3 ms·
"I see this as another symptom of USA consumerism. Your feel a little stressed? Take this tranquilizer! You feel tired? Take these vitamins!" On the selling an
by jerf 9y ago
"I see this as another symptom of USA consumerism. Your feel a little stressed? Take this tranquilizer! You feel tired? Take these vitamins!"
On the selling and purchasing end, that may be the case. No sarcasm, I mean that.
But they still need something to get a hold of to work. I think if we dig down one layer farther, what they represent is Western science's tendency towards excessive reductionism. Reductionism has its place; it has been very powerful and we've done a lot with it. (A software engineer who thinks reductionism is all bad has not thought very carefully about their their job...) However, the 20th century in my opinion had a really bad run with reductionistic views of the human body. Hence, for instance, the continual flipflopping between eggs being bad or good for you, in an attempt to reduce "egg" to an atomic element and class "good" or "bad" on a single-dimensional scale, when in fact "eggs" are insanely complicated and goodness and badness are horrifyingly n-dimensional things hard to even characterize. Vitamins are clearly important, but science has tried too hard to reduce characteristics of the body to the impact of this one single chemical on this one single problem, or things like that.
I wouldn't even say the science was bad per se; if you only have access to enough computational power to build an 8-dimensional model of a thousand-dimensional process, the best you can do is get a very reduced-power model. It may still be better than nothing. But I do think there was a lack of deep understanding and proper humility in the 20th century, and ongoing into this one. Far too many scientists and science journalists drawing lines through single points, or n-dimensional hyperplanes through underconstrained data sets, filling in the direction of the lines with their own unscientific biases.
And that's before we discuss the reductionism of attempting to model everything as linear processes, because that the "bright spot of light under the lamppost" that we can be metaphorically looking for our keys because the math works nicely for those cases, despite the obvious and abundant evidence that our bodies can not be modeled via linear processes....
(And let me both start and end on the fact that I'm still not necessarily disagreeing with you about the consumerist aspect, just trying to dig one layer further down.)