3 ms·
I think it's a horrible idea to burn Korans, but this is certainly not the answer. This is effectively just another form of violence, that's not the way to elev
by InclinedPlane 16y ago
I think it's a horrible idea to burn Korans, but this is certainly not the answer. This is effectively just another form of violence, that's not the way to elevate a debate.
- earl 16y agoRefusing to host a website is a form of violence? What?
- InclinedPlane 16y agoNo, removing hosting of a website is though. Imagine a comparable scenario: an independent newspaper is renting a printing press, they aren't behind on rent but the provider decides they don't like what the paper is printing so they repossess the printing press. That's definitely a form of violence, even if it isn't physical violence (in the same manner that publicly burning another religion's holy text is a form of violence).
- scott_s 16y agoI think using the word violence to describe those actions dilutes its meaning. edit: I disagree with the parent's point, but the post is civil and is a valid part of the discussion. Please do not downvote it because you disagree with it.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoI think burning Korans, or burning crosses, or burning any books certainly classify as violent acts. I doubt many people would argue otherwise. By the same token, removing an organization's website hosting is also a violent act, though of a different and certainly less serious sort. If Rackspace (or whomever) yanked EFF's website from the web I suspect a lot of people would implicitly appreciate the violence inherent in that event. I'm not trying to defend these scumbags, they are scumbags and what they are doing is wrong. But Rackspace is also in the wrong (though on a much different plane). The way to deal with assholes shouting hate on the street corner is not to kick the soap box out from under them and smash it with an axe. It may be satisfying, but it's ultimately unproductive.
- scott_s 16y agoI only used the word "violence" when it involves physical harm. I find words are most useful when they have narrow meaning (http://lesswrong.com/lw/ic/the_virtue_of_narrowness/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/ic/the_virtue_of_narrowness/). Regarding your second point, also note that I am not advocating making their speech illegal. What I'm recognizing is that others might not want to be associated with it, or enable it in any way. If, for example, I had a venue of some kind, and I was approached by Neo-Nazis to hold a rally, I'd refuse. I can't maintain that position while also faulting Rackspace.
- maxharris 16y agoWhat is your definition of violence? My dictionary (Dictionary.app) says "behavior involving physical force intended to hurt, damage, or kill someone or something." Specifically, how is Rackspace using physical force against anyone?
- InclinedPlane 16y agoPerhaps you should consult the additional definitions of violence: http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/violence http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/violence In this case Rackspace's cessation of hosting services very much seems to be an injury against this church, even if it is not an injury to any person's physical bodies.
- maxharris 16y agoOK. But all I'm concerned with here is whether or not [persons at] Rackspace violated the rights of the [members of the] church. To determine this, we need to establish if one party initiated force or fraud against another, and if so, which one did so first. I don't think anyone's rights were violated here.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoNobody's rights were violated, that's irrelevant. I'm just saying I'm not so sure this was a good idea. Acting within the law is not synonymous with doing the right thing.
- maxharris 16y ago> Nobody's rights were violated, that's irrelevant. It is relevant because you used the word "violence", which implies a violation of rights in the context we are talking about. > Acting within the law is not synonymous with doing the right thing. True.
- sigzero 16y agoIf you read Rackspace's terms of service there is a "incites violence" blurb that allows them to take site offline.