3 ms·
The problem is that a 5-star rating system is almost never a good fit. The stars are meaningless and it ends up coalescing into some tiny fractional scale. My
by manigandham 9y ago
The problem is that a 5-star rating system is almost never a good fit. The stars are meaningless and it ends up coalescing into some tiny fractional scale.
My uber ride either gets me to my destination safely, reliably, and timely, or it doesn't. It's just a yes or no, and should be rated as such. This would smooth out the subjective reviews and give drivers a much more fair rating. Support requests can take care of any specific complaints. Likewise tips can do the same for positive signals.
- AstralStorm 9y agoSombre people do not want to top but they shouldn't be barred from positive rating on the ride. The trouble is that rides are not reproducible readily. Conditions change (congestion, path taken, mood of the client or driver) Thirds means you have to accumulate a large amount of any kind of rating for it to maybe mean something. Drivers could game the system by servicing "good drives".
- manigandham 9y agoI do not want tipping at all, but since some people do and it's already here, it can probably stay. Outside of that, there is nothing stopping you from just talking to your driver if you want to compliment them. And yes, conditions change, which is why the 5 star system is too vague and useless. What is the difference between 4 or 5 stars? And why would this mean the same thing to anyone else who gets a ride after you? It's best turn this into a binary signal instead. Any system can be gamed, but it's much better when there are less random choices.
- vitorgrs 9y agoI guess this would be a nice solution. Yes or no, and then create a percentage. Just like Netflix and some services. So let's say, if you have less than 30% or something like that, you get out of Uber. And if you have more than 85%, you can be part of Uber X VIP (at least here in Brazil, if you use a lot Uber, you earn one month of Uber X VIP, so just works with drivers with top ratings. If you use a lot again, then you'll earn another month and so on)
- polskibus 9y agoWhat if it didn't get you on time because of you or because of an external event that couldn't have been planned for? Life is not black and white.
- jdmichal 9y agoThat's why it's not a no-tolerance policy. But, you will probably find that some people tend to "attract" such external events. Because they don't leave enough time to account for any externalities. Or, in this particular case, maybe they actually are a bad driver that does not know routes good enough to avoid anticipated traffic patterns. And so on... If Uber really cares about why the service was bad, they can always break out multiple yes-no questions. (They probably don't, though.)
- manigandham 9y agoOk, does that happen for every ride? Then there's clearly a problem. If it's 1 ride, then what's the difference? A binary choice would result in most people actually saying the trip was ok, even if a little late, especially since they're also in the car and can see the situation for themselves. Otherwise the trip is 'not ok' and contact support if there's a big problem.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoBut we all know that's not going to be the threshold. It's going to be if you drop below 85%, you're out of Uber.
- adrianmonk 9y agoAlthough there isn't an explicit number associated with it, seems like the threshold between ok and not ok could itself be subject to the same problem as inflation. There more it becomes clear to me that giving someone a not-ok rating threatens their job, the more that I don't want to take that nuclear option.