6 ms·
The problem is phone number reuse, if you try to open an anonymous Google, Twitter, etc account they immediately realize that phone number was already used.
by wslh 9y ago
The problem is phone number reuse, if you try to open an anonymous Google, Twitter, etc account they immediately realize that phone number was already used.
- foodstances 9y agoA lot of services that use SMS for new account verification also block numbers from non-mobile providers, even ones that haven't been used before. I tried using a Twilio number as a Google-Voice-like service where it would forward texts to my actual number, but many services refused to accept the Twilio number.
- Operyl 9y agoYep. We’re able to figure out VoIP numbers pretty easily thanks to services like Twilio Lookup. Helped out anti fraud out so much.
- chmars 9y agoIs there any non-VoIP telephony left?
- Rjevski 9y ago"VoIP" is a generic term in this case as they mean numbers that can be rented online by a customer directly, with little to no identity checks - sadly those are often used for fraud, though outright denying service on this basis alone is a dick move IMO. Pretty much all telephony is VoIP for at least parts of the call chain, though there are still even analog circuits in place; here are some numbers that lead to analog switching gear: http://www.binrev.com/forums/index.php?/topic/48166-ukrainian-crossbar-exchange/ http://www.binrev.com/forums/index.php?/topic/48166-ukrainia...
- jasonjayr 9y agoBut blocked legit users who ported their real phone numbers to VoIP, like I did. Google won't verify an account against my home phone line anymore. How can we continue to reduce fraud while still serving folks who are using the system legitimately?
- Operyl 9y agoWe offer users an easy way to contact us to request manual whitelisting. It's painless, fast, and we find that not much abuse gets through when they have to write in messages to get in.
- scbrg 9y agoWho are "we"?
- bogomipz 9y agoYou have commented twice saying "We." And it is not clear who the "we" is. Do you work for mailinator, Twilio, Google?
- Operyl 9y agoSorry, I was commenting from the perspective of a company that uses phone verification for account signups to help with fraud. I am not affiliated with any of the listed company.
- gruez 9y ago>But blocked legit users who ported their real phone numbers to VoIP, like I did. Google won't verify an account against my home phone line anymore. weird. i use a voip phone service, but twilio identifies it as a landline. maybe you're not using a fixed location voip service?
- dylz 9y agoI use Google Fi as my mobile carrier. It is blocked from virtually everything even though it is a legitimate Sprint+T-Mobile sim.
- Rjevski 9y agoOnly from those providers that explicitly disclose this fact; I provide API-driven phone numbers (from a carrier partner) and those show up as the carrier's numbers on every lookup tool, with no way to distinguish them from numbers allocated to SIMs directly. I actually really like this fact and will make sure it stays that way.
- shimon_e 9y agoWhat's your service called?
- Rjevski 9y agoNextgrid, though at the moment it's still a work in progress (building an entire telco core network from scratch by yourself takes a looooong time), but in the meantime you can get the numbers from my carrier partner directly: https://aa.net.uk/telecoms.html https://aa.net.uk/telecoms.html Those are UK mobile numbers, with SIP for voice and webhooks for texts, and all lookup tools I've found recognise their numbers as "Three" (a mobile carrier in the UK) mobile numbers. I am not actually sure how those guys interconnect to Three, it could even be literally a bunch of GSM modems with real SIMs in it. My long-term plan is to get rid of the middleman and become a carrier myself (get a number range allocated by OFCOM, UK's telco regulator) and offer both SIMs and API-driven numbers (with no way of distinguishing which is which from the outside).
- imatworkyo 9y agoDefinitely cool service - do these numbers support MMS?
- Rjevski 9y agoNot at the moment no. I might look into it before launch but to be honest nowadays there is very little business case for MMS so I’m not sure it’s worth the investment. Just out of curiosity, what do you use MMS for?
- 9y ago
- bluedino 9y agoWhich brings the question, when will 'ipv6' for phone numbers come out?
- BillinghamJ 9y agoWhy would it need to...? We aren’t running out of phone numbers.
- userbinator 9y agoWe will, if this trend continues...
- always_good 9y agoPhone numbers are regularly cycled. The nice thing about something like ipv6 is that you could build a system where reuse isn't any more convenient.
- jldugger 9y agoAnd with your own personal block of /64, you could give out unique numbers to anyone you want ^_^
- hk__2 9y agoWe need to think about it before running out of phone numbers.
- Latteland 9y agojust like we did for ipv6. think about it for years, people argue and we kind of solve all problems but too late.
- tehlike 9y agoI keep getting calls for the previous owner. I would love if i could get something unique.
- 9y ago
- Sir_Substance 9y agoPhone numbers do get recycled in a lot of countries though.
- lucb1e 9y agoAre there countries where it's not necessary to recycle them?
- anarazel 9y agoWhich is really annoying. Still getting calls, two+ years in, for the previous owner of my number. Including from medical providers.
- therein 9y agoA CVS half a continent away from has been calling me thinking that I am the previous owner of this phone number for the last six months or so. First they were leaving voicemails that I need to pick up a prescription and that they will return it in a day and stop calling me. But they have been calling every few days or so ever since. I had this phone number for over 4 years.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThat's always been the case. The problem is that, especially over the last couple of decades, people have built lots of systems with a central assumption being that phone numbers are uniquely tied to individuals. So, instead of fixing those systems, I guess the idea is to adapt phone numbers to the faulty assumptions made about them.