4 ms·
Because the compiler doesn't and cannot know the semantics of signal(2)/sigaction(2). There's what POSIX says, which a compiler could enforce using heuristics,
by cryptonector 9y ago
Because the compiler doesn't and cannot know the semantics of signal(2)/sigaction(2). There's what POSIX says, which a compiler could enforce using heuristics, and there's what your C library says. It's perfectly plausible to make a number of nominally not-async-signal-safe functions from the standard actually async-signal-safe in a particular C library. Granted, if you were to take advantage of such an extension, your code would not be portable.
(EDIT: The compiler doesn't even know that you're using POSIX. It can figure it out contextually. It doesn't know which C library you'll be linking with though. Bottom line: we need some C standards extensions, or failing that, GCC/Clang C extensions in order to best handle this, though there are some heuristics a compiler could implement even without those, at some mild risk.)
(E.g., suppose there was a thread-local counter of signal handlers on the stack... then stdio functions might be able to handle async-signal reentrance. It's not too farfetched, though it's obviously a lot easier to not bother at all and just leave the set of async-signal-safe functions being just the set of system calls that have sufficiently thin stubs in the C library.)
Now, the C standard could have additional keywords, much like, say, 'volatile' and friends, to describe async-signal-safety, reentrance, and other characteristics of functions. And if the C library and your programs used these then the compiler absolutely could warn or refuse to compile your program when you break the standard's rules.
Incidentally, Unix/POSIX signals are horrible. The only sane and portable way to handle them in programs that do I/O is to have an event loop and a "self-pipe" that the signal handler can write into so that the event loop can pick up and handle the signal as a normal async event in a context where there are no constraints on calling async-signal-unsafe functions. This is what I always do in my programs. I strongly recommend it. This means you don't need ppoll(2), pselect(2), signalfd(2), epoll_pwait(2), and so on -- you don't because you're always turning signals into normal I/O events, so you don't need to worry about signal blocking, and you don't need to use less widely available functions.