4 ms·
> it's really hard to find reliable information as to what actually happens since the internet is filled with FUD websites claiming aspartame gave their brother
by smallnamespace 9y ago
> it's really hard to find reliable information as to what actually happens since the internet is filled with FUD websites claiming aspartame gave their brother/grandma/cat/chair cancer.
The burden of proof should probably be on the side of those asserting safety of novel food components, and if that means waiting a full generation for the data to come in, so be it (note that animal tests don't really tell us enough, because metabolism doesn't seem that well conserved between species; there are plenty of things that humans can eat safely that animals can't and vice versa)
Human metabolism and our food has coevolved over thousands of years, and we have evidence in the fossil record that shifts in diet (e.g. agriculture, pastoralism) had negative impacts on human health (worse teeth, shorter, weaker bones) until either our genomes or microbiomes adjusted.
If you decide to consume large quantities of novel ingredients in combinations that no humans have ever eaten before in our evolutionary history, then sure, it may turn out just fine—but metabolism is an intricate dance and there are a lot of ways to screw it up.
"Eat food, not too much, mostly plants." and "Don't eat anything your great grandmother wouldn't recognize as food." seem like sensible advice for people who can afford to follow it [1].
[1] https://www.webmd.com/food-recipes/news/20090323/7-rules-for-eating#1 https://www.webmd.com/food-recipes/news/20090323/7-rules-for...
- conradev 9y ago> and if that means waiting a full generation for the data to come in, so be it I think we're pretty close to having a full generation's worth of data, considering it was approved by the FDA in 1981.
- sameyolo 9y agoI'm not particularly young and my great grandmother lived into the mid-90s. This would amusingly give me significant leeway. In my own quest to solve my stomach ailments I permanently quit soda and juices, switching to carbonated water. Helped tremendously.