4 ms·
I actually like the way this author deconstructs what a blockchain technically is and how it’s sold. And I agree on many points. However, this is where they go
by EGreg 9y ago
I actually like the way this author deconstructs what a blockchain technically is and how it’s sold. And I agree on many points.
However, this is where they go awry:
Instead of relying on trust or regulation, in the blockchain world, individuals are on-purpose responsible for their own security precautions.
THIS is the revolution. And the revolution will not be centralized :)
Blockchains are just one example of it. Kademlia trees and close consensus is another, used by SAFE network. Go look it up.
The whole POINT is, it is very hard not just for someone to tamper with a file, but to cut off access to it. Crypto-currencies also have the added requirement of preventing “double-spending”, which is very hard to do.
EXAMPLE: Why trust the landlord to have keys to open your apartment instead of an electronic lock that lets you set permissions YOURSELF? Use your phone to authenticate yourself instead of facebook controlling it. “Oh what if I lose the phone?” “Then have a backup.” “What if I lose everything?” “Then have M of N friends plus a key derived from a passphrase you know to restore it.” “Ok what about if I get amnesia and lose my phone?” “This is 0.00001% of the population and even Jason Bourne implanted a chip in his own ass.”
This guy doesn’t live in a country where the institutions people rely on have routinely screwed people. The solution is usually “throw more Democracy at it”, which is what can lead to totalitarianism.
Ever read “fuck the cloud”? It’s a good read. Why SHOULD I pay someone I don’t know to store all my files, and delete my local copies?
http://ascii.textfiles.com/archives/1717 http://ascii.textfiles.com/archives/1717
Have you all seen just recently what Facebook does? Why would I entrust my data, identity and brand to them?
Have we seen websites censored or DDOSed? Or just broken links to useful stuff?
SAFE network and Freenet etc. are the decentralized future. I agree that Blockchain is only a small part of the future.
Blockchains with one writer are, for example Scuttlebutt. Super resilient.
I also agree that there is no viable medium of exchange that’s fast and cheap for everyday transactions because the way blockchains currently work, they need a global consensus about every friggin transaction. That doesn’t scale. That’s why we launched intercoin.org
If you want to see more about this topic, I just wrote about it: https://qbix.com/blog https://qbix.com/blog
- nmeofthestate 9y ago>This guy doesn’t live in a country where the institutions people rely on have routinely screwed people. True, but his argument is that the actual fix (that would work) is to fix such dysfunctional countries so they are functional, rather than downgrading everywhere to a Somalia level of trust with blockchain as the techno solution.
- EGreg 9y agoAnd I am saying that is NOT the optimal solution. In the past we didn’t have many technologies, and we used centralized providers who did things manually. Was that better? You can throw more democracy at a problem. But technology to decentralize it is often better for everybody. I see technology as enabling UPGRADING, not downgrading. The proof is in the pudding: will people choose it over the existing systems.