4 ms·
I call this the Michael Caine, Sean Connery and Tom Jones effect. In the 1910s Britain was a viciously divided society - with poverty gaps greater than the US
by lifeisstillgood 9y ago
I call this the Michael Caine, Sean Connery and Tom Jones effect. In the 1910s Britain was a viciously divided society - with poverty gaps greater than the US sees now. The Great Depression was somewhat levelling but children born in the East End of London, Glasgow's Gorbals, or the rural poverty of Welsh valleys had desperately worse outcomes than those in the middle classes. (Can you guess where each of the celebrities was born and raised ? :-)
Then came a war that threatened to
cut off our food supplies (Nazi UBoats sank horrifying tonnage of shipping), and to combat it a simple solution was found cutting through generations of political baggage - rationing. Every citizen got given a minimum set of healthy food (like two eggs a week, a pound of meat etc etc).
For some this was government over-reach - for others it was the first time in their lives they had eaten properly. After the war, a Labour government introduced a welfare state that prescribed a minimum amount of food, education, healthcare in an on going fashion.
And what did we get 20 years later? We got tall strong good looking actors and singers who came to dominate their niches and did so without the rickkets, malnourishment and disadvantages that had been their older brothers lot. We got similar results in medicine, science and business, with each area finding their own James Bond, drawn from a much wider pool of talent.
In short we fed our underclass and turbo charged our growth in the post war period.
In my view there is a bottle labelled "nitro" attached to the American Economy that has yet to be turned on. The knob does have razor blades attached to cut whichever politician tries to turn it, but folks, it will be worth it, 20'years from now
- vokep 9y agoInteresting, I must say this makes some sense. On the otherhand I'm quite seriously opposed to wealth redistribution of any kind. While this isn't a major communist situation, it is as you said a welfare state. Historically capitalism is cyclic. Inequality grows over time until people are fed up and the system breaks, and then repeat and things are good for awhile. Perhaps one solution would be purposefully resetting the cycle from time to time. An occasional slight redistribution which gives the necessary boost to those in poverty to have some kind of fighting chance. Its probably a bad idea as most socialistic ones are but eh it sounds interesting, who knows.
- lovich 9y agoIn a conversation pointing to actual benefits from a socialistic system, your response is to say they are all bad and you oppose them anyway? How is that not just a dogmatic response, instead of a viewpoint backed up by reason?
- notfromhere 9y agoIf you want to look at a society where wealth isn't redistributed in some fashion, look to pre 20th century Europe. There was no hope or opportunity for most during those times.
- nimish 9y agoA strong, well-funded safety net protects and lifts all boats.
- dboreham 9y agoClose to home : my grandparents talked frequently of what it was like under rationing; and Sean Connery was my grandmother's milkman for a while..
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoDid she get up early and ask for enough milk to bathe in :-) (very obscure reference. How far up do you want it to come luv?)
- lifeisstillgood 9y agorereading that it could be taken the wrong way. My apologies if any offence caused. a fuller description is that having Sean Connery as your milkman is quite a story, and leads almost irresistibly to the land of milkman jokes. The one I remember is in "Ernie, fastest milkman in the west" (a Bennie Hill song #) - where the female character asks for enough milk to bathe in - and the milkman says "do you want it pasteurise? Pasteurise is best" and She replies "I would be happy if it got up to me chest" Yeah it's Seaside Postcard innuendo - but seemed in keeping. like I said, i apologise for any offence caused to you or your grandma. (#) Look the 70s was definitely a weird time - Bennie Hill and Black and White minstrels would never get prime time TV today. but they are a part of my childhood and whatever tracks they left in my brain I need to expose to the light occasionally...
- dboreham 9y agoThere's a similar joke around the brand of peanuts called "Rising Sun". I'm familiar with seaside postcard innuendo having grown up in a seaside town. Yeah no offence taken. Connery was just a kid when he was delivering milk. He later worked as a lifeguard at one of the swimming pools in town, where I believe he was spotted by a talent scout. But he was also active in amateur theater at the time, so ymmv on that story.
- nitwit005 9y agoWhen it comes to the traditional problems of poverty such as malnourishment, freezing in the winter, lack of cloths or shoes, and so on, many countries have done quite well. Even fairly poor countries have had success there. The complaints coming out of the US are more about inequality than poverty, although people confuse the two issues (sometimes intentionally).
- lifeisstillgood 9y agowell, in the UK a hundred years ago our cities hid poverty of the kind that is rare in modern world (war zones and the like). Rowntrees reports were transformative in understanding of same - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty,_A_Study_of_Town_Life https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty,_A_Study_of_Town_Lif... Also it's worth noting that modern notions of poverty are relative - with the "poverty line" often being drawn as some % of median income. Of course this is discussing inequality of wealth - which is what we usually mean, and is the pillar around which the other inequalities get talked about (unequal opportunity due to race, religion, education gender etc)
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The complaints coming out of the US are more about inequality than poverty, although people confuse the two issues (sometimes intentionally). They aren't distinct; poverty is always in relation to a set of standards, and there are very good reasons to looking to the contemporary context for the most applicable standards.
- nitwit005 9y agoIf you set an income standard, sure, it's relative, but you aren't "relatively" starving, or "relatively" infected with parasites because you have no shoes. Those are real problems that have nothing to do with how society choses to view innequality.
- todd8 9y agoAm I interpreting your story too literally? Do you mean that our economy will improve if we give people more food? Obesity is now a problem that affects all socioeconomic strata in the USA. See [1] and [2]. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db50.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db50.htm [2] https://stateofobesity.org/socioeconomics-obesity/ https://stateofobesity.org/socioeconomics-obesity/
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoYes too literally. We introduced a welfare state that for all its many failings, gave those at the bottom of society a floor below which they could not fall below, and that was a floor that gave sufficient supprt to grow and flourish. And with that flourishing came new talent, talent that had been previously held back by circumstance, and that talent helped drag the bankrupt UK out of its own collapse and bankruptcy (post WWII) The UK (and Europe) no longer have that vast inequality and underclass, but like its shale oil reserves, the US has cunningly kept tens of millions of poor and downtrodden citizens in misery, just so you can turn on the gas and surprise the Chinese economy with one last blast ;-)
- todd8 9y agoOkay, got it. It’s not the way I see it exactly, but I understand your point! Thanks.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoWell i did have to put in a special order for a brush as broad as the one I used above :-)