18 ms·
Portland Anarchist Road Care Fixes Potholes Anonymously (2017)
- josefresco 9y agoNot that it matters really, but I thought I heard this story quite a while ago, and in fact this article was published: MAR 15, 2017 "They also run the risk of being held personally liable if someone were to be injured by the pothole they attempted to fix" This makes me uncomfortable - are municipalities held accountable for injuries caused by a pothole? Are they held liable for injuries caused by a fixed pothole?
- bovermyer 9y agoThat depends on the municipality, I think.
- thelastidiot 9y agoI replied at the same time with the same concern. Shouldn't the municipalities be more concerned about injuries potholes can cause vs. the injuries one could potentially suffer from fixing them?
- uptown 9y ago"are municipalities held accountable for injuries caused by a pothole?" I know some municipalities will pay claims for tire/wheel damage caused by roads in disrepair if you file a claim with evidence. Presumably this same admission of liability could be upheld by courts if injuries had resulted from a problem like this.
- thelastidiot 9y ago“It’s not safe or legal for people to fill potholes on streets that are maintained by the city,” says Rivera. “They run the risk of being injured in a traffic crash.... They also run the risk of being held personally liable if someone were to be injured by the pothole they attempted to fix.” Not legal? Everything starts being illegal when it's an embarrassment for the governement. As in capitalism's paralyzie? Let these guys decide if they want to run the risk to be injured.
- pitaj 9y agoI don't know what you mean by "capitalism's paralyzie" but yeah, it seems like things similar to this should be covered by Good Samaritan laws.
- greggeter 9y agoImagine if we started allowing "competent, trained software developers" to make patches in Unix without QC. I guess that would be ok -- as long as the good Samaritan developers decided they wanted to take on the risk themselves...
- Spooky23 9y agoWe could use these guys in our city. Power to the people. The city’s approach is “see no evil” until you submit a see click fix ticket. But you need to submit them for individual holes. My street looks like a lunar landscape, but the crew will show up and fix the single hole pictured in the ticket.
- IAmEveryone 9y agoI believe their point is that you should be that person for your city, not them... In any case: fixing potholes is just about the least inefficient government service possible: it's a guy/gal making $x per hour, plus some extremely commoditised materials. Meaning: it's extremely hard for anybody to screw this up. If your city isn't fixing potholes to your liking, it is almost guaranteed to be the result of a general lack of funds. With the perennial bogeyman of "wasteful spending", governments in the US have simply been starved of resources. The behaviour you're describing makes perfect sense in this situation: moving on to the next pothole that someone complained about is simple prioritisation, even if it's slightly less efficient long-term to drive a block or two for every pothole instead of fixing a whole street at once.
- jessaustin 9y agoIf your city isn't fixing potholes to your liking, it is almost guaranteed to be the result of a general lack of funds. Have you ever lived in a city? I cannot reconcile this proposition with my understanding of any municipal situation I have ever seen. Cities certainly have enough money to patch potholes. They already have a compactor and a dump truck, and asphalt is cheap. If any city is not fixing potholes, it is a question of priorities. There is probably some byzantine explanation of e.g. why potholes on this street are fixed while those on some other are not, but that can't be simplified to "we don't have enough money".
- Spooky23 9y agoThat’s why I’d like some anarchist pothole fillers. The act of filling a whole with tarred stone is trivial, managing a municipal government so that the guy is filling a hole instead of doing something less productive (like driving a truck around looking for leaf bags in February, for example) is filling holes is not.
- bovermyer 9y agoIgnoring the safety of the people doing the fixing for a moment, how do we know that these potholes have been fixed in a way that'll last a long time and be safe? If I want to know the method and materials used, where do I go to find that out?
- thelastidiot 9y agoI destroyed my tire on a pothole last year and I had to change the entire wheel. I doubt a "fixed" pothole can be more damaging than an unfixed one.
- ceejayoz 9y agoIt's possible that an incorrectly fixed pothole would a) degrade far more quickly and b) do so in a manner that expands the pothole more than just leaving it alone would have.
- throwawayjava 9y agoRight. It's not so much about the pothole today, as much as it is the health of the entire road over the next decade+. That said, addressing this and other concerns isn't rocket science. The city could easily publish a detailed guide to filling potholes (what materials are ok, what materials are not, what process to use, etc).
- donarb 9y agoPublishing a guide to filling in potholes seems like it would create controversy with the public, who would ask why it appears the city expects citizens to fill in potholes themselves. It's much easier to just allow citizens to call a number and report a pothole. Seattle does that and potholes get filled fairly quickly, they even have a phone app that allows you to report all kinds of problems. Here's Seattle's pothole map showing where and when they have been fixed. http://web6.seattle.gov/sdot/potholemap/ http://web6.seattle.gov/sdot/potholemap/
- EarthIsHome 9y ago> “We don’t think the city should exist; we are only limited by our capacity and our imaginations,” says PARC. Cities are the most efficient way we've discovered to live as humans. They're less wasteful, they consolidate resources, etc. > “Don’t get us wrong, we believe that many of these services are crucial for society, like healthcare, education, and maintained roadways, but we believe that the way to achieve access for all is by deconstructing the state and capitalism, as well as other coercive hierarchies that exist in our society. It is this driving philosophy that motivates our actions, not only to fix the potholes, but to take power back from the state, into the hands of the people.” Centralization and urban living were invented thousands of years ago and has made these services possible and more efficient over time.
- azernik 9y agoIn context, they clearly are referring to the municipal government when they say the city shouldn't exist, not to the physical collection of people and infrastructure.
- EarthIsHome 9y agoAll the services they say they want are provided by the municipal government. How are they going to provide all the services of the government without the government?
- thechao 9y agoAll the anarchists I’ve met think citizens will spontaneously combust^W form committees, chosen by their peers using the Australian method, and those committees will cause work to happen by raising funds from interested peers. Like Mad Max, but with smiles.
- logfromblammo 9y agoCommittees in anarchism are more like the PTA, band boosters, rotary club, or your HOA--everything that has no statutory authority, and no power to tax. They form whenever someone thinks it might be even worse to not have one, everyone hates attending the meetings, and they are almost entirely dependent on one to five people devoting too much of their own energy to holding it all together. There might be a contract in place, and it might mandate that dues be paid. In lieu of mandatory dues, they will always be strapped for cash and either begging for donations or coming up with annoying fundraiser ideas. They might fork, and one or both parts of the fork will fail, because some of the critical support went to the other part of the fork. And some of them will actually be more like organized crime families or street gangs than the PTA. In other words, anarchy is happening right now, and you can see how it works right now. A bunch of crazies devoted to renegade pothole repair is a perfect example. They come together because of potholes. They fix potholes. People pay attention to them as long as they care about potholes. When the pothole problem is fixed, everyone forgets they ever existed, then stop paying attention and giving money. They either drift away to find something else to do, or become the lonely, ignored crusaders against potholes that people remember hearing about that one time, but had no idea they were still around and still fixing potholes. It doesn't scale, though. Anarchy can only exist at the local level because governments tackle many of the big problems and force people to pay for the solutions with taxes. Imagine if your city government operated like the mafia (Chicago!), or if your state government operated like a giant PTA meeting. It might get as far as agreeing to set a budget of $500 for the spring graduation party before removing someone from the gallery for shouting about invading foreign armies, and would still be answering stupid questions about the dress code for service dogs when the soldiers started dragging everyone out. Mr. Humungus (a reasonable feller) is president of the Juicetakers Committee, Toecutter vice president, Feral Kid as secretary, Gyropilot as treasurer, and someone that looks exactly like your Mom covered in warpaint as the member-at-large. The president has advanced a proposal that you just walk away and give us your juice. We took a vote, and it passed unanimously. We are also selling cookie dough as part of our fall fundraiser. So give us the juice, and please buy some cookies on your way out into the desert. I'd prefer it if they were shooting guns at me.
- aeruder 9y ago> They also run the risk of being held personally liable if someone were to be injured by the pothole they attempted to fix. Are they suggesting that the city can be held liable when a pothole they _haven't_ fixed jacks up my car or its tires? I've not really heard of that working in practice. From Portland's own website [0]: > Most pothole claims are not paid. Yea, figures - I think I'll take my chances with the anarchist-repaired potholes. [0] https://www.portlandoregon.gov/bibs/article/629953 https://www.portlandoregon.gov/bibs/article/629953
- IAmEveryone 9y agoIt's simply "you touch it, you (might) own it". The same principle applies, for example, to first aid, which is why "Good Samaritan" laws exist shielding you from liability. I generally sympathise with your point of view, because I really don't know how you can actually make a pothole worse by attempting to fix it. But if someone can make such a case ("they fixed it with road-coloured cardboard paper and I didn't see the hole below"), then yeah, they are liable. The city is just giving advice in this case. If someone where to harmed by one of these fixed potholes, the lawsuit would be between that person and these "pothole vigilantes".
- ensignavenger 9y ago"I really don't know how you can actually make a pothole worse by attempting to fix it" You have clearly never lived in the town where I grew up :)
- schoen 9y ago> "you touch it, you (might) own it" Perhaps compare https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10367855 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10367855.
- hermitdev 9y ago> I really don't know how you can actually make a pothole worse by attempting to fix it. My first thought would be using substandard or incorrect materials. Say, using concrete in an asphalt surface. You quasi cover this with your cardboard part of the comment. Perhaps an incorrect mix of aggregate to asphalt might have different thermal properties. If the pothole expanded more/faster than the surrounding material, it might make it a lot worse. Also, if your materials are not safe to drive on while setting (like my example, filling a hole with concrete). You'd also be endangering yourself and others while attempting such work as you'll be unsuitably marked and lanes won't be properly barricaded for your work.
- fzzzy 9y ago(2017)
- IAmEveryone 9y agoMost people don't even shoulder their share of household chores, even though fair sharing is enforced by informal yet powerful social mechanisms. So I'm not optimistic regarding widespread peaceful anarchy for services. Fixing potholes yourself also takes a (few million) step(s) backward in time: it's the bartering of public service, forgoing the awesome benefits of specialisation and cooperation. But you know where this sort of anarchy basically works: taxes! Almost all people send in their tax returns without a fuzz. It's almost as if they agree that everyone should chip in for shared endeavours, and that money is an excellent medium for coordinating it all. (yeah, I know there's the threat of criminal law lurking if you don't pay your taxes. But taxes are probably the world's most universal policy, and only a select few lunatics and presidents seem not to get the concept)
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoOk, so what do you do with a gerrymandered populace, a government that wants to cut as much tax revenue from companies that it can, and then cuts public service? Sure, Portland isn't likely that. I'm thinking of places like Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky - you know, those flyover states. These governments don't represent us. The winning party, at one time, "won" the right to redesign the boundaries. And they did so to their best benefit to keep them in office. So yeah, its working for them. EDIT: Gotta love the -1's over a factual statement and a legit question of "what do you do?" Cause these downvotes says "stfu". Quite sad, considering how many gerrymandered districts and areas there are.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- viridian 9y ago>I'm thinking of places like Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky - you know, those flyover states. >These governments don't represent us. These are why I -1'd you just now. Insulting the places themselves is rude, and pretending that these states would be blue were it not for gerrymandering, and thus rejecting that the majority of these state's voters vote R is ridiculous. yes, Gerrymandering is garbage, but Kansas's population isn't 90% secret blue voters being suppressed by gerrymandering. You are by and large seeing the actual will of the people.
- ourmandave 9y agoWait, are these guys Individualism or Collectivism Anarchists? Rewind 2000 years... Wait, are these guys the People's Judean Front or the People's Front of Judea?
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoI've seen the converse by using grafitti and drawing obnoxious penises around potholes. Sure, it defaces public property, but it's with the goal that the potholes will be taken care of quicker. Unsure how true that is in practice.
- reycharles 9y agoThey mentioned that in the article and link to another article about this.
- drawkbox 9y agoReminds me of the "Guerrilla Public Service" vigilante[1][2] from 2001, he added an I-5 sign notification where people commonly missed the exit. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANFaIeiJ40Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANFaIeiJ40Q [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Clgl63CWOkM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Clgl63CWOkM
- Someone1234 9y agoI love that story so much. We all have those "little" things that bug us, that we just wish we could throw our hands up and fix but naturally never do. The most we'll do is send a comment/email that will never get action-ed.
- chris_wot 9y agoIt would be far worse if they not only fixed the pothole, but then made a new pothole near the house of a government official.
- falcolas 9y agoI put this comment in the Tesla thread, but it applies here as well. Last summer saw a lot of really bad forest fires that had to be fought. The costs of fighting those fires had to come from the state in most cases, and many budgets suffered as a result (a situation made worse by the broad denials of federal assistance to states). In our case (Montana) the budget that suffered the most was road maintenance. Our roads received the minimum possible care they could receive this winter; the state just couldn’t afford more.
- hermitdev 9y agoAnd, in the case of the Lolo Peak fire, my parents are one of two households that are footing the cost of the firefighters major fuck-up of setting the back-burn that nearly took out an entire neighborhood. My parents lost nearly everything except 2 vehicles and the pets. The fire started on federal land, and federal officials set the fire that burned down my parents' house. No compensation to them, yet, except from their insurance. I know back-burns are not precise, but given that the fed took preventative measures sure as bulldozing a multimile fire line and laying pipe to power sprinklers, then they set the fire and didn't turn the sprinklers on, feels like arson to me. Also, that they started it at one of the worst times of the day. Everyone in Montana knows that winds pick up in the afternoon. When did they start the back-burn? Roughly 1-2pm local, depending on conditions. That's usually about the cutoff for regional slash burns. By cutoff, I don't mean start, I mean, they have to be stopped by then. Coupled with reports from neighbors, that refused to evacuate, that fire fighters stood by and simply watched while 2 houses & a neighborhood water system burned to the ground. Am I pissed? Of course. I think there was a huge failure of management in this fire. Will my parents every be properly be compensated? I doubt it. They, and the rest of my family, have lost a lot due to federal mismanagement. My parents' house was not lost due to a wild fire. It was lost due to federal action to combat a wild fire, and they fucked it up.
- avoutthere 9y agoRather than getting defensive, municipalities should support these groups much in the same way they do volunteer fire departments.
- cygx 9y agoFor liability reasons, the municipalities would have to enforce certain rules and organized structure. Good luck selling that to anarchists...
- icebraining 9y agoRight, and have a strike (and possibly lawsuit) on their hands for promoting unpaid labor. And frankly, I wouldn't blame the strikers.
- avoutthere 9y agoAre you familiar with the function of volunteer fire departments in the U.S.?
- icebraining 9y agoNot in the US, is there anything special them? If not, I'd say they have a different pattern of activity than almost any other municipal work: plenty of downtime with unpredictable peaks that might require huge numbers of people at a very short notice. This makes hiring professionals a huge waste except in large cities, because they'll be twiddling their thumbs most of the time.
- dawnerd 9y ago> This makes hiring professionals a huge waste except in large cities, because they'll be twiddling their thumbs most of the time. Fire depts are not sitting around twiddling their thumbs. Plenty of work to be done. To respond to a lot more than just fires too FYI. Volunteer firefighters are there to help out in areas not served by firefighters such as being out in a super rural area or when theres a big fire and there simply isn't enough staff, like wildfires. They're not volunteering to take away someones job. Some of them are just retired firefighters or veterans that want to look out for their community.
- lettergram 9y ago> Don’t get us wrong, we believe that many of these services are crucial for society, like healthcare, education, and maintained roadways, but we believe that the way to achieve access for all is by deconstructing the state and capitalism, as well as other coercive hierarchies that exist in our society One thing that always struck me, was in a capitialistic society we are actually all incentivised to fix potholes ourselves... Basically the improved potholes keep us safe, improve business, etc. I think many are just so short sighted, that when they think of capitalism they think of the standard "greedy corporation" If people actually thought two steps ahead (including said corporation) theyd be more like Amazon, improve logistics and you improve the world. Literally, everyone profits. That's the point of capitalism, you can basically do what you want. These guys are filling potholes for themselves, they said as much. That's a selfish, capitalism-centric act
- bbctol 9y ago...unless it violates someone else's property rights. The point of capitalism is that people can own things, and you can do what you want as long as you don't violate that system of ownership. The point of anarchism is that you can basically do what you want.
- kiliantics 9y ago> The point of anarchism is that you can basically do what you want. This is a simplistic characterisation. Anarchists hold individual liberty in the highest regard but also believe in solidarity and mutual aid. You can "basically do what you want" as long as you aren't restricting the individual freedom of others but rather supporting everyone in having access to the same means and rights as you do. Since exploitation of people is so endemic in our society, anarchists work mainly to free themselves and others from oppressive systems. Right now we can't do what we want, so anarchists fight against the social dynamics which are preventing this.
- PeterisP 9y agoWell, but in the absence of an overriding rulership, i.e. anarchy, you actually can do what you want even if you're restricting the individual freedom of others and denying them access to the same means and rights as you do. There's clear motivation for some people to do that, and what's going to prevent them from doing that to weaker or less resourceful people? And a system capable and intent on effectively doing that essentially becomes a de facto system of governance, and the situation ceases to be an anarchy.
- wolfi1 9y agothis seems to be from 2017. do they still mend the potholes?
- vondur 9y agoBack in my day, Anarchists destroyed public property, not fix it! Kidding aside, this is pretty cool, but really sad that the city can't somehow fix them before property damage or someone gets hurt.
- Viper007Bond 9y agoThe winter of 2016/2017 was really bad here in Portland and caused an unbelievable amount of damage to our roads. Whole portions of streets came up from the freeze/thaw. It was nuts and they're STILL in the process of fixing them, not that the roads in Portland proper were ever that great in the first place.
- TheMagicHorsey 9y agoIts strikes me that these people don't know what capitalism is. I think they think that corporatism is capitalism. In any case, you can't have an anarchist society ... its always going to turn into an anarcho-capitalist society. People are always going to join together into mutually beneficial joint-enterprises ... and they are going to want to share in the proceeds from such enterprises ... and that is what capitalism basically enables.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- forkLding 9y agoNot essentially, one can have worker cooperatives, capitalistic structures entitles profits to a few shareholders whereas the rest are workers. Worker cooperative (can be seen in communistic/socialistic/anarchist/democratic light) are where everyone has shares and ownership of the cooperative.
- TheMagicHorsey 9y agoWhat is a shareholder? Have you ever thought about it? What do you need to make a modern enterprise? You need tools and you need labor. Some people provide labor, and others provide the tools. Some people who can provide tools, don't necessarily want to provide labor. They are shareholders without being workers. If all the workers bring their own tools, then the enterprise can be 100% worker owned. If some workers need someone else to provide tools, they need some outside capital. That outside capital is basically outside people providing tools in exchange for some ownership in the enterprise. As enterprises become more complex, you may need more and more complicated and expensive tools ... and the people who provide the labor and the people who provide the tools can become highly specialized. There you go ... shareholder capitalism again.
- forkLding 9y agoAgain this depends, you're more describing corporate capitalism, most small businesses don't go through these processes and might become worker coops to survive if can't pay wages or if nobody good enough to take over even if its a profitable and expanding small chain.(speak from personal experience) Its pretty oversimplized to describe the capital acquistion process, small businesses can last 20 or 30 years without any actual outside investment. Most small businesses dont become corporations that require extensive outside investment because its hard, thus your case is only certain if every small business becomes a corporation through outside investment but it doesnt occur everytime and is only an edge case.
- bsimpson 9y agoSFMTrA is a similar group that adds protection for SF bike lanes when the city can't be bothered to do it: https://twitter.com/sfmtra https://twitter.com/sfmtra
- gadders 9y agoPeople in the UK took a different approach to get potholes filled in [1] - basically spray painting penises on them to shame the Council into filling them in. [1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/article/32448103/mystery-artist-highlights-bury-potholes-with-penis-drawings http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/article/32448103/mystery-artis...
- alex_duf 9y agoThere's this amazing story by 99% invisible about Guerrilla Public Service which I find both fascinating and funny at the same time. I highly recommend that episode: http://pca.st/YLdD http://pca.st/YLdD
- luckydude 9y agoI organized a crew to do this in the Santa Cruz mountains last year. I did it after losing two tires in the same car to the same pothole. That gets expensive. I tried to work with the county to make it official, the idea was to form a group of trained, careful people that would be to public works what the volunteer fire department is to Cal-Fire. Then we could be insured, etc. The county wanted no part of it even though their budget, at the time, was about $1M/year for 600 miles of roads (that's pathetic and the roads show it. The road I'm on hasn't been paved or screened for decades and it's falling apart, just like many others). I was hoping we could pioneer a model that other states/counties could emulate. Still am but don't know how to get there. We can bring way more people to the table than the county can. For example, they fill potholes with 2 people, one guy driving a pickup, one guy on the back shoveling patch. We did that (as you'll see below) with 7 people and two trucks (my flatbed and my 1/2 ton). Our protocol on busy roads was to park the flatbed facing into traffic, lights on, flashers on, safety LED flashers up high on, then cone off a buffer behind and in front, put two people with slow/stop signs just inside each cone zone, a person at the middle that directs traffic (everyone had radios on them), a driver for the flatbed (used to tamp in the patch) and shoveler. That's 7 people where the county had 2. We were dramatically safer. We could do that because we all volunteered. That's a lot of man power for free, it's less risky, it still blows my mind that the county can't get behind that. Someone decided it made them look bad. Personally, I think not using that man power makes them look bad but what do I know? https://www.mercurynews.com/2017/03/17/mountain-vigilantes-tackle-plague-of-potholes/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2017/03/17/mountain-vigilantes-t...
- jjp 9y agoDevon, county in England, has a similar problem. They look to be embracing getting local community to do the work, providing materials and who after training are then covered on liability. https://new.devon.gov.uk/communities/casestudy/100000-funding-to-roll-out-community-road-warden-scheme-countywide https://new.devon.gov.uk/communities/casestudy/100000-fundin...
- luckydude 9y agoThat's great news, I'll pass that on to the county. Thank you!