3 ms·
Of course just because the GDPR _sounds_ tough doesn't mean enforcement will be tough in practice. The UK decided that all UK companies must disclose the actua
by tialaramex 9y ago
Of course just because the GDPR _sounds_ tough doesn't mean enforcement will be tough in practice.
The UK decided that all UK companies must disclose the actual humans who control them. This sounded like a really good rule, which would help expose some of the worst abuses going on, although it wouldn't fix everything.
But it turned out that the shadowy figures just ignored it completely and the government did nothing. So you have a form field saying "Persons with significant control: You must list one or more natural human persons who exercise significant control over this company" and a lawyer writes "Offshore Shadowy Puppet Corporation #36656" and hits submit and it's accepted.
My reading of the law is that the government _could_ identify companies that ignored this rule, and seize their assets, on the justification that they haven't taken anything from any actual natural person, no natural human person was identified as controlling these assets anyway. But even if I'm right they do nothing, so what was announced as this big important policy change became in fact just a PR stunt.
- donohoe 9y agoVery possible. However the various groups I've spoken too are very concerned that this directive does have teeth and willingness to use enforcement power. In the same way that legal firms started patent-trolling, there is concern that GDPR is ripe for the same treatment (legal firms brining cases on behalf of users in order to earn fees). Right now I think there is legitimate concern, but time will tell.
- jakewins 9y ago> GDPR is ripe for the same treatment Nonsense. Patent litigation allows trolls to sue for and receive damages from the other party. GDPR violations lead to fines fines that go to the government; the plaintiff does not receive damages. Law firms working GDPR cases will only make money off of their clients, not from the companies they bring suits against. This is fundamentally different from patent law.