3 ms·
I'm working my way through Being No One at the moment. It's very interesting, and (to me, anyway) sounds like he's on the right track with his 'transparent self
by taneq 9y ago
I'm working my way through Being No One at the moment. It's very interesting, and (to me, anyway) sounds like he's on the right track with his 'transparent self-model' understanding of consciousness.
Interestingly a lot of robotics seems to work the same way - the robot has a model of itself and the world around it, and when it "looks at the world" it's actually looking at that model.
- state_less 9y agoIt's also worth reflecting on your model of reality and color. RF wavelengths vary along a single dimension, the wavelength. But we perceive red, green and blue. Sometimes we don't perceive the wavelength if it's outside our visual range, it never is mapped into the model, unless we lift it into visual range with sensors (IR) or dig into it through the analytical mind.
- taneq 9y agoIt's actually quite scary if you think too much about it - what we 'see' and 'hear' and 'feel' as our nice neat comprehensible rectilinear 3D world with directional audio and consistent textures and shapes etc. is nothing like what's "really" there, there's just a 2-way mapping between our model and "reality". All that's really there is an invisible hot soupy sea of quarks fizzing around at ludicrous speed.
- psyc 9y agoThere is a certain sense in which one has never actually interacted with anything other than one's own brain. It's not the only sense of things, but it's one.
- andbberger 9y ago> the robot has a model of itself and the world around it, and when it "looks at the world" it's actually looking at that model. So do you! Perception is a bayesian inference problem! Maybe the actual state of the world is x, but you observe the latent z (eg photoreceptor output) which is related to x in some complicated way. What you are doing when you look at a scene and understand what's going on is inferring what underlying state of the world is most likely to have generated your observation! Theoretical neuro gets one surprisingly far in terms of gaining insight about the self. For instance, I'm a big sucker for the sampling hypothesis, which says basically that thinking is the process of drawing samples from the posterior p(x | z), states of the world which are likely to have generated your observation.
- eli_gottlieb 9y agoYou have your latent and observed variables reversed. The former is `z`, the latter is `x`. ;-)
- lou1306 9y ago> the robot has a model of itself and the world around it, and when it "looks at the world" it's actually looking at that model. That would be the classical "sense, plan, act" approach to AI. There is also a whole array of more "reactive" solutions, that only relies on sensor inputs without building any world model. Brooks' "Intelligence without reason" [^1] is probably one of the best papers out there in describing how this way is better suited to build complex robotic/AI systems and apply them to real-world scenarios. [^1]: http://people.csail.mit.edu/brooks/papers/AIM-1293.pdf http://people.csail.mit.edu/brooks/papers/AIM-1293.pdf