3 ms·
For those interested in considering alternatives, I recommend giving the sci-fi book "Queen of Angels" by Greg Bear a read. [1] That novel follows a police det
by wpietri 9y ago
For those interested in considering alternatives, I recommend giving the sci-fi book "Queen of Angels" by Greg Bear a read. [1]
That novel follows a police detective trying to solve a crime. A major source of tension is that all of the quasi-public data (public cameras, citizen movements, credit card use) is in the hands of a separate institution called Citizen Oversight. If I remember rightly, it was a separate, quasi-governmental (or non-governmental) body, broken down by region and with separately elected commissioners.
In the novel, the main focus is the relationship with the police, which was very tense; Citizen Oversight was very stingy with data. But you could easily imagine it having jurisdiction over corporate behavior around individual data. And having an active regulator whose job it is to enforce broad principles would have advantages over detailed rule-making fixed in laws. Especially so if they were part of a legally independent body.
It was definitely interesting to think about. And given that it came out in 1990, surprisingly prescient on the topic of data and privacy.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queen_of_Angels_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queen_of_Angels_(novel)