5 ms·
> Lastly, a transaction is either voluntary or it is not. There are no degrees of 'voluntary' if you use the word in the conventional sense. So if I point a gu
by lisper 9y ago
> Lastly, a transaction is either voluntary or it is not. There are no degrees of 'voluntary' if you use the word in the conventional sense.
So if I point a gun at your head and threaten to shoot you if you don't hand over your wallet, you would say that you voluntarily handed over your wallet because that was a fair price for keeping your head intact?
Most people mean something different when they use the word "voluntary".
- patricius 9y agoBut that is exactly an example of an involuntary transaction including threat of violence or murder.
- lisper 9y agoOK, so here's a second example: suppose I somehow arrange to have control over all of the available food and tell you that in order to access it you have to hand over your wallet. Is your choice to hand over your wallet so you can eat now voluntary or not?
- patricius 9y agoIt is voluntary whether he chooses to hand over his wallet. Edit: Irrelevant comment.
- lisper 9y agoOK, so if you give me your wallet because I threaten to kill you with a gun (quickly, painlessly) that's not voluntary, but if you give me your wallet because I threaten to kill you by starving you to death (slowly, painfully) that is voluntary? That makes no sense to me.
- patricius 9y agoIf I don’t give you my wallet, I face starvation. I could choose to steal from you but that would be immoral. I personally don’t have any control over any food. If I go the supermarket, they threaten to starve me if I don’t hand over my money. I believe it is a voluntary choice for me to pay up not to starve.
- lisper 9y agoBut supermarkets are competitive. The scenario I'm putting forward is one where I have a monopoly and use that leverage to charge you 100% of your income for just enough food to survive.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoIn the conventional sense of the word, no, that transaction is clearly not voluntary. And I don't think your example is making the point that you're trying to use it to make.
- lisper 9y agoSee my response above to Patricius.