3 ms·
I just coined that word, but you are right that it is polarisation in a sense that it's either too light or too heavy. However, what I mean by "Averagisation"
by mrtksn 9y ago
I just coined that word, but you are right that it is polarisation in a sense that it's either too light or too heavy.
However, what I mean by "Averagisation" is that all the content begins to look like the previous one and as the trend is to drift either to the most monetizable or most politically extremist.
I wouldn't call this polarisation because these are not polar opposites. The "nice, advertisers friendly" content is not polar opposite to the extremist content, they co-exist without any conflict. So, the content becomes more from the same, just they are in two categories.
- catamorphismic 9y ago"Uniformization" sounds like a better fit, if we are searching for a more conventional word.
- mrtksn 9y agoMaybe. I just don't want to use a well-established word to tag a new phenomenon because people can start judging the situation by the wider meaning of the word "Uniformization" or maybe different people will understand something different. Instead, I coin a word and proceed to explain it. I find that using words with precise technical definitions or words that are jargons is dangerous in an informal context.
- lmm 9y agoSounds analogous to Stross' concept of a "beige dictatorship" in politics.
- gr33nman 9y agoOr “Homogenization”
- bitxbitxbitcoin 9y agoI think this is the more established term.
- prepend 9y agoIs it related to “regression to the mean?”
- ctraynor 9y agoWhat you're describing seems to be pretty much exactly polarization. You get one set of creators who want monetary gain and so their content fits within certain limits. Over time this will create more similar content as they watch what works for other people. The other set of creators have different goals and don't care about monetary gain. The popular parts of this content will also tend to local maximum based on the level of extremism that's popular.
- mrtksn 9y agoAn iPhone unboxing video is not a polar opposite of a video complaining about feminists. I wouldn't call this polarisation even if it can be described as the polarisation of income models because my concern is about the content of the videos. I find it disturbing to see comments on HN completely disregarding the content and context and default to monetary optimisation. I believe that people and their creations are what matters and the business models around those are incidental, despite the fact the business is influencing the content. People always sing songs but the way they profit from this keeps changing over time. Selling tickets, selling recording, selling streaming, selling right - all change as the technology and society changes. Therefore, I think that the polarisation is not the right word here as there is no polarisation of the content of ad-friendly and controversial content. They might be polarised among themselves tho, like iPhone vs Samsung and MAGA vs Antifa.
- ctraynor 9y agoThe content of two videos don't need to disagree with each other for the general effect to be called polarization. The polarization isn't about income models, it's about the different kinds of content (light hearted safe content that aligns with advertisers vs extreme content that doesn't). I may have confused things by mentioning gain. The different goals of the creators was just my basic explanation as to why similar content continues being created because the effect is already in place. I find it disturbing that you disregard the effect of capital. Advertisers are 100% focused on monetary optimization, and they're very good at driving creators to what will work best for them. Of course content and context is important. But, money drives the content creation. Even when it isn't used to pay for the original content. Advertisers want impressions and clicks. Content creators want more viewers. The type of content aligns with advertisers goals -> money becomes involved -> more similar content. And other creators see this and want part of it.
- ableal 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hotelling%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hotelling%27s_law (Why ice-cream stands on a beach bunch together in the middle instead of being conveniently - for customers - distributed.)