5 ms·
1. The snippet you're quoting is about marine mammals 2. Dinosaurs were not aquatic 3. The biggest aquatic reptiles were much smaller than modern whales (ples
by masklinn 9y ago
1. The snippet you're quoting is about marine mammals
2. Dinosaurs were not aquatic
3. The biggest aquatic reptiles were much smaller than modern whales (plesiosaurs and ichthyosaurs topped up around 15m long and 2 tons, which is 2x the length but 1/3rd the weight of a male Orca and nowhere near large whale league)
4. Dinosaurs weren't necessarily homeotherms and may have thus had a larger (but lower) range of efficiency
5. As the snippet notes the upper bound has to do with food limitations, and large sauropods largely evolved ways to mow down ridiculous surfaces (and thus amounts of food), which could have combined with higher plant growth/density from higher O2 levels to put a higher cap on food issues
- todd8 9y agoLooks like there is a small typo: should read “higher in CO2” whouldnt that produce faster plant growth?
- pfarnsworth 9y agoYour point of #3 is probably wrong. It’s harder to get fossils of aquatic creatures so there’s likely a vast number of animals that we will never know about. Saying with certainty that the biggest aquatic reptiles were smaller than whales is a logical fallacy. Only the ones we know about are smaller but we don’t know if there ever were, we might get lucky and find a fossil that is larger.
- michaelvoz 9y agoI don't think you are correct. Plenty of places that used to oceans and seas have become land. This has given us access to aquatic fossils.