3 ms·
This is counter to the point of funding them more. Unions exist to empower labor. Remove them and you diminish teachers. Regulating them or coming up with crea
by ianai 9y ago
This is counter to the point of funding them more. Unions exist to empower labor. Remove them and you diminish teachers. Regulating them or coming up with creative incentives for societal outcomes would help. Ie give a subsidy (or even an award) to unions for onboarding new teachers and retraining current teachers.
- sokoloff 9y agoUnions are one way to pay teachers more. It's possible to be in favor of paying teachers more and still be anti-teacher union. Disclaimer: My parents both taught in public schools their entire careers and their county was unionized. My parents seemed to hate the union on balance, but now I'll have to ask them... The shenanigans that I experienced first and second hand that were enabled and supported/defended by the union were appalling. Teachers teaching subjects they were unqualified for, teachers not showing up to work reliably being protected, a math teacher who literally replied that "the square root of 2 is irrational because it says so on page 79", etc. It was always "gimme more, more, more" and never seemed to be about the kids. If that experience is in any way indicative, I'm all for gutting the teachers' (and other similar) unions. I don't mind paying teachers more than we currently do (and paying the required taxes to enable that), but I'd like to see some accountability and improved results. The key question is how to judge that on a timeframe that is both fair to the kids and the measurement (a long timeframe) and to the teachers (who probably don't want to wait until kindergarten junior is 30 to be paid)
- ianai 9y agoTo propose gutting unions requires proposing a substitute. Unions are known to protect “incombants”. It is a very real problem with plenty of studies in the labor literature.
- sokoloff 9y agoAn alternative is "no union" obviously. It works for other government employees, active duty military for example, and I wouldn't think your average E-1 has any more negotiating leverage than an individual public school teacher. Military has IG; that could perhaps serve as a model to protect those employees in ways that they ought be protected but without the thuggish protectionist aspects that unions often fall to.
- ianai 9y agoI’ve heard that those positions do not treat laborers in ways to be modeled as success. The best way to position a market is such that the parties involved naturally meet mutually beneficial outcomes. Ie incentivize away from abuses and toward goals.
- sokoloff 9y agoJuly 1 this year will mark 45 years of an all-volunteer armed forces (meaning no draft, not meaning that people are working without pay). It seems that the military is able to meet its demand for personnel without a union for the employees, so I'd say there's at least a lower limit on "meet mutually beneficial outcomes".
- michaelt 9y agoUnions exist to empower labor. In the airline industry, I've heard it claimed [1] that the unions currently in place are bad for junior employees, because of the way they're structured internally. In particular all the political power is held by long-serving pilots - so long-serving pilots earn $300,000 and are last to be laid off, while junior pilots earn $20,000 and are first to be laid off. In other words, pilots are simultaneously overpaid and underpaid - and the union simultaneously empowers and disempowers employees. I don't know how accurate that claim is - but in discussions about American teachers' salaries, I have noticed people seem unable to agree on whether teachers are well paid or not. [1] http://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines.html http://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines.html