally familiar with its use. They would have skills like marksmanship, trigger discipline, and maintenance. They might need to learn the specifics, but these skills largely transfer. Edit: Now, I don't think banning breech-loaded firearms makes sense, but that is for reasons unrelated to the original purpose of the second amendment.
- leetcrew 9y ago> Single shot weapons are good enough for home defense source? one center mass shot from a 12 gauge or an ar would probably put down an assailant, but only if the person aims perfectly (easier said than done with a long gun inside a building in a stressful situation). and with a pistol, by far the most common firearm in the US, you are pretty unlikely to neutralize the threat with only one shot.
- Retric 9y agoAiming a gun at someone is a useful deterrent, actually firing is generally unnecessary. Plenty of cases of people using even empty guns in this role. As to being shot, even the 'Hollywood graze' is going to ruin your day and make a lot of noise. Actually killing someone is very rarely necessary.
- AstralStorm 9y agoPlease watch some recordings of happenstances in places where gun violence is rampant, such as Brazil. Intruders and robbers attack places clearly employing armed guards. That have their weapons visible. A graze is called that because it rarely kills - and adrenalin is one hell of a drug, trained people can resist for quite some time in life and death situations even after being shot and stabbed multiple times.
- Retric 9y agoI know someone that pays for an armed guard in Panama. Simply having the guy on the property without firing a shot has been extremely effective. You can always think about that last 0.0001% but 99% effective is where you see the vast majority of benefit. PS: Actually walking around with a loaded gun is fairly useless vs someone willing to sniper you from a distance. The simple truth is even criminals want to minimize risks.