6 ms·
Freedom of the press only means freedom to use hand cranked printing presses. That is all the founders were thinking about. They did not anticipate high through
by superkuh 9y ago
Freedom of the press only means freedom to use hand cranked printing presses. That is all the founders were thinking about. They did not anticipate high throughput roll to roll printing, radio, television, or the internet. Consequently freedom of the press does not apply to any of these things.
Only hand cranked printing press manufactured leaflets should be allowed. Freedom of the press should be banned for all other mediums.
... and in case you're wondering, yes, this is a metaphor for another on-going debate and an apt one.
- Varcht 9y agoWords don't influence people, people do!
- ufo 9y agoSorry but I dont understand what analogy you are trying to make here
- OscarCunningham 9y agoPeople sometimes argue that the second amendment doesn't or shouldn't apply to certain weapons, because the founders of the US didn't anticipate those weapons.
- InitialLastName 9y agoI mean, we already know that the first amendment doesn't (and should not) apply to some forms of speech; slander, libel and incitement to violence are all things that we (as a society) have decided are forms of speech that should be regulated.
- friendlydude12 9y agoThe first amendment isn’t intended for physical speech. It exists to protect opinions and ideas. It’s for this reason lots of non-verbal “speech” is protected under the first amendment, like online posts and flag burning. Threatening violence or slander has nothing to do with the first amendment.
- friendlydude12 9y agoAnd they are totally wrong because there were all sorts of machine guns and powerful cannons available in those days, even some used in the Revolutionary war. Projectile weapons have been improving throughout history, it’s silly to assume the Founders weren’t well aware of that. I mean, there were medieval weapons that were pretty devastating by even today’s standards and the first amendment makes no mention of that. These were enlightenment thinkers well versed in the history of governments and technological progress. The 2nd amendment is a principle meant to transcend all time and cultures. The people have a fundamental right to defend their rights.
- hluska 9y agoI'm not OP, but it seems to be an apt (and well written) analogy to the 2nd amendment to the US Constitution, which grants: "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." The 2nd amendment was written when muskets were state of the art and assaukt weapons like AR-15s were almost beyond belief.
- mamon 9y agoSo, the logical conclusion would be that every citizen has the right to privately own state of the art nuclear missiles?
- s2g 9y agoYes, absolutely. The internet gives the average person the ability to mass disseminate information. If you want to try and use that as a metaphor then we should be allowed to own weapons of mass destruction.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- microcolonel 9y ago> The 2nd amendment was written when muskets were state of the art and assault weapons like AR-15s were almost beyond belief. Well, there is no definition for the term "assault weapon", and semi-automatic (edit: not semi-automatic, but self-cocking repeating, similar operation and results) weapons were well known (and not that far away from being popularized) by the time the second amendment was drafted, and by the people who were drafting it. "Arms" also encompassed things like cannons and explosive charges, which could be fitted freely to ships/properties and stored (though the latter could create a tort, if you don't take necessary precautions) by private persons, as proven in case law. It also applied to bladed, blunt, or more unconventional arms. The word "arms" is used instead of "muskets" because the right being protected is the right of the people to own arms sufficient to feasibly defend themselves (or, with a militia, defend their community), and to do so unmolested.
- devdas 9y agoGuns in the US.
- plandis 9y agoFirst amendment: “Congress shall make _no_ law” Second amendment: “A well regulated militia, being necessary [predicate] .... the right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed” Your analogy kind of fails and also isn’t really related to the article, TBH.
- andromeduck 9y agoWell if you listened to Heller vs DC, the court decided that it wasn't a predicate based on the interpretation of preceding and subsequent state law and other historical reasons.
- microcolonel 9y agoThe Supreme Court disagrees with you. No predicate (or in this case, prefatory clause) could undermine or limit an operative clause that straightforward, at most it could be considered a motivation: i.e. the right of the people to keep and bear arms is intended to (at least, but not solely) give those people the ability to keep and bear arms sufficient to feasibly form an armed militia.
- s2g 9y ago> and in case you're wondering, yes, this is a metaphor for another on-going debate and an apt one. You can use a printing press to inform thousands and thousands of people a day easily. Get rid of the 2nd amendment!
- friendlydude12 9y agoThe Founders had more foresight than you think. These were enlightenment thinkers who were well versed in the history of governments and technological progress. The Bill of Rights is a document of principles: principles exist to ensure stability regardless of culture or time period or technology. The spirit of the amendment is to allow the people to spread their own information, it doesn’t matter how they do it. The first amendment says nothing about “fake” or “real” news even though there was plenty of fake news in those days. I could argue fake news started the French Revolution.
- joelrunyon 9y agoHe's making an analogy.
- friendlydude12 9y agoWasn’t sure which direction he was going in but now I see. That’s incredible satire. Thumbs up.