5 ms·
> The AV1 format is and will always be royalty-free Not sure how they can make this statement. VP8 was patent encumbered all over the place and eventually req
by threeseed 9y ago
> The AV1 format is and will always be royalty-free
Not sure how they can make this statement.
VP8 was patent encumbered all over the place and eventually required licensing from MPEG-LA. Surely AV1 would be infringing on at least some of HEVC's expansive patent pool. Unless of course Google is willing to indemnify user's against patent infringement lawsuit. Which would be really big news.
- Thaxll 9y agoFrom wikipedia: AOMedia Video 1 (AV1), is an open, royalty-free video coding format designed for video transmissions over the Internet. It is being developed by the Alliance for Open Media (AOMedia), a consortium of firms from the semiconductor industry, video on demand providers, and web browser developers, founded in 2015. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AV1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AV1
- threeseed 9y agoNot sure what this comment is supposed to mean. All of that was covered in the article as well.
- thiagocsf 9y agoIn Reddit, these type of comments are usually upvoted to the top because most users don’t bother reading articles. My guess is that we have a fellow redditor here.
- Twirrim 9y agoGuessing (maybe generously?) at OP's meaning, claims were made in the past about VP8 being royalty free etc, and that turned out to be wrong. It's not clear how much we can trust them this time around. http://www.streamingmedia.com/Articles/News/-76781.aspx http://www.streamingmedia.com/Articles/News/-76781.aspx http://carlodaffara.conecta.it/an-analysis-of-webm-and-its-patent-risk/ http://carlodaffara.conecta.it/an-analysis-of-webm-and-its-p... http://www.fosspatents.com/2013/03/patent-clouds-remain-over-vp8-google.html http://www.fosspatents.com/2013/03/patent-clouds-remain-over... http://www.fosspatents.com/2013/03/next-patent-infringement-trial-over.html http://www.fosspatents.com/2013/03/next-patent-infringement-...
- shmerl 9y agoAll of those are quite old sources, and patent claims were refuted. Is there anything newer?
- Twirrim 9y agohttps://www.zdnet.com/article/google-and-mpeg-la-settle-long-running-vp8h-264-patent-dispute/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-and-mpeg-la-settle-long... So far as I can see, that's the final state. Google ended up having to get a license from the MPEG-LA VP8 patent pool.
- magicalist 9y agofrom your link: > Google's Serge Lachapelle notes that today's agreement is "not an acknowledgment" that VP8 infringes on any of the patents claimed by MPEG LA https://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/rtcweb/current/msg06631.html https://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/rtcweb/current/msg0663...
- shmerl 9y agoBad for Google, but it's not a proof that they require a license. The court didn't rule on it, so it just shows that they didn't want to fight the troll further.
- sofaofthedamned 9y agoThere is nothing in there that asserts your claim about VP8 being encumbered by royalties/patents.
- pavlov 9y agoApparently Google does IP diligence for AV1 to navigate around patents. Matt Frost of Google is quoted as saying: "Obviously, if we have an open source codec, we need to take very strong steps, and be very diligent in making sure that we are in fact producing something that's royalty free. So we have an extensive IP diligence process which involves diligence on both the contributor level – so when Google proposes a tool, we are doing our in-house IP diligence, using our in-house patent assets and outside advisors – that is then forwarded to the group, and is then again reviewed by an outside counsel that is engaged by the alliance. So that's a step that actually slows down innovation, but is obviously necessary to produce something that is open source and royalty free." The original source is a video, but this quote transcript is on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AV1#cite_note-frost-sme2017-16 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AV1#cite_note-frost-sme2017-16
- mtkd 9y agoHow did we end up at this point? It's like a self-enforced ceiling on evolution of technology. The tar pit gets more tarry every year.
- pavlov 9y agoFortunately patents are fairly short-lived (at least compared to copyright). A lot of the worst software patents were granted in the '90s and early 2000s and are reaching their 20-year expiration date.
- zip1234 9y agoHave a look at recent patents for Facebook. http://stks.freshpatents.com/Facebook-Inc-nm1.php http://stks.freshpatents.com/Facebook-Inc-nm1.php A patent for 'user status update suggestions' for example. Yuck.
- kelnos 9y agoDoes this actually help that much, though? I imagine many of the important patentable improvements end up being obsolete by the time the patents expire.
- shmerl 9y agoWhen did VP8 require licensing?
- pgeorgi 9y agoWhy should Google indemnify users when MPEG-LA isn't willing to do so for their licensees? (see the mess that HEVC is in now, or even good old MP3 with Sisvel)
- magicalist 9y ago> VP8 was patent encumbered all over the place Was it? Can you name a single patent? MPEG-LA never did. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/03/google-mpeg-la-agree-to-royalty-free-terms-for-vp8-video-codec/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/03/googl...
- xroche 9y ago> MPEG-LA never did The never do. It's like the mob: "pay us or you'll be in trouble". You can either pay the MPEGLA (and by the way, you will never know who inside the MPEGLA decided to sue you), or face consequences (and discover which patents are supposedly infringed)
- stepik777 9y ago> Surely AV1 would be infringing on at least some of HEVC's expansive patent pool Yes, it probably would, but if these patents are owned by members of AOM it is not an issue