3 ms·
> A union at Google could threaten to effectively halt all institutional operations of governments or other companies in order to influence their actions. But
by chrisseaton 9y ago
> A union at Google could threaten to effectively halt all institutional operations of governments or other companies in order to influence their actions.
But this seems an amoral thing to do, to me! A small group of unelected, unaccountable and non-diverse people abusing their relative power to try to force a democratically elected government or private company to do something? Why would anyone want that?
- deciplex 9y agoThis post seems like it was probably sarcasm but I can't tell. Just in case, though: we already have that.
- chrisseaton 9y agoMy post wasn't sarcasm. Nobody thinks the current system is perfect or not vulnerable to corruption or special interests etc, but at least it attempts to be representative of the people and accountable, and to be well informed through intelligence networks and professional analysis. A dictatorship of a union of Google employees forcing the hand of the government based on what they're angry about from Twitter doesn't even bother to make a pretense of being fair.
- deciplex 9y agoI think if you can twist your head enough to believe that our current system "at least attempts" (but, by implication, even you seem to agree still fails) to be representative of the people, but also believe that any employee union is a priori unrepresentative, you might be showing some bias. Maybe a lot of it, actually. And it doesn't help that you immediately heap a bunch of strawmen on this hypothetical Google union, either. Edit: from your original post it also occurs to me you might think union leadership is never elected? But it almost always is (usually by law, in fact).
- nafizh 9y ago'a democratically elected government or private company' is the same thing? Workers of a private company should have a say in the doings of the company.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> Workers of a private company should have a say in the doings of the company. But the person I replied to advocated them abusing that say to undermine an elected government. They weren't just saying 'Google should not have the government as a customer' they were saying 'Google should have the government as a customer and then deliberately abuse that to force their political agenda'. > A union at Google could threaten to effectively halt all institutional operations of governments or other companies in order to influence their actions. See the difference? That's not 'we don't want to be involved in this, thanks'. It's 'we're going to abuse our position of power to get you to do what we want rather than what the voters' representative want'. And I'd gently suggest that if you think this would be fine, it's just because they happen to have the same politics as you, which would be lucky for you, but beware it may change. What if the Google union forced the government to bomb Yemen, instead to not bomb Yemen?
- zanny 9y agoI'd love to live in a world where collective action by workers could be considered an abuse of power. The workers would be way better off in such a world. It is completely insane and probably symptomatic of the extremely successful doublethink anti-union campaign by big business in the US to think organized workers could ever pose a larger threat to democracy than corporations you are grouping with the government as victims. What a lot of people don't realize is that incorporation under US law is functionally franchising an elected government. The difference is that instead of the members of the business getting the votes the votes are called shares and are controlled by an oligarchy majority of shareholders. The means by which the vast majority of businesses are run (with exception to many nonprofits, public benefit corporations, and coops) is what many would consider antithetical to how to run society fairly. And then people are surprised that such unaccountable undemocratic systems produce blatant corruption - except people don't even call it corruption despite it being a direct mapping to public corruption, they call it business as usual or meeting earnings expectations. But no, the influence of THAT system of organization is fine - better, adored. Aspired towards. Workers trying to have more equal negotiations by working together though? Threat to democracy.
- kiliantics 9y agoCurrently, Google and other large companies already do have power and influence over what the government does. But only a tiny portion of people at these companies are the ones deciding what to do with that power. It would be preferable if the entire company took part in deciding how it would influence what the government does. It would be even more preferable if workers across whole industries and whole sections of society together used their collective power to influence what the government can do. Ideally, these large federated unions would also do so with the interests of the unemployed/disabled/disenfranchised as well. This is what the IWW does. Tech workers should join the IWW.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> It would be even more preferable if workers across whole industries and whole sections of society together used their collective power to influence what the government can do. Everyone in society is already part of one big union that can influence government - the electorate. Everyone gets one vote. If you try to force the government to do something it wouldn't do otherwise you're trying to get power beyond your one vote. That's why it's an abuse.