5 ms·
HP is right to sue Mark Hurd
- yummyfajitas 16y agoJust a note, the title reflects the opinion of the author, not me. I have no opinion on the matter, but thought a counterpoint was useful.
- rbanffy 16y agoI have to agree with the author. When you sign a confidentiality agreement you have to expect to keep what you know about your job confidential.
- parfe 16y agoI don't understand why the golden parachute payout when combined with a non-compete doesn't take the form of continued "employment". Keep the guy on the payroll making $6million/year for 5 years. The lump sum "thanks for all the fish" payout just seems like you are forcing yourself to sue, rather than just fire the guy.
- NumberFiveAlive 16y agoIn this case, it's because HP was dumping Hurd because of the controversy. You can't sever ties with someone but keep them on the payroll for 5 years. Even if it amounts to the same thing.
- pmichaud 16y agoThis piece is probably right, but in a purely sociopathic sort of way, Hurd did the rational thing: take the $23m for signing the confidentiality agreement, then worry about actually keeping that money later. A bird in the hand...
- po 16y agoThe saying is not "A bird in hand AND the two in the bush." If he was following that expression he would stay with his millions and ride it for a year or two. He knew he could lose his "bird in hand" by joining Oracle. This just makes me wonder exactly what Oracle was offering him.
- pmichaud 16y agoYou don't get hired as a big wig in 1 month. That process takes quite a while, so the one month was probably just the ending part, the culmination of many months or even a year of recruitment effort. That he took the $23m anyway just means that he would rather have a chance at keeping it than no chance of keeping it, which is rational. Plus, that amount of money makes enough interest to pay for its own legal defense, so he really had no down side to accepting it with every intention of breaking the agreement then getting sued for doing so. If he loses, he breaks even, if he wins he gets $23m. Makes sense.
- po 16y agoNo, I agree that it's rational. Just that the saying doesn't fit. ;-) Also, in this case, there wasn't a long recruitment duration. He was kicked out by the board somewhat abruptly due to a scandal and Larry Ellison went on record saying he thought it was a stupid move. Within weeks he was hired. I think Larry respected the guy, didn't care about his scandal, saw an opportunity, and jumped on it.
- rbanffy 16y ago> You don't get hired as a big wig in 1 month You do. Networking is everything. And, if he loses, Oracle and Hurd will have damages to pay. By violating his confidentiality agreement and going to work to a direct competitor (Oracle acquired Sun after all) he will cause irreparable damage to HP's business. It's unethical for Hurd to accept the job and unethical for Oracle to offer it. I am not surprised.
- napierzaza 16y agoHe could have easily balanced the two. If Oracle offered to beat the amount and pay legal fees, he could easily go to Oracle. I don't think he simply decided to break the agreement without considering things.
- brownleej 16y agoHere's what I don't get. If the agreement he violated only required him to protect HP's trade secrets and such, how can merely taking a job violate it? Even if it's likely that he would reveal these secrets at some point in the future, is that enough to constitute violating this agreement? Wouldn't they need proof that he has already released sensitive information to Oracle?
- mgrouchy 16y agoThis. If he hasn't actually revealed any trade secrets yet, why are they suing them? Because he may reveal trade secrets? I understand HP's interest and need to protect themselves, but they are doing it preemptively. As of yet, he hasn't done anything wrong.
- rbanffy 16y agoBecause the day he starts working at Oracle he will start having to answer questions and make decisions that will be based on confidential information he learned at HP. The risk of that damaging HP's business is high enough that HP feels it's necessary to sue him.
- Blunt 16y agoI just find this highly unlikely... Managers at large multinational companies just are just a few levels deep into management tend to know jack about 'trade secrets' or what the actual secret sauce is much less have their hands on it via separation of duties policies. I don't see the real "threat" here.
- spinchange 16y agoGiven that there is no "non-compete" and only a confidentiality agreement, I don't agree that HP is 'right' to sue seeking to bar his employment elsewhere. If they felt this way, it should've been negotiated in the severance agreement. Perhaps HP can do what IBM did with Mark Papermaster when he went to Apple - make him check in with the courts from time-to-time to swear that he's not divulging confidential information.
- jrockway 16y agoIf they felt this way, it should've been negotiated in the severance agreement. That's their problem; what HP actually wants is illegal in California. So they are trying to get the same thing in a different way. (And will likely fail, because hey, it's illegal.)
- tptacek 16y agoBasically devastating: Hurd accepted over $30MM in an exit process that involved him signing an agreement the spirit (and likely the letter) of which enjoined him from accepting the role he appears to have taken at Oracle. What's interesting about this to me is that it's a case where you can see a downside to California's policy against noncompetes. It's hard to argue that $30+MM(!) is inadequate consideration for an executive noncompete. Most people, even those who (like me) detest noncompete agreements, can grudgingly accept the notion that it's fair and reasonable for two parties to agree to set one up with two lifetime's worth of compensation in exchange for avoidance of competition. So far as I can tell, none of the exceptions to the "noncompetes are invalid in California" policy cover Hurd, who isn't a partner at HP and hasn't accepted the noncompete as part of the sale of a huge chunk of HP stock. HP is left with the much fuzzier trade secret enforcement path to express a much simpler "don't go fuck us" agreement.
- Blunt 16y agoI don't get this. HP = hardware and non-DB software. Oracle = database company. How is HP threaten by Oracle again?
- calloc 16y agoWhat company did Oracle recently buy that was built around something known as the SPARC processor?
- russell 16y agoOracle = hardware, remember Sun? HP = consulting. Oracle = consulting. They overlap in lots of areas. HP stupidly fired Hurd and now he has gone to the company most likely to eat their lunch in a lot of areas.
- rhooper 16y agoStrictly speaking, HP seems to want to enforce their confidentiality agreement as a "generally unacceptable" (FTA) non-compete. The two are separate entities, and although Hurd is trying to have his cake and eat it too, HP is doing the same. The article outlines an array of superficial "flaws" in the argument that Hurd should be expected to work at a high-profile tech company.. given any real thought, the article's hard backing of HP's corner is obvious. >CEOs get paid handsomely for this very reason; they are set for life, at the very least. So, if they are restrained from not working for a direct competitor for two years after leaving the firm -- sitting on $33+ million dollars, in Hurd's case -- so be it. Hurd isn't restrained from working for any individual or party -- the confidentiality agreement is, again, NOT a non-compete. >Mark Hurd also has many options. He may choose to work in the technology sector with a company that do not pose this strong a conflict of interest with HP. HP most likely would not object to companies such as some smaller tech firm, private equity, or venture capital, just to name just a few of the many options available within technology. Hurd has plenty of options, yes, but in the absence of a non-compete, who is HP, or the author, to dictate his options? Why wouldn't they object to Hurd working ANYWHERE that might utilize his same knowledge? >Moreover, many exiled CEO`s work as business consultants, advisors, teach classes at MBA programs, work for many diverse business organizations, etc. during this natural transition period. And again, more mindless spectation. Hurd could have done any of the above options, but he likely chose the most profitable and beneficial. Who wouldn't? I think Hurd is being thrown over a fire because HP is enforcing a confidentiality agreement as a de facto non-compete, and everyone seems to be going along with it. Even the author of the article himself states that Hurd is violating the 'spirit and intent' of the confidentiality agreement. If that 'spirit and intent' is non-competition, then the agreement should have been such. This is a whole lot of PR spin on HP's part, and the legalities aren't being looked at. If Hurd doesn't violate the confidentiality agreement by divulging 'trade secrets' or .. per the agreement.. "confidential" practices, then he should absolutely be permitted to utilize his former work experience in a new position. Isn't that what all of us do when transitioning to a new employer?
- grellas 16y agoI understand the spirit of the author's point in this piece (and, in fact, sympathize with it) but it really does not track the relevant California law. This case will turn on what is known as the "inevitable disclosure" doctrine, which has been explicitly rejected in California, going back to the Schlage Lock case in 2002 (see http://library.findlaw.com/2003/Mar/18/132641.html http://library.findlaw.com/2003/Mar/18/132641.html) and most recently in Flir Systems, where the court found that a trade secrets case had been brought in bad faith because it was based on inevitable disclosure. (A recent article on why this case law makes HP's Hurd case an uphill fight appears here: http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1202471748471 http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1202471748471). Basically, California law prohibits non-competes in a post-employment context unless coupled with a transfer of a goodwill interest (e.g., when your business is acquired) and, when an employer complains that a former employee will "inevitably" disclose valuable trade secret information by reason of his position with a new firm, the courts have rightly interpreted this position as an after-the-fact attempt by the employer to get what amounts to non-compete-style protection where the law otherwise forbids this. At the same time, HP is not without arguments because California's adoption of the Uniform Trade Secrets Act does authorize courts to enjoin "threatened" violations of an employer's trade secrets. This usually means the employer has to present detailed evidence that the former employee's role in the new company poses a clear threat that this would happen. Of course, without additional evidence, the mere fact that the employee's new position poses such risks really amounts to "inevitable disclosure" (which the courts reject) and this means that a complaining party is not likely to win such a case unless it really does have some other evidence strongly suggesting that trade secrets are likely to be compromised. That is why it is such an uphill fight for the employer. Inevitable disclosure cases are often upheld elsewhere in the U.S. but even then it most often happens when the departing executive is shown to have done suspicious things along the way (see, e.g., this piece summarizing why a guy who was one of a handful of people in the world to know the ingredients and processes by which Thomas' English muffins achieve their "nook and cranny" feel could legitimately be enjoined from joining a direct competitor, and where the evidence showed that he hung around for months after secretly accepting the competing employment and, in effect, gathered information from his old employer in anticipation of the move: http://chicagobreakingbusiness.com/2010/07/english-muffin-secrets-safe-at-thomas-for-now.html http://chicagobreakingbusiness.com/2010/07/english-muffin-se...). In my view of it, major egos are involved on both sides of this Hurd mess and that is likely what is driving this lawsuit. It will therefore be brutally fought and, if there is an ounce of anything in the law to support an injunction, HP will scrape for and find it. Given the well-settled California law, however, this effort is likely to amount only to a wild swing that is unlikely to land. This may mean that Mr. Hurd will get a windfall while HP is left with nothing but a black eye, but that is what is most likely to happen.
- raganwald 16y agoIn Ontario, management have fewer protections under the law than rank-and-file employees. For example, it is illegal to fire a rank-and-file employee just for exploring other job options. If they look for a job on their own time and equipment, that's their business and they can't be fired for this alone. Managers are entitled to no such protection. A manager is considered to be a more vital component of the company's value, and as such the act of seeking another job without negotiating this in advance with your current employer is considered a breach of your obligations to the company even if you do so on your own time. There's some fuzziness involved. Is a team lead considered a manager or a senior developer with some project management responsibilities? Is an Architecture Astronaut with no reports but crucial IP responsibility entitled to job hunt without permission? Getting back to this situation, my point is that there is a difference between the obligations of a CEO and the obligations of a rank-and-file employee. Laws erected to protect employees at the expense of the company shouldn't apply to CEOs. Obviously, California's laws are whatever they are for whatever reason. But even if Mark's actions are technically legal, I consider them wrong in every way shape and form. In fact, debating the legality of his actions is ridiculous for me. I'm not a lawyer, nor do I consider it a worthwhile pursuit to argue what a law can be interpreted to mean with flagrant disregard for the moral ideal. Morally, I find this repugnant.
- daniel-cussen 16y agoHP should have paid him a few million every year if he didn't take a job at a competitor that year.