4 ms·
Anyone who want's some insight/context into India's economic regulatory environment from which these controls came from should watch this (2 part) video: https
by dmix 9y ago
Anyone who want's some insight/context into India's economic regulatory environment from which these controls came from should watch this (2 part) video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hVwIZzGHxwc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hVwIZzGHxwc
There's a crazy amount of regulation and paperwork for even the most benign business. And much of it differs as you go between the different areas, so businesses that have to say transport goods from Mumbai to New Delhi may have to stop 4-5 times to fill out each regions regulatory paperwork.
It's really not surprising to such a top-heavy state being wary of something which seems like it can't be as easily controlled top-down. Which we saw with the "banning" of those paper bills - which had a significant negative impact on the economy, as much of the economy manages to function in spite of those rules, large by side stepping them.
India will never catch up to China's growth unless they clean up this mess. And even beyond growth, it benefits no one to have so many businesses feel the need to completely bypass all the rules because they are so bad ones in between the good.
- hangonhn 9y ago"It's really not surprising to such a top-heavy state being wary of something which seems like it can't be as easily controlled top-down" I don't disagree with your analysis but I think the conclusion is debatable. The problem isn't India is top-heavy, China is too. The difference is that China is highly centralized. It's been that way since the Qin dynasty. The Qin dynasty standardized everything from weights, measures, and even the language itself. The example you cited is a problem of standardization. If all the paper work is the same, the process should be pretty simple and efficient. That said, India is a VERY diverse country and seems very tolerant of differences. Part of this may be because India was not historically centralized nor homogenized. Just as a personal opinion, it would be a shame for India to lose its cultural diversity in its pursue of growth and efficiency. Once you lose the culture, it's really, really hard to bring back.
- newyankee 9y agoTrue, but taxes like GST are really trying to make all this easy. Change comes slowly in India and off late there have been some changes that were once thought impossible to implement (like GST)
- Karishma123 9y agoIndian here. India's regulation love is mind-boggling and matched only by Venezuella or North Korea. Only difference being that people beat the system no matter what. My family decided to start a fully self-funded private school in 2004. Here are the steps. 1. First we need to get NOC from the local government which we will get only if we show the land, building etc. Most important factor in NOC is "need". So we need to show paperwork that there are not enough schools nearby for the projection of new students over 10 years and all that. Clearly, you can't argue that "my school would be better". (We paid $10k as bribe to get this) 2. There is lot of regulation related to teacher's salaries and qualification, teacher-student ratio etc. Fee regulation etc. but relatively easier to get with very less bribe. 3. Right to Education Law (RTE) kicks in. We have to do tremendous amount of paper work and give 25% of our seats to government for free which the government allocates based on complex lottery that uses caste/income etc. Given that our school caters to lower middle class a plumbers kid is paying to subsidise education of electrician's son because the former did not win the RTE lottery. We have to increase fees of remaining 75% students to cover the expenditure on these 25%. The government promised a small money per seat by law. However for last 4 years we have not got a penny. The amount is any ways very little. But then RTE has various other provisions and the violation of that results into withdrawal of NOC, closure of school and criminal proceeding against the principal/management. Here are some of the provisions: - There should be X toilets per 100 students. - You can not dismiss any student for any reason. (not just 25% RTE students but all 100% students) - You can not set any admission criteria what so ever. No tests, interviews, family background nothing. Pure lottery only. (For the 75% students) Most parents know this and will simply refuse to pay fees after we give admission to their kids. All we can do is to beg. 4. There is 100% exemption to any school that is run by management whose members are Christians, Muslims, Buddhists, Jain or Sikh. (which means RTE applies to your school only if the management is Hindu or Jewish) 5. RTE resulted into closure of thousands of schools in India and mushrooming of Church run schools. My family closed the school in 2016. There are various court cases still going around this.
- AareyBaba 9y agoRe 4: Article 30 in The Constitution Of India 1949 30. Right of minorities to establish and administer educational institutions (1) All minorities, whether based on religion or language, shall have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. This was put in the constitution as a guarantee to linguistic and religious minorities that they could maintain their identity within the vast majority. This was in liu of the more unpalatable option of providing special representation in Parliament for each minority group. In subsequent years after independence the Supreme Court clarified that the minority status would be determined by state. So presumably, you could set up a school in Mizoram if you are a Hindu. Or a Hindi language school in Tamil Nadu. If I am not mistaken, Sindhis run their own colleges in Mumbai under these minority rights.
- shripadk 9y ago> And much of it differs as you go between the different areas, so businesses that have to say transport goods from Mumbai to New Delhi may have to stop 4-5 times to fill out each regions regulatory paperwork. This is no longer true. With implementation of E-way Bill under GST you need not stop anymore. A single e-way bill is enough. Also those stops were needed earlier because there was no uniform taxation between states. However with implementation of GST there is no need to fill up paperwork while transporting goods between states. Just need to procure an e-way bill. This came into effect from April 1st 2018. Changes are happening rapidly so take these old videos with a grain of salt. Read more about e-way bills here: https://www.livemint.com/Politics/ZHOXrBEfe2TR5ALJJFZGoI/All-you-need-to-know-about-the-GST-eway-bill-system.html https://www.livemint.com/Politics/ZHOXrBEfe2TR5ALJJFZGoI/All... Quoting: "To avoid technological glitches, the GSTN and the National Informatics Centre have ramped up the infrastructure. The system can now handle 75 lakh e-way bills daily, compared with 26 lakh earlier. To prevent harassment of taxpayers, e-way bill rules specify that goods will be inspected only once during the journey except in cases where specific information on tax evasion is received. Further, in case a vehicle is detained for more than 30 minutes, the transporter can report it on the portal."
- walshemj 9y agoThat's sounds a lot like the problems France had prior to the revolution internal trade had to go though lots of little local barriers.
- amrx101 9y agoAnd mostly these regulations are used by more established aka politician & bureaucrat bribing companies and conglomerates to kill competition in the market. In India regulations are not for consumer rights protection but for highest bidder so that regulatory mechanism can be unleashed with full wrath on the competitor. In his book the former head of central bank wrote that in the Indian state of Madhya Pradesh no one could set up any industry in mining if there were not part of the Jindal group. No entrepreneur or businessmen would get license from the state government if they were not part of the Jindal group. The Jindal group would in turn pay the politicians and bureaucrats in money and sex. Thank god that Soviet Union failed and global economic conditions with that forced India to become more market friendly. But these regulations are still there.