3 ms·
>> I want to ask: why is Tesla's advanced suite of cameras and ultrasonic sensors unable to detect a big, yellow and black stationary barrier? The answer to th
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> I want to ask: why is Tesla's advanced suite of cameras and ultrasonic sensors unable to detect a big, yellow and black stationary barrier?
The answer to that is that sensors detect, but don't make decisions. The decisions are made by the car AI that takes input from the censors and outputs control signals.
So the pertinent answer is "why is Tesla's AI unable to make the decisions necessary to avoid a big, yellow and black stationary barrier?".
Unfortunately, nobody can answer that, including Tesla engineers, because their cars' AI is trained with black-box machine learning algorithms that are extremely resistant to any attempt to understand how they make decisions.
But, you know. I'm pretty sure they're really safe /s
- danso 9y agoTesla's sensors are also claimed to detect/read, but not recognize or react to imagery of stop signs and traffic lights: https://forums.tesla.com/forum/forums/autopilot-handling-stop-signs-and-traffic-signals https://forums.tesla.com/forum/forums/autopilot-handling-sto...
- protomyth 9y ago> Unfortunately, nobody can answer that, including Tesla engineers, because their cars' AI is trained with black-box machine learning algorithms that are extremely resistant to any attempt to understand how they make decisions. What is the justification for allowing anything we don't understand to be on the road? I really want the NTSB to ask specifically what decisions the Tesla was making and not accept "black box learning" as an answer.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> What is the justification for allowing anything we don't understand to be on the road? What's the justification for allowing human brains in the control loop?
- protomyth 9y agoBecause we have a right to travel in most countries and cars are the mechanism that we use and we can be held responsible for our actions. This black box AI has none of those attributes.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoBecause human brains can tell a human from the side of a barn?