2 ms·
The problem is that point is inherently subjective and gives a veto to the least-rational, most-emotional people. Allegations that certain speech is 'harassing'
by gojomo 16y ago
The problem is that point is inherently subjective and gives a veto to the least-rational, most-emotional people. Allegations that certain speech is 'harassing' or 'hate speech' can be made strategically to censor disfavored speech. Such policies can even provide an incentive for violence, as a means of proving certain speech should be squelched. ("You said something that made me throw this rock, so you should shut up. And I'll keep throwing rocks until I've shown exactly how dangerous your speech is.")
Unless speech contains a credible threat of violence, speech is not itself 'violent'. No reasonable, law-abiding person should see/hear any speech and be thrown into a violent rage. (If they do, they're the person breaching civilized norms deserving punishment -- not the original speaker.)
I understand the business reasons for caving to any sufficiently-large angry mob with grievances. But if more businesses said they didn't censor otherwise legal speech because of emotion of the part of third parties, as a matter of non-discriminatory policy, then it'd be easier for all similar businesses to adhere to the same principle.
- zeteo 16y ago"I understand the business reasons for caving to any sufficiently-large angry mob with grievances" Yup. A DDoS attack was almost certainly going their way, and perhaps physical threats as well.
- MichaelSalib 16y agoIs there any evidence to support this contention? Or is this complete speculation based on absolutely no evidence whatsoever?
- drusenko 16y agoAgreed. DDoS attacks (in our experience) do not originate from the religious right.
- Natsu 16y ago> Allegations that certain speech is 'harassing' or 'hate speech' can be made strategically to censor disfavored speech. Legally, some judges are wary of this. They call this the "heckler's veto."
- natep 16y ago> creates a risk to a person's safety or health, creates a risk to public safety or health, compromises national security or interferes with a investigation by law enforcement; I'd say this criterion is clearly met in this case. When you have a general, secretary of state, and President of the United States all saying that this would cause national security issues, and put American troops in more danger, I think it's safe to say that Rackspace isn't really making a subjective decision any more. So to you and everyone else who seems to be saying "Oh no, what if they stop hosting my site!?!": don't piss off the POTUS (and even then, you'll get a warning first).