10 ms·
Facebook retracted Zuckerberg’s messages from recipients’ inboxes
- everdev 9y agoI'm no fan of Facebook and deleted my account years ago, but the flood of articles like these that are barely embarrassing since the major Cambridge Analytic embarrassment feels more like an agenda or piling on than newsworthy items. There are many reasons to reduce or eliminate your time on FB, but this isn't one of them.
- throwaway84742 9y agoThat’s because you misunderstand the intent of this pile-on. The intent is to ensure full compliance in 2020 elections.
- haydenlee 9y agoUsing bad arguments is rarely an effective way to get what you want.
- sunir 9y agoIn business. In politics it works.
- saagarjha 9y ago> The intent is to ensure full compliance in 2020 elections. I don't see how these actions help Facebook be compliant in any way.
- rdl 9y agoI think he means "towing the (establishment/party) line", not "complying with regulations".
- throwaway84742 9y agoThat’s exactly right.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoThe behaviour described in this article implies a culture willing to look one way for users and another way for themselves. That’s pertinent less to users and more to lawyers and lawmakers.
- haydenlee 9y agoI dislike FB as much as the next dev here, but surely it's a widely accepted (and beneficial) practice that employees have special privileges in the apps they build. Imagine using this argument to say that Facebook couldn't shut down a page/group/account.
- vages 9y agoYes, it is technically the same abilities being used. The reaction comes because of how they're used: to indiscriminately delete old messages that may potentially be harmful to themselves while not offering the same options to its users.
- musage 9y ago> surely it's a widely accepted (and beneficial) practice that employees have special privileges in the apps they build But it's more specific than that. Imagine using this technique to respond to someone who points out that you have toilet paper stuck to your shoe that it's agreed upon that the existence of toilet paper is a good thing, and that surely they wouldn't prefer the alternative.
- CodeMage 9y agoOn the contrary, everyone's willingness to accept this kind of behavior as normal indicates how far the Overton window has moved when it comes to the trustworthiness of our digital services. We need a collective effort to shift things back where they belong.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jerkstate 9y agoI disagree, privacy-conscious people have been warning that Facebook has been doing these things since forever, so people (especially here on HN) can't claim that they didn't know these things were going on. This is just the same old story: people being upset about the consequences of what they were warned about many many times.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> privacy-conscious people have been warning Saying. And what was said was obviously not heard. Tangibility helps any pitch. We shouldn’t fault people for agreeing later versus sooner; at the end of the day, agreement trumps the alternative.
- _jal 9y agoI, too, wish for a better quality of collective decision-making on the part of humanity, but this seems to be how "we" do these things. "What, me worry?" is probably the central recurring theme of history, if you're inclined to look at things a certain way.
- flukus 9y agoWe also used to accept that negative reinforcement was part of this learning process, but now it's called victim blaming.
- donkeyd 9y agoI feel like you're both right though. We can't claim we didn't know, but the fact that we accept this en masse is concerning.
- chris_wot 9y agoHardly, if we cannot retract our messages from Facebook, neither should they!
- cm2187 9y agoI disagree, this shows a strong pattern of "do as I say, not as I do" in term of privacy. And this is a prime example.
- radicaldreamer 9y agoProved again and again: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16725506 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16725506
- matte_black 9y agoThing is a nothingburger. Do people really believe messages can’t be deleted no matter what?
- gaius 9y agoIt’s difficult to retract a message SMTP’d to my server then POP3 download to my desktop computer Sometimes the old protocols are the best
- supertrope 9y agoDelete buttons cut both ways. You can yank content but so can others. Of course you don't have assurance it's been truly deleted and someone could save a copy. Even before I quit it was hard to tell if the submitter wanted it gone or if it was a technical glitch, censorship, or displaced by ads. If you want to be cynical it's kind of like the memory hole in 1984. More charitably, it's not that different from broken links (except that broken links leave a trace).
- jerkstate 9y ago"the cloud is just someone else's computer"
- jamra 9y agoThe article specifies that messages older than 2014 were deleted. I read once (can't find the resource now) that Microsoft deletes all chat and email messages older than a certain date. I think the reason is legal. If ever subpoenaed, providing too much chat info could be potentially damaging. I feel like the insinuation is that something specifically nefarious is going on. They can delete private messages in their own chat program for their executives as much as they want to. I also don't understand why this is considered bad behavior or why people somehow think something nefarious had to occur for them to want to do so. It may just be standard practice at many giant corporations.
- jonathankoren 9y ago1) Users are explicitly not allowed to do this. You can delete things in your inbox, you can’t delete things in other people’s inboxes. 2) It convienely starts happenening right when FB finds themselves in a shitshow, and with a CEO that famously said, “They trust me — dumb fucks”. There is no evidence that this is anything except something very very new. 3) Document retention policies only work for your company. Not someone else’s. I have no right to go into your documents and shred things I no longer want you to have.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- alphakappa 9y agoI think it's clear from nearly a decade's worth of Facebook's trysts with privacy issues that it is a company that doesn't have a fundamental stance that's in favor of user privacy. Over and over again it has either intentionally built features that disregard privacy, or put in wrong defaults, or simply brushed off criticisms when others have misused Facebook. At this point we should be asking ourselves why we expect Facebook to change on its own. There isn't a good alternative to Facebook (given the network effect and the legitimate features that Facebook provides), but it's probably important that there be public oversight of Facebook (and any other social media company that becomes large and powerful as Facebook). We should also be asking ourselves whether an organization that has the power to be so influential in the destinies of nations should be run by executives who see every issue as a PR issue to be dealt with, rather than ones that should teach them fundamental lessons. If the leadership is so reluctant to tackle these issues head-on, maybe they need to be replaced with a humbler set of leaders.
- supertrope 9y agoI agree that FB has shown time and time again that they consider user privacy a mere road bump. Pervasive dark patterns. I disagree that specific regulatory oversight is needed. Advertising supported websites will always remain loyal to their customers: advertisers. Users are not willing to pay money and requiring a cover charge hurts adoption. What used to be called spyware is now "analytics." People proudly proclaim targeted advertising as a benefit for users. If we want privacy to be respected we need a right to privacy law. It's hard to be a sustainable business if everyone else is racing to the bottom. I'm waiting on FB's marketshare to tank.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JKCalhoun 9y ago> I disagree that specific regulatory oversight is needed. - and - > If we want privacy to be respected we need a right to privacy law. You're almost disagreeing with yourself unless you see a significant difference between regulatory oversight and privacy laws. Both reflect government authority over Facebook (etc.) to protect its citizens. Myself, I would be happy with either option. We have neither now.
- timeimp 9y ago"Do as I say and not as I do" -Facebook Privacy Policy, circa 2018
- KozmoNau7 9y agoExactly. There are rules for the rulers, and different rules for the serfs.
- saagarjha 9y ago> Zuckerberg’s profile doesn’t show a button to add him as a friend on desktop, and the button is grayed out and disabled on mobile. Of course he has special rules for himself. Fun fact: you cannot block Mark Zuckerberg on Facebook. It just won't let you.
- fowl2 9y agoEveryone can controls who can send them friend requests.
- spicyj 9y agoMost users can only set it as restrictive as "friends of friends", but if you have 10k+ followers or are verified then you can restrict it further.
- rock_hard 9y agoWhich frankly makes a lot of sense! Building products is all about finding the right balances...an engineers mind often wants to expose all possible options to users, just because they can. But I have never seen that work with users at scale...you need to curate, only give people the controls they absolutely need
- spicyj 9y ago> Fun fact: you cannot block Mark Zuckerberg on Facebook. It just won't let you. This was fixed months ago (and was a technical problem that affected anyone blocked by many thousands of people, not just him). It wasn't intended.
- feelin_googley 9y agoThe folks in Myanmar apparently have taken issue with how Zuckerberg referred to FB's "tools" and "systems" for detection of hate speech in his Vox interview. They sent him a letter: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/05/technology/zuckerberg-facebook-myanmar.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/05/technology/zuckerberg-fac...
- cornholio 9y agoBlaming Facebook for not stopping chain letters spread on messenger is disingenuous, especially in the context of the privacy debate. If you believe people have the right to private communication, there's nothing a technology company can do to fix social problems like this, you need social measures, international pressure and so on.
- ryanlol 9y agoI recently saw the name @Mat available on instagram, I registered it. Twice. Both times the name was taken from me by a Facebook employee and eventually given to this Mat Henley guy from Uber. Screenshots of Facebook staff forcefully resetting the account names: https://i.succ.in/WuwuV1IH.png https://i.succ.in/WuwuV1IH.png https://i.succ.in/WuMMtKTr.png https://i.succ.in/WuMMtKTr.png (The revert button does nothing, just offers to change your password) It seems like FB employees do not need a particularly good reason to go play around with admin tools editing user accounts. If they can edit users accounts this lightly, what does it take for them to look through you private posts or messages?
- siquick 9y agoThis needs to be made more of an issue.
- needToSay 9y agoWow, the FB workers are disgusting as Zuck and the company itself.
- exodust 9y agoYour screenshots show no evidence of "facebook staff" doing anything. Looks to me like an automated notification triggered by a username change on your account. I don't use Instagram so maybe I'm missing something, but you should have done as it said and changed your password after clicking "revert this change".
- ryanlol 9y ago>Your screenshots show no evidence of "facebook staff" doing anything. Are you suggesting that Mat Henley from Uber hacked me (or hired someone to hack me?), or that I myself gave up the name and am telling lies now? I think both of those sound tremendously unlikely. I am 100% sure that neither of these accounts were compromised. >but you should have done as it said and changed your password after clicking "revert this change". I did, that's how I found out that the button does not actually revert the change, it just takes you to a prompt which makes you reset your password.
- auchenberg 9y ago"Nothing to hide"
- feelin_googley 9y agoApparently Sandberg went on a press tour giving five or so interviews, apologising according to script in each one. But apparently she veered a bit off script in one of them, on the Today show. She said "our service depends on your data." Apparently she said something like "If they want to opt out of sharing all their data, they will have to pay for it." Source: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/sheryl-sandberg-sticks-to-script-ahead-of-zuckerbergs-testimony-before-congress/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/sheryl-sandberg-sticks-to-scrip...
- r00fus 9y agoWondering what form of payment Sandberg wants. It's not like they give us the option to pay in money.
- chx 9y agoThe problem with any regulation curtailing Facebook is it's practically guaranteed to hurt Internet freedoms. A lot.
- mirkules 9y agoThank you! I feel like I'm watching this trainwreck in slow motion by myself, as we used to inch - but now barrell - towards regulating the internet into oblivion. This is ironic, of course, because the internet is meant to be decentralized and deregulated, and the very people pushing for regulation are the same ones that oppose legislation in other aspects (e.g. encryption). It's a very short hop from wanting Facebook to comply with some law, to compelling Facebook to turn over user data to verify the law has not been broken.
- rimliu 9y agoRegulating what corporations can do with your data is a bit different than regulating internet.
- rimliu 9y agoHow? By this measure GDPR should also hurt internet, no?
- joering2 9y agoIt is, but in most part it is hurting spammers and shady ESPs :)
- feelin_googley 9y agoMike Myers (Dr Evil) thinks Zuckerberg is more hated than Donald Trump. https://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/tv-and-radio/mike-myers-resurrects-dr-evil-as-ex-trump-staffer-announces-zuckerberg-as-2020-running-mate-20180406-p4z824.html https://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/tv-and-radio/mike-myers...
- fluxsauce 9y ago> "They 'trust me.' Dumb fucks."
- kerng 9y agoThis is another example of Facebook valuing its own privacy, while at the same time continuing to disregard the privacy needs for its users. I always gave them the benefit of the doubt, but it's getting ridiculous.
- luckydata 9y agoFacebook exists for one reason only, Mark's desire to be rich. Everything else is completely opportunistic. If you see it through that lens, everything they've ever done makes complete sense.
- jasonvorhe 9y agoIf that was the case, he'd find a replacement CEO, sell his shares and be done with it. He's already rich enough to be have to lift another finger in the next 10 lifetimes.
- joering2 9y agoI made it from few thousands per month of salary to my first sell for $1MM in 2004. I thought I was rich. Then I start meeting people much richer. My last exit was with $17MM check. Guess what - I still feel I'm poor. The point being, rich people don't look down - they look higher at people who are richER or wealthy (few people in America are such as Buffet, Gates, etc). I assure you Zuck doesn't sell his stock to be rich and "done with it"; he's looking at Bezos fortune and that's where he's aiming at. Greed never stops and there is always something/someone bigger to look at. Fun fact: I know a buddy in Bezos close circles and he told me Bezos is not looking up at anyone but keeps growing like crazy NOT TO lose his position. So there you have it; always a reason to get up just another morning and make just another buck.
- lolsal 9y agoNot everyone that has money thinks this way. It's a special kind of freedom to be content with more than you need and not have wants.
- filoeleven 9y ago> Bezos is not looking up at anyone but keeps growing like crazy NOT TO lose his position And what are the consequences if he does lose his position? He still has a literally incredible amount of power. Is the drive to be at the top of the heap a necessary trait of amassing wealth? The way you write about competition amongst the rich makes it look like a pissing contest in a community pool.
- feelin_googley 9y agoSend your old comms with Zuckerberg to the FTC for safekeeping. The three sources asked to remain anonymous for fear of "angering Zuckerberg". But they still wanted to share their story with TC.
- HenryBemis 9y agoWatch "The Circle"!! It is the famous moment when Tom Hanks says "oh we are so ....ed". And Tom Hanks can deliver a line! Secrets are Lies, but their secrets are better than your secrets. I am surprised that FB still hasn't lost 30% of their users by now.
- exodust 9y agoAfter 20 minutes I couldn't stand it any longer. Bad movie.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jamescyber 9y agoafter facebook now exposed truth off After a broadened activity of more than 10 months, these programmers have gotten to the private data of the apparent ISIS sympathizers that incorporates the photograph, name, email ID,MAC address etc. Kislay Chaudhary, cyber security expert and chairman of Indian Cyber Army said Despite having concrete information about the ISIS sympathizers or other terror supporters, the government or the intelligence agencies do not pay a heed to it. Instead of conducting a primary investigation, the motive and patriotism of the hackers are questioned, Full news :- Kislay Chaudhary Ft. in India today on Exposed Nasty Truth About ISIS Supporters. https://www.ica.in/newsroom/indian-cyber-army-in-india-today-on-exposed-nasty-truth-about-isis-supporters https://www.ica.in/newsroom/indian-cyber-army-in-india-today...
- thrillgore 9y agoThe continuing saga of people's realizations that raccoons have been digging through the collated data of 2 billion "dumb fucks" as Zuckerberg would call them.
- throw2016 9y agoThe basic endpoint of Facebook and Google whatever their stated objectives is to build detailed long term profiles of every individual, like the stasi or any totalitarian state. This appetite for user data is so great simply tracking location and content across devices is not enough. Here is Facebook trying to do deals with hospitals to access all their patient data [1] It's easy to see where this goes and how encompassing it becomes. People in the ad ecosystem will hand wave, diminish and deny but that's just self interest. For wider society the effect is sinister. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/05/facebook-building-8-explored-data-sharing-agreement-with-hospitals.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/05/facebook-building-8-explored...
- mtnygard 9y agoThis seems like FB expects to get hit with a discovery process and injunction against deleting anything. It's housecleaning before they're forced to open the curtains.
- zcytrewq 9y agoFacebook should be banned and closed. They lied and violated every aspect of user data privacy.
- esturk 9y agoI now wonder whether it's worth it to join Facebook just to delete my personal data and just quit afterwards? I wouldnt even ashamed to admit this in future interviews.
- charlotte112 9y agoThis will definitely help you out . If you got any problem that would require the services of a professional hacker and you don't know who to contact, I know just the right person for you.Get in touch with ENRIQUEHACKDEMON11@GMAIL.COM and let him know what you want to hire him for, his services includes Phone Hacking, Tracking, Spying, Cloning.He can also load a bank account and sell logs to do stuffs like Retrieving of deleted text, pictures and videos, Upgrading results. Adding your name to guest invitation list, Provision of information and evidence.. . he is one of the best underground hackers.He is also very efficient and trustworthy. he will do a pretty nice job for you. You can also reach him through Whatsapp messenger +1 628 203 7005 ,you can also call or text me on +14099993477,…. best of luck.