6 ms·
> 1. Ethical. One thing is that you do a stupid thing and die. Another is that a technology fails in trivial circumstances that in theory are avoidable. A docto
by ajross 9y ago
> 1. Ethical. One thing is that you do a stupid thing and die. Another is that a technology fails in trivial circumstances that in theory are avoidable. A doctor can make also errors, but a medical device is required to be very safe and reliable in what it does.
This needs elaboration or citation. You're one of the only folks I've seen come straight out and make this point: that somehow a technology or practice that is objectively safer can still be "unethically safe" and should be shunned in favor of less safe stuff.
I don't buy it. This isn't individual action here, there's no utilitarian philosophy rejection that's going to help you.
In fact, medical devices seem actually counter to your argument. No one says an automatic defibrillator's decisions as to when to fire are going to be as good as a human doctor, and in fact these things have non-zero (often fatal) false positive rates. But they save lives, so we use them anyway.
Bottom line, that point just doesn't work.
- Ajedi32 9y agoI think the point he's making is that it's worse if a person dies because of something they have no control over (self-driving car malfunction) than if a person dies because of their own stupid choices (driving drunk, driving too fast for conditions, running red lights, etc). This, of course, ignores the fact that stupid choices drivers make tend to affect other people on the road who did nothing wrong, so the introduction of a self-driving car which makes less stupid decisions would reduce deaths from both categories of people here.
- matte_black 9y agoNo, that conclusion completely ignores the fact that the kind of people who buy Teslas are generally not the kind of people who drive unsafely anyway and die in terrible wrecks. If you give every shitty driver a self driving Tesla maybe you would do something to make roads safer, but if you’re just giving it to higher net worth individuals who place greater value on their own life, you haven’t even made a dent in traffic safety. In fact in some cases all you’re doing is making drivers unsafer because the autopilot encourages them to not pay attention to the road no matter how much you think they are watching carefully. The men killed in Teslas could have all avoided their deaths if only they had been paying attention. If I see a Tesla on the road I stay the hell away lest it do something irrational from an error and kill us both.
- rileymat2 9y agoIs there evidence for your better driver claim? https://wheels.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/08/12/the-rich-drive-differently-a-study-suggests/ https://wheels.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/08/12/the-rich-drive-d... I do see some sources that claim rich divers get better insurance rates, but it is unclear to me if that is due to driving skill or a number of other factors that increase rates like liklyhood of being stolen or miles driven.
- ajross 9y agoSeems like your first two paragraphs are amenable to analysis. Surely there is data out there that splits traffic accident statistics on income, or some proxy for income. Is a Tesla on autopilot more accident-prone than a BMW or Lexus? The numbers as they stand certainly seem to imply "no", but I'd be willing to read a paper. The third paragraph though is just you flinging opinion around. You assert without evidence that a Tesla is likely to "do something irrational from an error and kill us both" (has any such crash even happened? Seems like Tesla's are great at avoiding other vehicles and where they fall down it tends to be in recognizing static/slow things like medians, bikers and turning semis and not turning to avoid them). I mean, sure. You be you and "stay the hell away" from Teslas. But that doesn't really have much bearing on public policy.
- matte_black 9y agoDrunk drivers, recklessly fast drivers, redlight runners, stop sign blowers, high speed tailgaters... those are the demographic you have to compare the Tesla drivers to. Do people who buy Teslas engage in those kinds of dangerous activities?
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoThere was a recent news item about a Tesla driver who fell asleep at the wheel and who was allegedly over the legal limit: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=tesla+driver+drunk+asleep&t=ffsb&atb=v100-7&ia=videos https://duckduckgo.com/?q=tesla+driver+drunk+asleep&t=ffsb&a...
- 9y ago
- stale2002 9y ago> I think the point he's making is that it's worse if a person dies because of something they have no control over Perhaps. I reject this argument though. A death is a death. And if you prevent lifesaving technology then you are responsible for a whole lot of deaths, irregardless of how "deserved" those deaths are.
- ksk 9y ago>Perhaps. I reject this argument though. A death is a death. A death caused by shitty engineering (e.g. Tesla in this case) is not the same as a death caused by gross negligence on ones own part. >And if you prevent lifesaving technology then you are responsible for a whole lot of deaths, irregardless of how "deserved" those deaths are. How many deaths has Tesla prevented, which would have happened otherwise?
- AliShug 9y ago> How many deaths has Tesla prevented, which would have happened otherwise? Certainly a larger number than the number of deaths caused by Autopilot failure (which makes major news in every individual case). Have a look at YouTube for videos of Teslas automatically avoiding crashes.
- ksk 9y agoI don't see a number.
- mike10010100 9y ago> A death caused by shitty engineering (e.g. Tesla in this case) is not the same as a death caused by gross negligence on ones own part. The result is the same, no? Isn't the idea to save lives? Why does one life have more value than another's simply because someone's death was caused by their own negligence? What about the other people on the road? Do their lives matter less because of the gross negligence of the person not paying attention while they're driving? This issue is a lot more complicated than you're making it seem.
- bendauphinee 9y ago> because of something they have no control over Expect in this case, the driver has 100% control.
- macawfish 9y agoThe driver's not the only one on the road.
- chillingeffect 9y agoThe key here is that in the larger system, we can do more to ensure humans perform better. If we encouraged and enforced behaviors that improve driving statistics, perhaps with other technologies, we would yield a more difficult metric to beat than our current driving stats. I agree we should spend our time doing that, rather than accepting in an inferior level of performance.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoEthics works by consensus. If the majority of the public become convinced that they prefer to die as a result of their choices than as a result of the choices of a machine they have no control over, even if the machine kills less often, then the machine is not an ethical choice anymore. Basically, forcing people to die in one specific way stinks to high heaven. As to why we use certain technologies, that is not so clear cut either. For instance, if I have a heart attack and someone uses a defibrilator on me- at that time, that is not necessarily my choice. I'm incapacitated and can't communicate and if I die at the end there's no way to know what I would have chosen. Not to mention- most people are not anywhere nearly informed enough to decide what technology should be used to save or protect their lives (for instance, that's why we have vaccine deniers etc).
- stale2002 9y ago> Basically, forcing people to die in one specific way stinks to high heaven Then these people should stop trying to force me to accept a less safe method of transportation, by preventing me from using new technology! Yeah, those people shouldn't be forced to use a self driving care. As they are ALREADY not being forced to do. Nobody is being forced to use the technology. Just don't use it if you don't like it. It is literally the opposite. These other people are forcing ME into a more dangerous situation.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoOk, you take the red tape away from silencers and short barreled rifles and I'll take it away from your self driving cars. I'm all for less red tape.
- ericd 9y agoMight help to give the context that suppressors can save target shooters' hearing.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoThe technology is not yet safe, as should be evident by now. It's being promoted as safer than humans, but it's not anywhere near that, yet, mainly because to drive safely you need at least human-level intelligence. Even though humans also drive unsafely, they have the ability to drive very, very safely indeed under diverse conditions that no self-driving car can tackle with anything approaching the same degree of situational awareness and therefore, again, safety. For the record, that's my objection to the technology: that it's not yet where the industry says it is and it risks causing a lot more harm than good. Another point. You say nobody is being forced to use the technology. Not exactly; once people start riding self-driving cars then everyone is at risk- anyone can be run over by a self-driving car, anyone can be in an accident caused by someone else's self-driving car, etc. So it's a bit like a smoker saying nobody is forced to smoke- yeah, but if you smoke next to me I'm forced to breathe in your smoke.
- debt 9y agoIt is definitely much safer. However it's unethical to gloss over/coverup/play down the fact that people have died because it failed to drive to car. Both can be true.
- imh 9y ago>You're one of the only folks I've seen come straight out and make this point: that somehow a technology or practice that is objectively safer can still be "unethically safe" There are plenty of people making that case. See for example this piece in The Atlantic the other day (https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/03/got-99-problems-but-a-trolley-aint-one/556805/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/03/got-9...) talking about the concept of moral luck in the context of self driving cars. It puts the point eloquently.
- ksk 9y ago>In fact, medical devices seem actually counter to your argument. No one says an automatic defibrillator's decisions as to when to fire are going to be as good as a human doctor, and in fact these things have non-zero (often fatal) false positive rates. But they save lives, so we use them anyway. Yes, we would also tolerate Teslas if they were critical life support technology. How many lives has it saved BTW? >and in fact these things have non-zero (often fatal) false positive rate What is non zero? Ten to the power -20?