4 ms·
This article gives a good overview of the promises and issues of the Aadhar system. I might be wrong but it doesn't add anything new which hasn't been covered i
by thisisit 9y ago
This article gives a good overview of the promises and issues of the Aadhar system. I might be wrong but it doesn't add anything new which hasn't been covered in other Aadhar related articles submitted earlier.
The system has done some good. Mostly in the public schemes area where it was originally intended to stop corruption.
But, there are some serious issues with the system.
First is the internet infrastructure. As mentioned in the article, a lady had to register for it thrice because the system wouldn't load the data. That doesn't surprise me a bit because the internet infrastructure is so poor that even 512kbps is defined as "broadband".
There is a funny interview of a supposed Income Tax guy:
https://youtu.be/AnxrJiS5uKU?t=135 https://youtu.be/AnxrJiS5uKU?t=135
He equates "cloud computing" to actual clouds. And posits that if people's data in put in cloud and rains then the person is screwed out of his benefits. As stupid as it sounds, over reliance on Aadhar means people might not get their benefits if the Aadhar system is down. And given the poor internet infrastructure, that is a real concern.
Second is the creeping coverage. The system is slowly outgrowing is intended usage from public schemes to invading into private lives. Now telephones and banks need the data. It was promised that the data will never be used for forensics. But given the data stash, it is not stopping lower courts from trying to access it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nsenifty 9y ago> There is a funny interview of a supposed Income Tax guy: That's just a wrong example. He was not an officer in the government at the time of the interview. He worked for the tax department long before cloud computing was even popular.
- captn3m0 9y agoAs hilarious as that video is, it is quite out of context in a Aadhaar discussion. If someone is interested in issues with aadhaar,the rethink aadhaar website has a nice FAQ[0] [0]: https://rethinkaadhaar.in/faqs/ https://rethinkaadhaar.in/faqs/
- intended 9y agoHey if you have an article showing that Aadhar has done good, please share. Most of the Aadhar numbers are disputed and many cases they made straight up fraudulent or ambiguous claims.