4 ms·
Note that eliminating the ability to do detailed profiling and precise targeting does NOT stop this kind of manipulation. It just makes it more expensive. Thos
by tzs 9y ago
Note that eliminating the ability to do detailed profiling and precise targeting does NOT stop this kind of manipulation. It just makes it more expensive.
Those people who will respond to your fake news in a way favorable to you are still out there. It just means that instead of being able to target a group of say, 10 000 people that will give you a 5% conversion rate, you might have to pay to target 1 000 000 people with a 0.05% conversion rate.
This raises an interesting question: would we be better off if instead of restricting data we make it more widely available?
As suggested in the second paragraph above, restricting the data doesn't stop those with enough money from influencing susceptible people at scale. It just makes it more expensive, so only the very wealthy can do it.
If we make the data more open, we make the playing field more level, perhaps giving smaller, less well financed groups a chance to compete with the billionaire backed groups and causes.
- not_that_noob 9y agoQuite true and an interesting proposition. Especially with regard to transparency - if we all can see the data FB sees on what ads were targeted to whom - then that might help as well, as outsiders can watch for dark patterns. In addition, I think they need to use AI to verify if posts and ads can be fake before allowing it to go live. Of course, doing so would mean fewer clicks. The more extreme the info, the greater the clicks. This is at the heart of Zuck’s dilemma - to curb this problem in a meaningful way means reduced revenue.
- FridgeSeal 9y agoThe idea is to discourage people from using propaganda to manipulate democracy. I honestly don't think that throwing open the floodgates so that effectively anyone can would fix the problem at all. Realistically all you're going to do there is make it cheaper and easier for existing players and worse for everyone subjected to it.
- creaghpatr 9y agoOne solution to OP's problem is to strengthen libel and slander laws to deter people from casually publishing fraudulent news, akin to a DMCA takedown request but perhaps a bit more bite. In this case I would distinguish publishing from 'sharing' with a bit more legal finesse. The problem is the press will scream bloody murder at any attempt to reign in their right to publish, perhaps rightfully so. IANAL.
- 220V_USKettle 9y agoHow enforcable would that be outside US borders, realistically?
- creaghpatr 9y agoGood point
- dingaling 9y agoWhilst I appreciate the concern, so long as the US government has platforms such as the EC-130 Compass Call ( which can overpower broadcast frequencies with its own propaganda ) in order to 'shape' democracy in other nations it's quite hard for people outside the USA to think anything other than 'a taste of your own medicine'. The only thing that seems different is that it was the 'other guys' who were playing psyops better this time around, rather than the incumbent government.
- Larrikin 9y agoAlso what about Hillary Clinton's emails while we're at it. That is the real scandal. The other issue should be ignored because the world isn't perfect.