4 ms·
What if I told you... (Morpheus photo) 1. Social websites don’t have to be giant, centralized communities too big to police themselves. 2. People need more t
by EGreg 9y ago
What if I told you...
(Morpheus photo)
1. Social websites don’t have to be giant, centralized communities too big to police themselves.
2. People need more tools to help them achieve things in the real world, rather than spending hours a day chatting about the real world online.
3. There are ways to make money online without ads begging you to click on them, and they involve real-world goods and services that your website can help connect people for?
What kind of world would it be that one minute spent online would result in hours of enjoyment out of the house?
Would you NEED to collect data on people in order to tailor ads to them, when the interface would enable them to express their own INTENT to spend money, which you can then help facilitate?
EDIT: downvoted heavily, what else is new. Yeah, clearly saying people want to achieve things in the real world deserves condemnation and scorn from anonymous downvoters, but no counterpoint is given.
- URSpider94 9y agoAll the things you mention are certainly possible, but if that’s truly what consumers wanted (judged by where they spend their time and money), then the market would reward companies that provided those services. Put another way, you can argue as much as you want that people want to eat salad and steamed vegetables for every meal, because it will make them thinner and healthier. And yet, McDonalds is still doing well (maybe not quite as well as before, but still very well). Regulation will curtail the edge cases where people are acting to their own detriment to a degree that society deems unacceptable. Beyond that, it’s up to the invisible hand of capitalism to dictate what customers want.
- geofft 9y agoWhat? Why? The market rewards working services over not-yet-working ones - it's not surprising that customers who prefer a more complicated service will use the less complicated one in the meantime. There's also all sorts of confounding things with social networks like network effects. Capitalism is one way to get at a society's preferences. It is not the only way, nor is it able to perfectly determine a society's preferences.
- merinowool 9y agoCapitalism is the most free of all, from there the more you turn left the more authoritarian it gets.
- geofft 9y agoWhy is democracy not the most free of all? Let one person have one vote - not one dollar have one vote.
- merinowool 9y agoIt is not, as one could say it is a tyranny of majority...
- nybble41 9y agoTo expand on what merinowool said: Under capitalism you are free to do whatever you want with your own property provided you extend the same courtesy to others, and don't interfere either their use of their property. It is easy to see that this is an optimum balance: any more freedom than that would necessarily come at someone else's expense. This is sufficient on its own to say that any other system must be less free than capitalism. "Democracy" comes in many forms. If a particular implementation of democracy includes strong (effectively absolute) protection for the rights of the minority, including property rights, then it becomes a special case of capitalism where interested people voluntarily choose to address issues of common concern through voting. One example of such a system is a co-op; no one is forced to participate, but those who do become members have equal representation with respect to the disposition of the co-op's common property. If respect for the minority's rights is subject to majority vote, however, then things which one would be free to do under capitalism—by definition involving only one's own property and that of others who voluntarily choose to participate—become restricted to suit the will of the majority, which plainly makes one less free.
- merinowool 9y agoI couldn't put it any better. Thanks!
- qznc 9y agoIn other words: People get what they want, but not what they need. Similarly: Short-term trumps long-term.
- EGreg 9y agoI think it is because the solutions don’t exist yet. Like before the Telephone consumers “preferred” to visit each other. The Gentleman Caller.
- anonymousab 9y agoI think the problem with 1 is that the usefulness of Facebook, for a lot of people, comes from having darn near anyone they ever knew on the platform. There's the benefit of being able to trivially connect with friends, family and acquaintances by a few degrees. But since that applies to those users too, and the overlap is partial, the user graph grows unbounded. If you limit it in some way, then you necessarily will have some users at an edge with a restricted experience. That's likely very bad for business. With point 2 there's the general overall argument of whether these concrete, codified social networks should exist at all - whether they are healthy to society or people compared to the more limited gossip circles they would be in otherwise. I don't think it's clear cut to call it worse and I don't know if we can put that cat back in the bag even if we wanted to.
- EGreg 9y agoI would argue that being able to find anyone is a bug, not a feature. Bill Gates doesn’t let people find him on FB by his name. Why should anyone else? The real names policy is a consequence of this thinking. But why should people put that info out there for everyone and the NSA to find out?
- qmalzp 9y ago> 3. There are ways to make money online without ads begging you to click on them, and they involve real-world goods and services that your website can help connect people for? Yeah, I could even imagine a scenario where you help connect people to real-world goods and services for free; the provider of those goods and services would be more than happy to help keep your bills paid, assuming there was some kind of mechanism that would drive people to their goods and services and not a competitor. What would such a mechanism look like?
- always_good 9y ago>There are ways to make money online without ads begging you to click on them, and they involve real-world goods and services that your website can help connect people for? Not every website is in a position to sell something directly. That's how ads work in the first place. I run a collaborative writing forum that is predominantly used by teens. I make so little money off it that I'm running it as a charity because forums like it were a valuable part of my youth. And there's very little I can do to make money from my userbase these days, though it used to make a couple thousand bucks per month and got me through uni. People on HN and the like love to scoff and go "if you can't make money, then you don't deserve to exist" which is awfully short sighted. Like the only consequence they can think of as they Mr Burns their hands together is The Verge, operated by a billion dollar company, shutting down. Ads service the middle of the bellcurve of sites that aren't 100% charity but also not in a position to peddle you merchandise. The internet is going to lose out if society doesn't find an alternative. Just more centralization.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThe question is whether your ads really need to be targeted to individual persons (requiring a huge surveillance infrastructure) or if you can just sell ads to some sponsors and everybody sees the same ads. I prefer the second option. Nothing wrong with ads per se.
- nopriorarrests 9y agoIt's just not feasible for the sites like parent commenter described to look for sponsors, sign contracts, etc. We are talking about, say, $200-600 per month in advertising. You can spend more time searching for next sponsor then you will make from ads. They can monetize by working with 3rd party, like SSP, who will sell the inventory programmatically. But to monetize effectively, that 3rd party will do tracking, that's true.
- EGreg 9y agoI totally agree that your forum should exist. My main question would be, what exactly are you providing as a service ti the teens? Custom software? A server? It seems to be quite cheap to just download something and run it on a server. I’d like to see a self-configuring, end-to-end encrypted decentralized thing that people can literally just run on their own machines and let servers act like dumb hubs. Something like SAFE network. Then the forum software is just a client side thing like SourceTree for git. And that can be open source and free for the teens.