3 ms·
I know that these round-up programs are quite popular -- but it reflects a sloppy-with-money mindset I just don't have. Let's say you're a super-heavy card use
by gojomo 16y ago
I know that these round-up programs are quite popular -- but it reflects a sloppy-with-money mindset I just don't have.
Let's say you're a super-heavy card user -- 5 times a day. And charges are random in the cents value -- so on average a charge yields a $0.50 allocation.
Why not just donate (30 days * 5 transactions/day * $0.50/transaction =) $75/month to your chosen purposes (be they personal savings as with BoFA or a charity as here)?
Sure, you cold use transaction volume as an initial indicator of ability-to-pay or a socially-normed anchor-value. But, there really ought to be more consideration of personal circumstances than that. (What's your overall savings/debt? What are your other obligations?) And, this only requires an occasional look-back at prior volume to set a benchmark level -- not a constant function of every transaction.
Sure, putting allocations on autopilot improves compliance to a stated plan... but that can be done without the 'round-up' transaction gimmick. (Lots of systems for auto-charging donations or savings on weekly/monthly/paycheckly/etc. schedules already exist.)
And why $0.50 per transaction? If trying to achieve an optimal savings rate, it's unlikely that's the right ratio for anyone.
- jerf 16y ago"but it reflects a sloppy-with-money mindset I just don't have." It redirects the sloppy-with-money behavior into something that benefits you instead of harming you. A surprising amount of self-control ultimately boils down to that, differing only in the exact level on which they are applied. It is way easier to fool your bad habits or false ideations than actually eradicate them, and you've only got so much self-control to spend, as recent psychology research is demonstrating.