3 ms·
You already don't have control over any of the other drivers on the road, some of which are unlicensed, impaired or even homicidal or suicidal. Not to mention
by astura 9y ago
You already don't have control over any of the other drivers on the road, some of which are unlicensed, impaired or even homicidal or suicidal.
Not to mention your car already has software that can kill you, even if it doesn't steer.
Even ignoring software, hardware can have "bugs" in it too that kill you. I'm not sure why you think engineering mistakes are "worse" when they are in the software vs the hardware.
Basically, no matter what it "feels" like, you are subjected to many many many forces outside your personal control.
- gormz 9y agoYeah there can be other bugs in my car, or other people that do something stupid, but I feel like I am more in control. It is unlikely I die from my engine blowing a gasket or my ECU completely dying. It might be a slight danger to those around me while I coast to the shoulder. But at least it's not going 60 mph into the shoulder...
- astura 9y agoYou're severely underestimating danger of engineering mistakes in hardware. Faulty Takata airbags have killed at least 20 in the US and injured over 100 since 2013. Then there was the Ford-Firestone fiasco that killed hundreds and injured thousands. The Ford Pinto ended up being a death trap. I also recall there several lawsuits around faulty guardrails that have killed. That's just off the top of my head. The idea "software bugs kill, hardware bugs don't" is just plain wrong. I also can't even fathom an understanding of why it's "better" to be killed by someone whose overdosing on heroin behind the wheel than being killed by an engineering error. Especially given the hypothetical case that was proposed when engineering errors are less common.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoI think the idea was "why add another layer of things that might kill me on top of existing ones?" In this regard, SDVs deliver the exact opposite of their marketing pitch.