3 ms·
Hey! I'm usually that guy, but in they are they are using "optically stimulated luminescence". https://www.usu.edu/geo/luminlab/whatis.html https://www.usu.edu
by gus_massa 9y ago
Hey! I'm usually that guy, but in they are they are using "optically stimulated luminescence".
https://www.usu.edu/geo/luminlab/whatis.html https://www.usu.edu/geo/luminlab/whatis.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luminescence_dating https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luminescence_dating
I'm not an expert in the subject an I'm not an archeologist, but the method sounds good.
One of the parts is the decay of radioactive atoms. This is a very well known subject, it's very easy to model and it is not affected by pressure or temperature (unless you use ridiculous huge amounts).
The other part is about electrons trapped in the defects of crystals, and the conduction and valence band of crystals. This is also a well known subject, but it's more difficult to model. So IIUC after measuring the amount of "trapped" light they must irradiate each sample to calibrate the "trapping" ability of the material. This is not affected by usual variations of pressure and temperature. In particular the energy of the photons in sunlight is very different from the photons due to normal levels of heat. (At high temperature like more than 500°C or 900°F, that is possible near a fire, the difference between the energy of the photons is not so much and you have https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoluminescence_dating https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoluminescence_dating . But the heat below a few inches of the floor under sunlight is not enough.)
As I said, I'm not an expert, but it looks like they are combining well known techniques and I guess that if you can enclose a bunch of Ph.D. students in a lab for 20 years with proper equipment, a few interesting samples and enough food, they will be able to rediscover this method.
If you want to find something shady here, I'd look at
> [Katerina] Harvati, who wasn’t involved in the research, said she would be cautious in definitively assigning the finger fossil a Homo sapiens identity due to the fact that its shape overlaps with other hominin species. [...]
- aetherspawn 9y agoThanks for the writeup. Makes sense, but requires some further thought on my part (re: comments below on validation using multiple methods). Also I have no problem with the biology aspect as it is trivially verified what a human (or otherwise) bone looks like, composition etc
- lurquer 9y agoDude in a caravan 100 years ago gets finger cut off while harnessing camel. Buried finger in sand. At night. (thus leaving the sand 'unbleached' as the term is used in the optical luminescence field.) Occam's razor.
- gus_massa 9y agoI still not 100% sure because I can't read the research article, but from the press article it loos like they didn't find the bone in the middle of a pile of sand but in the middle of some dry mud that was at the bottom of a lake a looong time ago. With dry mud you an easily notice if someone has been digging there after the main part of the sediments was formed. Some relevant parts: > After all, fossilization on land is very rare; the water and wet sediments of the paleolake must have offered just the right protection from oxygen to preserve the bone. > One possibility is that, at the time, it wasn’t a desert. While the Nefud is all sand and rock today, at the time of the Al Wusta fossil, the region was a savannah, covered in lakes and rivers thanks to summer monsoons. The multitude of animal bones found in the same location, from wild cattle to antelopes, suggest that game was plentiful. The lake itself lasted year round and offered a source of fresh water, though it may have come with risks as well as rewards: many of the faunal bones bore marks of carnivores’ teeth.
- lurquer 9y agoReads like they found it near the surface: ------ "But researchers behind the recent Misliya discovery argue that the bone’s location on the surface rather than in the lake deposits below mean it might not correspond to that climactic period."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Ar-Curunir 9y agoLol for people interested in Science, HN really likes to think Science is easy and done by idiots...