4 ms·
I don't think it's money laundering as much as money stashing. A lot of this money is flowing in from areas where the banks are unreliable, personally owning r
by munk-a 9y ago
I don't think it's money laundering as much as money stashing. A lot of this money is flowing in from areas where the banks are unreliable, personally owning real estate is not certain (there are a preponderance of eminent domain seizures) and your control of your in-country assets is subject to the government's opinion of you.
I don't think this is laundering as much as finding a mattress to hide it under that pays back a bit on your investment. So that if you lose everything you can liquidate your hidden little pockets of real estate and maybe make a bit of cash while fleeing to where ever.
- charlesdm 9y agoPretty much this. It's also the reason why I believe cryptocurrencies will continue to do well in the coming years -- there's a need for a state independent store of wealth.
- dazc 9y agoThe advantage of property being it will always be worth something.
- roywiggins 9y ago> it will always be worth something Assuming a sufficiently friendly state apparatus that enforces the ordinary claims of ownership. If that goes away, or is turned against you, it's not yours anymore. With stuff like real estate, you can't exactly smuggle it out of the country. (This is what the Global Magnitsky Act and international equivalents are meant to do- having your personal assets frozen by the US or UK government suddenly makes your frozen assets somewhat less valuable to you...)
- charlesdm 9y agoSure, if it doesn't end up being confiscated.
- jonknee 9y agoIt's much easier for a state to seize your cryptocurrency key than foreign real estate. There's a whole system of law protecting your NYC penthouse, but a couple of goons and a hammer can take all your BTC (without any way to reverse it!).
- charlesdm 9y agoThe penthouse, yes. But not the shares of your offshore shell corporation owning the property, which can easily be transferred through a simple share purchase agreement..
- gambiting 9y agoThe whole point of doing this is that no one knows you own property in London. If you keep 130 million dollars worth of bitcoin in your wallet literally anyone can see it.
- pjc50 9y agoIndeed. In some ways what the UK is exporting is rule-of-law, a functioning courts system and a government that for good or ill is extremely reluctant to interfere with real estate ownership, even if it's been bought with suspect money. The existence of a safe offshore cash stash is a benefit to some autocrats and a risk to others - it allows their underlings to escape.
- elipsey 9y agoThe complaint is against anonymous ownership, not foreign ownership. I didn't notice any statement in the article opposing foreign ownership in general. Cameron states "We need to stop corrupt officials or organised criminals using anonymous shell companies." Why does ownership need to be anonymous to perform the function you describe if not to conceal obvious money laundering? It is specualated in the article that the real owners are civil servants with billions in wealth that is inexplicable absent corruption.
- dsacco 9y agoTo play devil’s advocate: if your faith in your government is such that you’d like to allocate your wealth in another country, you may also be motivated to hide that wealth for reasons that have nothing to do with corruption. There can be reasons for discretion and anonymity other than money laundering.
- elipsey 9y agoThis is a good point, and easy to imagine a situation where a foreign citizen might fear retaliation from various bad actors were it know that they were exfiltrating assets to other countries. I think the question should be whether this is remotely as common as laundering. It seems implausible to me that a considerable number of people other than the elite and corrupt use anonymous foreign shell corporations to protect their safety and legitimately acquired property. I think addressing this kind of corruption is an international cooperation problem and, in utilitarian terms, the people who are harmed by financial corruption stand to gain more by solving it than the people who profit from that kind of anonymity. I’m certainly willing to be convinced by evidence that a considerable number of foreign citizens need to own shell corporations in my country simply to protect their liberty and property, but I find that pretty far fetched.
- spoonie 9y agoSo let them stash it in a bank account or the stock market (both places where it will do more good for the economy). Houses and land are special and scarce, and shouldn’t be subject to the same rules as other financial assets.