4 ms·
I hear you, and I want to make a "times change" argument. This is my perspective, because I read too much scifi: I can conceive of a couple possibilities in 30
by komali2 9y ago
I hear you, and I want to make a "times change" argument.
This is my perspective, because I read too much scifi: I can conceive of a couple possibilities in 300 years.
1. Humanity is gone or stone-aged. Either because it failed to colonize before being wiped out by disease, because it nuked itself, or because it implemented AI in a way that got itself killed.
2. Humanity has turned peaceful, formed a global community (if not wholly, then at least nearly so regarding scientific resources), and colonized.
I draw such a sharp line because I don't see how the resources to colonize can be mustered without justifying it with an arms race unless peaceful cooperation is established. Without this, I think somebody is going to put a nuke in orbit around Mars and call themselves King/Queen of the inner solar system.
Therefore, I think we should be working towards the cultural changes that I believe necessary immediately. This is why I'm a staunch proponent of universal education, universal healthcare, gun control, etc. I think there's no better time than the present to "be in the race together" globally than now. Given climate change, death of bees, super-bacterias, and narcissists with penis-size complexes holding fingers over red buttons, I see a ticking clock.
Avoid (1) by tackling culture, is my theory, and I think that's what these googler employees are here. (I post this very much looking forward to being challenged on all points)
- mkirklions 9y agoI worry that culture doesnt help at the top of leadership. Once you get to the top of an organization, only a few people need to listen to you. As long as you keep their paychecks and power, they will listen to you. Dictators dont care if war is unpopular as long as its beneficial. I think nukes may be obsolete because war is no longer beneficial, but leadership of a company may be 100% set on finding AI by any means necessary.
- komali2 9y agoCan you clarify your second line, "Once you get to the top of an organization, only a few people need to listen to you. As long as you keep their paychecks and power, they will listen to you." Are you saying that everyone has to do what you say because you pay them? If so, I don't think that point applies to this situation - we're talking Google engineers, they shouldn't be hard pressed to pick up their things and find a job elsewhere that aligns better with their values.
- ixtli 9y agoCapital interests wont go away quietly, but I hope you're right.
- jeremyjh 9y agoI doubt they will go away peacefully, either. I cannot think of an instance in history where they have though I’d love to be wrong.
- ixtli 9y agoI honestly cling to the hope daily that the internet has changed what people's reactions to power will be in the future. It's the one of the few deep things that's changed.
- ataturk 9y agoEvery policy idea you have listed is idiotic. Globalism == lack of agency, the end of voting and elections. Universal education == total indoctrination and ideological consistency of the collectivistic variety. Universal healthcare == the end of individual choice, individual responsibility, all new extensive taxing regimes, the destruction of the individual on many levels. Gun Control == People control. Then total domination by the state and a monopoly on the use of force. Which, by the way, has never worked out well for any citizen anywhere. I think you probably need to study some history before spouting off on HN about your perfect utopia and realize that it's all been attempted in the past with terrible consequences.
- pacala 9y ago> Either because it failed to colonize before being wiped out by disease, because it nuked itself, or because it implemented AI in a way that got itself killed. If the probability of a kind of disaster is sufficient to blow up Earth, it is likely that the same kind of disaster will blow up all the handful of colonies we can hope to build. At astronomic scale, the speed of light is quite slow.
- komali2 9y agoPotentially. I think the possibility of quarantine is much higher between planets, though.
- mr_spothawk 9y agothere's a dead post from @Ataturk who nails my arguments against your point, but doesn't do so very nicely. history should be a guid here. presuming penis-size conversation is anything more than an intentional dig by a chauvinist powermonger, probably isn't helpful here.
- komali2 9y agoI don't see the dead post, though I've looked. I'm happy to hear the points.
- shitgoose 9y agoafter removing insulting remarks, ataturk's comments looks like this (which i personally agree with): Globalism == lack of agency, the end of voting and elections. Universal education == total indoctrination and ideological consistency of the collectivistic variety. Universal healthcare == the end of individual choice, individual responsibility, all new extensive taxing regimes, the destruction of the individual on many levels. Gun Control == People control. Then total domination by the state and a monopoly on the use of force. Which, by the way, has never worked out well for any citizen anywhere.
- komali2 9y agoThank you for taking the time to find and share the points. I'd like to rebuke : >Globalism == lack of agency, end of voting and elections If federalism didn't lead to this, why would globalism? What even is globalism? I am skeptical of this because "globalism" seems to be used as a catch-all alt-right bogeyman lately. >universal education == total indoctrination, ideological consistency Universal access to education doesn't have to mean homogeneous curriculum. It doesn't have to mean lack of education choices. It doesn't even have to mean requirement to receive education. Another thing I find curious - the very people I find rejecting education "collectivism" are often people who wouldn't blink before forcing their own "indoctrination" upon others. We fight this fight in Texas far too often - should schools teach facts (evolution), or give "fair credence" to falsehoods (intelligent design) because of religion? Woops, out goes falsehoods as soon as the satanists get involved and also flex their constitutional rights, never mind, we'll take evolution! >universal healthcare == the end of individual choice I don't see why this has to be true, it isn't in any of the current implementations of universal healthcare. >end of individual responsibility Are you presently responsible for your water being clean? Are you presently responsible for the quality of your roadways? Are you presently responsible for the guarantee that your medication contains advertised active ingredients that do as it says on the label? >Extensive taxing regimes Shift military funding, close ultra-rich tax loopholes. >destruction of the individual Fail to see how this is true. Unsupported by argument. >gun control == people control False equivalence. >then, total domination by the state and a monopoly on the use of force Currently working just fine in countries with gun control laws, which, by the way, completely nullifies the false "has never worked out well" absolute you ended with. Furthermore, the USA has right now a monopoly on the use of force. The US and its laws have sovereign control over whether you are allowed to use force or not. You have almost no say in the matter. Furthermore, this isn't 1776. The gap in armament between civilians and a martial state is so large as to be hilarious. Were the need to arise, US combined armed forces could drone strike, Tomahawk, artillery, AC130, or just door to door ground and pound any organized militia to dust. Or, you know, nuke it. Are you, private US citizen, allowed to build a nuke? I see this kind of response a lot to "the globalist threat." What's the end game, for people that believe these things? Endless culture war? A galaxy-spanning human civilization that still has their "I'm an American and you're Chinese" safe little lines? Is there a fear that the "wrong" culture will persist into the future?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoIf you're so worried about the world destroying itself with its own weapons, how are you going to enforce your weapons ban without using weapons?
- nugi 9y agoBut if all the guns were gone we wouldn't need any anymore, ergo world peace, cats and dogs living together, and mcdonalds becomes vegan. /s
- komali2 9y agoThe same way Japan "enforces" around violent and petty crime - by removing the need for it, and establishing a culture opposed to it. It's not nearly as easy as that but that's the basic summation of my philosophy around the idea.