3 ms·
To propose gutting unions requires proposing a substitute. Unions are known to protect “incombants”. It is a very real problem with plenty of studies in the la
by ianai 9y ago
To propose gutting unions requires proposing a substitute.
Unions are known to protect “incombants”. It is a very real problem with plenty of studies in the labor literature.
- sokoloff 9y agoAn alternative is "no union" obviously. It works for other government employees, active duty military for example, and I wouldn't think your average E-1 has any more negotiating leverage than an individual public school teacher. Military has IG; that could perhaps serve as a model to protect those employees in ways that they ought be protected but without the thuggish protectionist aspects that unions often fall to.
- ianai 9y agoI’ve heard that those positions do not treat laborers in ways to be modeled as success. The best way to position a market is such that the parties involved naturally meet mutually beneficial outcomes. Ie incentivize away from abuses and toward goals.
- sokoloff 9y agoJuly 1 this year will mark 45 years of an all-volunteer armed forces (meaning no draft, not meaning that people are working without pay). It seems that the military is able to meet its demand for personnel without a union for the employees, so I'd say there's at least a lower limit on "meet mutually beneficial outcomes".