4 ms·
I mean a support team that has actual freedoms to help the customer and is not forced to operate on a script that has only one option to tell the customer: You'
by mschuster91 9y ago
I mean a support team that has actual freedoms to help the customer and is not forced to operate on a script that has only one option to tell the customer: You're screwed.
Or, even better: as here the case seems to be that the shooter depended on Youtube as income, why shouldn't she have the right to have her effective "firing" appealed in a proper court of law, like in Germany?
- ajross 9y agoIt's been alleged that her videos were genuinely controversial (vegan screed, animal violence depictions). How is a support team going to fix that? And the right to sue for redress of grievances is covered in the first amendment, for goodness sake. She didn't exercise it.
- walshemj 9y agoHow is "vegan screed" controversial
- ajross 9y agoAnimal violence is controversial. I added the vegan bit to clarify that she wasn't, I dunno, a dog fighting afficionado. Her content (which, again, I haven't seen!) was "controversial", it wasn't a straightforward ToS violation.
- mschuster91 9y ago> And the right to sue for redress of grievances is covered in the first amendment, for goodness sake. She didn't exercise it. Good luck trying to sue one of the most powerful companies in history. I wouldn't dream of this.
- ajross 9y agoWhat are you talking about? If it's less than the local statutory limit (quick google tells me $7500 in California, likely around what this woman thinks she was owed) then you don't even need a lawyer. File a small claims suit, show up at court, and make your case before the judge. Now, she probably wouldn't win, because there's no contract here and Google has no affirmative duty to host anyone's video in particular nor to pay them for it. But you can absolutely do it.
- mschuster91 9y ago> But you can absolutely do it. You can do it, but who has the resources (especially the motivation and willpower) to drag such a case through the various appeal instances, with the issue that if you do lose, you have to pay the opposite party's lawyer bills? No way in hell I'd risk loading up THAT debt risk.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoBecause youtube didn't employ her. She was never hired, and so can't be fired, in any sense of the word. If anyone thinks that they are working for Youtube, then they must be delusional. Edit: I meant if anyone thinks they should depend on youtube ads for income, they are delusional.
- Larrikin 9y agoIf they actually are receiving their income from Youtube why are they delusional?
- lotsofpulp 9y agoYoutube specifically states they dictate how much you will earn, and you have no negotiating power.
- tedunangst 9y agoHow does the law work in Germany? If youtube pulls ads from a German's videos, they can demand to get paid anyway?
- mschuster91 9y agoNot if you're working on your own (though there may be a slim chance of getting damages replacements if the decision is proven to be malignant, but that's difficult as hell to do). If you are an employed creator, on the other hand, yes your employer has to pay you even if Youtube shuts down the monetization. Exactly this safety net is what the "gig economy" tries to cut...