3 ms·
> WhatsApp - WhatsApp feature means some encrypted messages could be read by third party. > Alternatives: > Signal - Uses Signal Protocol. Pretty sure both W
by oarsinsync 9y ago
> WhatsApp - WhatsApp feature means some encrypted messages could be read by third party.
> Alternatives:
> Signal - Uses Signal Protocol.
Pretty sure both WhatsApp and Signal both use the Signal's crypto for encryption, and both "suffer" from the same "design defect" / "usability improvement".
That said, I still think WhatsApp only encrypts text messages E2E, and doesn't bother for videos/photos/anything else, based on how efficiently it forwards videos compares to sending them for the first time (accounting for video conversion time), so I'd still put WhatsApp in the bad list, but not for that reason.
Being owned by Facebook is enough of a good reason in itself at this point too, mind.
EDIT: Just read through the full list. This is superb. Thank you for putting this together!
EDIT AGAIN: Just read through some of the comments, Iridium in particular is what got my attention as awesome, prior to learning that it's not been updated in 5 months, which is beyond dangerous given the number of security fixes that will have come out in that timeframe. Sad times :-(
- nikivi 9y agoI removed Iridium from the list. You are right, 5 months is too long for no updates in a browser. Also I agree with you on WhatsApp. I mention now that it does use Signal protocol. However WhatsApp sends user's entire contact books to their servers as well as them logging all the metadata around messages which is very revealing.
- pasbesoin 9y agoSometime in the past year, a contact required that I sign up for WhatsApp. At least on Android mobile, I didn't find how one could complete the sign up without giving them access to one's Android/Google contact db.