3 ms·
The fundamental problem with math education in the United States (yeah, I know the article is about UK, but it's Friday and I'm in a ranting mood) is that math
by btilly 16y ago
The fundamental problem with math education in the United States (yeah, I know the article is about UK, but it's Friday and I'm in a ranting mood) is that math is taught as a set of rules that must be followed, rather than as a common-sense way of systematizing simple common concepts.
http://randomgraphs.blogspot.com/2009/06/feynman-on-education.html http://randomgraphs.blogspot.com/2009/06/feynman-on-educatio... is a good cautionary tale on what this tendency leads to.
Part of this is that teachers tend to have a poor quantitative background themselves,
This is not a new problem. In the 50s a survey of elementary school teachers found that most thought that 3/5 was larger than 2/3. Based on anecdotal experience and the impressions of people I've talked to, I would expect the same result if the same question was ask of today's teachers.
Speaking of anecdotes, the first time I won an argument with a teacher was in grade 6. I hadn't done my homework, so I sat reading the textbook while the class went through homework. I understood the textbook's explanation, and realized that the teacher had been teaching us the wrong thing for the last 2 weeks, and that explained why the class had consistently found that the answers in the official answer key were "wrong". It took me 20 minutes of arguing to convince the teacher, and everyone had to relearn that 2 weeks of material. (We had been practicing doing arithmetic in bases other than 10, and he had been teaching us to just calculate the answer in base 10 then convert into the right base. What we needed to do was convert the number into base 10, calculate, then convert back into the right base.)
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoWhat you need to do is, learn to calculate in other bases. It works exactly as well as doing it in base 10, and of course is yards quicker.
- btilly 16y agoIf you use another base a lot, then yes. But when you're facing problems in a half-dozen bases at once, then the learning curve of keeping that many times tables separate is not worthwhile.
- eru 16y agoYou should also read how Feynman helps with choosing school books in California. http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm