10 ms·
Lessons from “The Profit”
- taheca 9y agoThis especially stuck out to me as it is fairly consistent across most episodes that I have seen: "If Lemonis has a genius skill it’s in keeping his temper and working through bullshit problems to get to the real festering issues that are at the root of inefficiencies."
- sutterbomb 9y agoThe top comment right now on the thread on Apple’s new AI exec hire is entirely about how “suits” and “management” are worthless. Recent economic research, as pointed out by Tabarrok here, strongly disagrees.
- gscott 9y agoMany times suits and management drive the company right into the ground.
- replicatorblog 9y agoTo be fair, A fair few technologist-led startups have failed because they focused exclusively on product, sure that the market would beat a path to their door.
- leesalminen 9y agoLike most things in life, it’s like walking a tight rope. Too far one way or the other results in failure.
- koboll 9y agoYep, and that's exactly why suits and management are so important -- their competence determines whether the business survives.
- DrImplausible 9y agoThanks for sharing; it was a good quick read, and I found it instructive. What I'm not sure is how the lessons of a material production culture might translate to the digital one that most of HN (presumably) interacts with. Version control, getting rid of legacy systems, concentrating on the high-margin products that keep the business going. These could all be applied, correct?
- actionscripted 9y agoI was trying to figure a few of these out myself as I was reading the article... Dropping low-margin products/services could mean companies stop making small websites or apps for local companies. Keeping organized could mean making sure AWS assets are tagged and tracked or that all code is version-controlled with proper branches and deployments. Knowing the numbers could mean being able to say at any given point in time how your revenue stacks up against your costs (again maybe with AWS). Keeping things clean could mean consistent file organization, tidy personal machines or servers without stray SSH keys or software. I definitely feel like whenever I watch shows like The Profit or Restaurant Impossible I learn the same lessons: personal issues manifest and destroy, keep an eye on margins, don't be afraid to manage, keep things tidy.
- jaggederest 9y agoMy tongue-in-cheek simple rules: 1. Charge more for your product than the marginal cost to provide it to customers. 2. Get rid of complexity and overhead, streamline systems. 3. Manage your cashflow, I've seen amazing things done with e.g. trade credit, annual subscriptions, etc. to turn a break-even business into a cash-flow-positive business.
- tlb 9y agoSoftware companies have similar inefficiencies, but they're harder to see and measure. Instead of piles of rotting inventory they live in bug trackers and post-it notes and long meetings. Managing to metrics is harder, because the metrics (bugs retired, KLOCs written) are so meaningless and easily fudged. Also, good programmers tend to be undisciplined. Good programmers are good because they're creative and they can keep a lot in their head, but that makes it hard to get them to follow processes and track everything rigorously. Replacing them with mediocre but disciplined programmers doesn't usually improve things. It's such a hard problem to run an efficient software shop that most companies don't even try -- instead, they only go after businesses with 80% gross margins.
- thisisit 9y agoThis one really close to home for me. Upon joining one of my previous employers I found that while they had an IT system, there was zero reporting. So, people had no clue on exact uptime for various systems. Once we had it in place, we found tons of issues in the infrastructure setup, installs etc. Cleanup was a long and arduous task but it failed in the end. The reason was people - many of the guys working on these systems were with the company for 3-5 years. These guys had grown into a culture of zero accountability and reporting systems were hazardous to their careers. So, they ensured the reporting system had only one leg.
- jsight 9y ago> These guys had grown into a culture of zero accountability > and reporting systems were hazardous to their careers. So, > they ensured the reporting system had only one leg. Hmm, isn't that more of a symptom of a hazardous management culture? I've generally only seen this happen when people were afraid of unreasonable repurcussions.
- mseebach 9y agoI have definitely come across employees who acted borderline criminally irresponsibly, and had nothing to fear from management either way. Of course, not punishing that kind of behaviour is its own kind of hazardous management culture.
- startupdiscuss 9y agoThere is a particular episode where he turns around a chain of family restaurants. I can't remember the numbers but various locations earnings were something like: +1 million, -1 million, +300k, +100k. Now he bought it for some multiple of earnings (can't remember but assume it was between 4x and 10x) on the condition that they shut down failing locations. Note that you don't have to do anything else but shut down the -1 million location and the whole business is much more profitable and valuable. So I agree with the insights, but I would also pay attention at the outset to how good a deal is, and how small the risk actually is at the outset.
- Benjammer 9y agoI think this is kind of the point though. It just shows how many businesses (albeit with sampling bias for the show) can be turned around with simple "Management 101" techniques and processes. It doesn't quite seem like a fair criticism to say that he isn't taking enough risk for your liking.
- startupdiscuss 9y agoYou're right, if I had said that it would not be fair.
- bonestamp2 9y agoI saw that episode and if I remember correctly, there was basically a sentimental reason they didn't close that -1 million location. I think a lot of businesses suffer from similar decisions -- you value something that isn't reflected in the balance sheet. Seeing that in someone else's business makes it so much easier to appreciate how foolish it is and to be more self-aware about those types of flaws in your own management decisions. The hardest one is probably people... managers often keep certain people around because they like the person, even though the person is terrible at their job.
- startupdiscuss 9y agoI believe you are correct but they eventually relented after they had sold part of the business. Lemonis, for his part, voluntarily gave up part of his equity to the manager of the location who volunteered to shut down his own location.
- swanson 9y agoI think there is something there with the "reality-TV MBA" the article links to. Lessons from "The Apprentice": the dynamics of leading a project. If you win, it can cover up bad process/bad leadership; if you lose, people blame the person they like least and rationalize reasons. Lessons from "Nathan for You": outside the box thinking and pushing on rules until they are just about to break spurs innovative and creative thinking, it's mostly garbage ideas but there are gems. Even the garbage can be interesting because people are so used to companies following existing playbooks and being safe. Lessons from "Shark Tank": desirable companies are in a position to reverse interview investors, basic heuristics for company valuation, financial metrics (COGS, CAC, etc), the difference between products and companies
- swanson 9y agoI will add that I watched Lemonis' spin-off show "The Partner" and it was hot-garbage. One of the worst reality shows I've ever watched in terms of structure and concept.
- tylersmith 9y agoI'm not a business person but Nathan For You, while being funny and enjoyable, really tought me some ways to think outside the box about marketing. His ghost realtor gimmick is still being used afaik.
- nosefrog 9y agoNathan For You is one of the best shows out there. It's a satire of other business advice shows -- the host pitches ridiculous business schemes that are usually borderline scams, and it's crazy how often they work out. He's had a couple episodes go viral, like Dumb Starbucks (he opened a Starbucks lookalike called Dumb Starbucks and justified it by saying it was protected under parody law). I highly recommend it!
- __s 9y agoI remember this guy having skits on 22 minutes, my father & I thought it was genius, glad to see how he's continued
- programminggeek 9y agoIt's worth noting that The Profit picks companies that are inherently dramatic because it's a TV show. The goal of a TV show is to get you to watch. Thus, the more of a train wreck, the more likely you watch. If Marcus was trying to maximize his ROI on the business investments, he would start with different businesses and more reasonable owners. Instead, he is maximizing the ROI on his TV show and his Brand (ugh, I hate that word). So, by losing a small amount of money on some ridiculous businesses, he makes a whole lot more on the back end of being on TV, selling business books, giving speeches, and in general looking like a business hero. The long play here is very, very smart and has obviously paid off already.
- glenra 9y ago> If Marcus was trying to maximize his ROI on the business investments, he would start with different businesses and more reasonable owners. To get a great deal, Marcus is looking for underpriced businesses that are broken in the particular ways he can help with. Since dealing with interpersonal issues is one of his strengths this probably would select for unreasonable owners even if "being on TV" weren't part of the deal.
- eitohaoeth 9y ago100% this. Actually seeing through to the incentives and motives behind it in order to see the context for what it is.
- gizzlon 9y ago> So, by losing a small amount of money on some ridiculous businesses Check out the recap in episode 1, season 5. Some of them make quite a good profit.. and some don't. > he makes a whole lot more on the back end of being on TV, selling business books, giving speeches.. hm.. did you do the math on this? Seems like you would have to sell a lot of books to cover losses of a few million USD per year [1]. And AFAIK he's not selling any books (?). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Profit_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Profit_(TV_series)
- ummonk 9y ago> If Marcus was trying to maximize his ROI on the business investments, he would start with different businesses and more reasonable owners. That doesn't seem true to me. If a company is relatively well run and still struggling, it will likely be much harder to turn around than one that is struggling simply because it is run extremely poorly...
- bufferoverflow 9y agoI watched the first season a while ago, and was shocked how badly some small businesses are run, and somehow they stay in business for years. And then the owners often fight to keep them in the crappy state for no good reason.
- PaulHoule 9y agoBig biz too. Where competition is absent, you don't need to cut the fat. So long as the cable company can raise your rates every year, reducing truck rolls will always be "too expensive". If those truck rolls come out of the bonus of the CEO on the other hand, they will get down to the root causes of why so many truck rolls.
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoThis is exactly why it's such a bad idea to blindly set your prices according to what the competition charges. That competition may just be slowly going out of business, and now you're following them!
- SadWebDeveloper 9y agoThe only lesson i learn from "The Profit" besides whats already stated on the article is that: It takes money to make money. If we apply the same methodology without injecting money to business it will probably fail because the profit gained from the savings in production won't be enough to cover the debt in a short term.
- louprado 9y agoThere was remarkable moment in one episode where the company had made a really bad deal on a long term lease. Somehow Marcus solved the problem and I immediately grabbed my notebook and leaned in... After a commercial break you learned he solved the problem by, drumroll, buying the entire building! IIRC it was a $20Million+ purchase since it included the neighboring suites as well. There is much to learn by watching the Profit, but that moment was just another example of a recurring theme. That money can solve a lot of problems.
- eitohaoeth 9y agoSure but that in itself is a valuable lesson. Grow your asset base. It's starts hard and gets exponentially easier.
- rmason 9y agoI really like The Profit and have recommended the show to others. A similar show (with way more drama) is Bar Rescue. It's becoming a trend now because Richard Rawlings of Fast 'n Loud has a new show called Garage Rehab where they turn around failing auto repair shops. Things all these businesses in different industries have in common: 1. They don't know their numbers so they're flying blind 2. Problems with family members or employees 3. Lots of unsold inventory and sometimes plain junk tying up capital 4. Owner isn't taking a salary I've personally worked for small businesses as well as startups that had some of these problems so they're pretty common.
- peacetreefrog 9y agoAll of these seem reasonable, self-explanatory except (4), can you expand/expound on why not taking a salary seems harmful? Is it because then the owners tend to just dip into their cash on hand and aren't that disciplined?
- dazc 9y agoIsn't it just an indicator that the business isn't making any money?
- peacetreefrog 9y agoI suppose and that makes sense, but that's more of a correlation/symptom of failure, whereas 1-3 seem more causal
- rmason 9y agoThe business is losing money and by not taking a salary the owner is trying to prolong the inevitable. However in most cases he or she isn't making any changes in how the business is run so real improvement is nearly impossible. In effect all they're doing is delaying the business closing.
- taneq 9y agoIt depends why they're not taking a salary. If the owner is already loaded and doesn't need the money, that's fine. If they're having some cashflow issues but the pipeline is full and there's revenue coming, then that's probably OK. If the business is tanking and can't support a wage, obviously that's bad.
- gizzlon 9y agoBig fan of the show, I've watched four seasons in six months. I like it for two reasons: 1) I do learn about business, retail, making deals and dealing with conflict. And 2) It's uplifting and inspiring to see how much people fuck up and still almost making it. Many of the business did quite good at some point. Obviously it's TV and I don't expect it to be 100% real, fact based and neutral. But I do think it's better than most "reality" TV-shows.