5 ms·

It sounds to me like the researcher wanted to use this data to identify at-risk groups and get them preventive care. I don't mean "identify" as in, de-anonymiz

It sounds to me like the researcher wanted to use this data to identify at-risk groups and get them preventive care. I don't mean "identify" as in, de-anonymize them, but to use data to figure who may need help (or advertised to -- same difference really). This actually sounds like a good idea if that's the purpose. It's not any different than retailers identifying cohorts they can sell to. It also sounds very similar to what a lot of AI research does (in my limited understanding of it). Take known samples and use that to identify/predict other things...

jamra 9y ago
Although I agree that it’s a non issue, it is a big deal to identify patients against their permission. It’s also illegal.
tjoff 9y ago
Sure, all I see is that insurance companies will be the ones with the most to gain (economically) from this information, and thus the ones that will pay the most for it.
- RoyTyrell 9y ago
  Insurance companies already have tons of relevant medical data on their clients, there's no reason why whatever FB can provide them is going to be miraculously more telling than actual medical data such as their current and past diagnoses and medical conditions.
  - sidlls 9y ago
    Insurance companies are perhaps surprisingly often ignorant about their own medical data and what it means for their clients or patients (except for what it means in terms of revenue). Entire profitable businesses (who aren't insurers) sell analytics products based on these data to companies because insurers don't have the means or know how to.
    - RoyTyrell 9y ago
      > Insurance companies are perhaps surprisingly often ignorant about their own medical data and what it means for their clients or patients (except for what it means in terms of revenue). You may very well be correct, but how do you know that? > because insurers don't have the means or know how to. Again, where do you get your insight on the inner-workings of insurance companies in general from? I'm not disagreeing with you outright. I just wondering if you're guessing or you have actual knowledge to the one or more health insurance companies and their actuarial and analytics processes.
  - LinuxBender 9y ago
    It could be useful additional data for detecting insurance fraud.
908087 9y ago
Yes, I'm sure Facebook's goals are entirely altruistic just as they were when they performed psychological experiments on hundreds of thousands of people without consent. Why are we still giving this company the benefit of the doubt after years of blatant abuse? Advertising corporations shouldn't be anywhere near my medical records, period.

jamra 9y ago

Although I agree that it’s a non issue, it is a big deal to identify patients against their permission. It’s also illegal.

tjoff 9y ago

Sure, all I see is that insurance companies will be the ones with the most to gain (economically) from this information, and thus the ones that will pay the most for it.

RoyTyrell 9y ago
Insurance companies already have tons of relevant medical data on their clients, there's no reason why whatever FB can provide them is going to be miraculously more telling than actual medical data such as their current and past diagnoses and medical conditions.
- sidlls 9y ago
  Insurance companies are perhaps surprisingly often ignorant about their own medical data and what it means for their clients or patients (except for what it means in terms of revenue). Entire profitable businesses (who aren't insurers) sell analytics products based on these data to companies because insurers don't have the means or know how to.
  - RoyTyrell 9y ago
    > Insurance companies are perhaps surprisingly often ignorant about their own medical data and what it means for their clients or patients (except for what it means in terms of revenue). You may very well be correct, but how do you know that? > because insurers don't have the means or know how to. Again, where do you get your insight on the inner-workings of insurance companies in general from? I'm not disagreeing with you outright. I just wondering if you're guessing or you have actual knowledge to the one or more health insurance companies and their actuarial and analytics processes.
- LinuxBender 9y ago
  It could be useful additional data for detecting insurance fraud.

908087 9y ago

Yes, I'm sure Facebook's goals are entirely altruistic just as they were when they performed psychological experiments on hundreds of thousands of people without consent. Why are we still giving this company the benefit of the doubt after years of blatant abuse? Advertising corporations shouldn't be anywhere near my medical records, period.