2 ms·
I think the issue is that creating new injustice on the “innocent” isn’t a very good reason. The “someone must suffer and it sucks to be you” creates a negative
by prepend 9y ago
I think the issue is that creating new injustice on the “innocent” isn’t a very good reason. The “someone must suffer and it sucks to be you” creates a negative cycle because in 50 years they now have a case.
It’s like poking out a random person’s eye because racists blinded someone. Yes it helps the person who can now see, but the person who lost their eye will likely be bitter.
The best program I’ve seen is the dedicated funding to expand new positions and try to target the expansion toward underrepresented. So while the ratios are still weird, people aren’t being excluded.
Of course this is the most expensive option, especially in zero sum games like Harvard admissions. It’s easier to target some less visible vulnerable population and reallocate the positions.
I do agree that being truly color blind keeps populations lacking 100 years of opportunity locked in a cycle. But perhaps we can get more precise with targeting based on income, or social determinants, or factors that are not specific to race and are more likely to provide opportunity to need. Of course many populations also share social determinants like income, parents education, country of birth, etc.