5 ms·
Currently, the Tesla autopilot page has this as its top headline: > Full Self-Driving Hardware on All Cars Followed by this: > All Tesla vehicles produced in
by danso 9y ago
Currently, the Tesla autopilot page has this as its top headline:
> Full Self-Driving Hardware on All Cars
Followed by this:
> All Tesla vehicles produced in our factory, including Model 3, have the hardware needed for full self-driving capability at a safety level substantially greater than that of a human driver.
http://web.archive.org/web/20180323054727/https://www.tesla.com/autopilot http://web.archive.org/web/20180323054727/https://www.tesla....
Getting past the arguments of whether Tesla should be calling this "Autopilot", is its claims about hardware true? Is the failure to detect stationary objects like a firetruck or a gore point solely as a result of currently-inadequate software? Because it doesn't sound like the sensor suite is anywhere near the AVs of Waymo or Uber.
- Shank 9y ago> Getting past the arguments of whether Tesla should be calling this "Autopilot", is its claims about hardware true? Tesla actually hasn't called that Autopilot -- they refer to it as "full self driving" and not in the same category. But...is it true? It's vaporware right now, so we can't really say. Obviously, in a purely hypothetical landscape, even with cameras you should be able to emulate what humans can do and have 100% attentiveness. That is to say, humans don't have lidar and radar, yet humans do drive. So, if you can achieve human levels of perfection and have 100% attentiveness, it should be possible to beat out crash statistics based on the fact that many are caused by failure to respond on the human side accurately or fast enough. This is all hypothetical, though. All of it comes down to computer vision/software, which is really hard to do. It's possible, but not yet done.
- miskin 9y ago"Autopilot" is the name of the page that danso referred to, is in the title of that page and is used on the page 9 times. How would you possibly not recognize this as name of the feature?
- carlmr 9y ago>Obviously, in a purely hypothetical landscape, even with cameras you should be able to emulate what humans can do and have 100% attentiveness. That is to say, humans don't have lidar and radar, yet humans do drive. Which camera has the same dynamic range as the human eye?
- notahacker 9y agoHumans don't have lidar and radar, but humans permitted to drive have optical hardware which is in all respects except simultaneity of inputs from different directions superior to that which Tesla is claiming is sufficient for full safe driving capability. Much harder to imagine software surpassing alert human driving capabilities if it's not equipped with sensors offering better depth perception that could compensate for lack of general intelligence to process unfolding situations, visual anomalies etc. Harder still if the optical sensors are objectively worse than human ones in many lighting conditions.
- elgenie 9y agoTheir claim is that all the sensing capability is there for the car equivalent of the proverbial sufficiently smart compiler to achieve full self-driving capability. But said sufficiently smart software running sufficiently smart algorithms capable of sufficiently speedy processing of the senser data doesn't exist at the moment. The claim is falsifiable if and only if one can prove the minimum sensor capability required for full self-driving exceeds what they have. But even proving the falseness at a later date doesn't prove malice or fraud unless Tesla knows right now that their claim is not true.
- unityByFreedom 9y ago> is its claims about hardware true? Is the failure to detect stationary objects like a firetruck or a gore point solely as a result of currently-inadequate software? It might be true, but it's also true that most self-driving researchers prefer to use lidar, not 2D images, because lidar gives better results. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16765923 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16765923