4 ms·
I don't sympathize with shooting up a company's headquarters at all, but I feel that this could have been avoided by forcing Youtube (and, for that matter, all
by mschuster91 9y ago
I don't sympathize with shooting up a company's headquarters at all, but I feel that this could have been avoided by forcing Youtube (and, for that matter, all other social networks!) to have a way to reach an actual human support.
In the end, this is one of the "externalities" that get forced upon society when the big companies decide to cut corners on support. Some will... take matters into their own hands. Be it by spraying racist tweets as graffiti in front of the Hamburg Twitter office or by running amok, when they feel desperate enough. Desperation, especially perceived desperation, drives people to really horrible decisions - and demonetizing all videos of someone who depends on YT income for life is certainly enough to seriously mess with people.
- jimmies 9y agoBut she said she talked to the support team...
- meri_dian 9y agoShe was crazy. I don't think attempts to walk through her thought processes will bear fruit
- sillysaurus3 9y agoEveryone can be crazy if pushed in just the right way.
- aninhumer 9y agoWhenever something like this happens, people like to dismiss the situation by saying we can't possibly understand "crazy" people. It avoids having to consider the systemic reasons why something like this can happen. I'd imagine a significant part of it is that we live a society where some people can have their livelihood yanked away from them, with no support structure to help them, leaving them desperate and angry.
- meri_dian 9y agoYes, and the crazy people are the ones who, when desperate and angry, try to kill 3 innocent people and then themselves. I don't understand the equivocation here. It seems a symptom of the broad inability in modern social thinking to pin any responsibility on individuals. While this stems from our desire to root out systematic issues, which is necessary and important, it should not be the only thing we care about. In fact, a culture of individual responsibility actually can become a deep feature of our society if we take the time to engender it. Talking about individual responsibility is not ignoring the systematic issues in society, because a lack of focus on individual responsibility is actually rooted in our culture and hence is a systemic issue in itself.
- aninhumer 9y agoI would argue the opposite. We already have an intense culture of "individual responsibility" in many areas of society, and that's exactly the problem. Because a culture that seeks to blame individuals for problems makes individuals extremely reluctant to actually accept responsibility for their decisions. Consider how the airline industry investigates after a disaster: They investigate the circumstances leading to each bad decision, and then attempt to change the process such that it cannot happen again. This leads to individuals being forthcoming about their mistakes, and implements changes that actually solve the problem. This culture of focusing on systemic issues rather than individuals has made air travel extremely safe.
- where_do_i_live 9y agoHate to break it to you, but no one is dead outside of the shooter currently. You might want to take some of your individual responsibility and correct your statement.
- meri_dian 9y agoChanged it, though "trying to kill 3 people" rather than "killed 3 people" are morally equivalent.
- jimmies 9y ago
- mschuster91 9y agoI mean a support team that has actual freedoms to help the customer and is not forced to operate on a script that has only one option to tell the customer: You're screwed. Or, even better: as here the case seems to be that the shooter depended on Youtube as income, why shouldn't she have the right to have her effective "firing" appealed in a proper court of law, like in Germany?
- ajross 9y agoIt's been alleged that her videos were genuinely controversial (vegan screed, animal violence depictions). How is a support team going to fix that? And the right to sue for redress of grievances is covered in the first amendment, for goodness sake. She didn't exercise it.
- walshemj 9y agoHow is "vegan screed" controversial
- ajross 9y agoAnimal violence is controversial. I added the vegan bit to clarify that she wasn't, I dunno, a dog fighting afficionado. Her content (which, again, I haven't seen!) was "controversial", it wasn't a straightforward ToS violation.
- mschuster91 9y ago> And the right to sue for redress of grievances is covered in the first amendment, for goodness sake. She didn't exercise it. Good luck trying to sue one of the most powerful companies in history. I wouldn't dream of this.
- ajross 9y agoWhat are you talking about? If it's less than the local statutory limit (quick google tells me $7500 in California, likely around what this woman thinks she was owed) then you don't even need a lawyer. File a small claims suit, show up at court, and make your case before the judge. Now, she probably wouldn't win, because there's no contract here and Google has no affirmative duty to host anyone's video in particular nor to pay them for it. But you can absolutely do it.
- isseu 9y agoThe problem is not Youtube support ...
- wehadfun 9y agoYea. To even suggest this is Youtube supports fault is absurd.
- YetAnotherNick 9y agoYou can blame everything on a lunatic and that is right thing, but it won't change anything.
- GiorgioG 9y agoIt isn't so much that companies decide to cut corners on support, it's that at companies that operate at this scale (YT, FB, Twitter, etc ) the individual content-creator is a drop in the ocean. When she was de-monetized, it may have meant the world to her, but in YT's perspective it's not worth the time/effort to even have a conversation about it (say beforehand.)
- Mithaldu 9y agoWell, they made an economic tradeoff, and now people have been injured. As the famous comic says: "But for a beautiful moment in time we created a lot of value for shareholders.”
- jmull 9y agoI don't see a how you could come to a reasonable accommodation with someone who thinks, "You will let me do anything I want on your platform (with full benefits) or I'll shoot you." This doesn't look like a support issue at all to me.
- sh4z 9y agoHis point is if the person could have reached some kind of support they might never have ended up in such a desperate situation. When I get really mistreated / fooled and can't reach any kind of human support and none of the "robotic" support options work - it's incredibly frustrating. Not to the point where I'd shoot someone, but I've definitely smashed my fist on a table once or twice.
- YetAnotherNick 9y agoI have been once in such point of frustration when I had not received prize for what I won in the competition and the person whom I was in contact with did not said that they can't pay me but just ignored my mail. And it was not even a huge amount, but it could be used for a semester in college. Edit: I was emphasizing that I became irrationally frustrated, not that I didn't kill someone.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Though I was not close to pick a gun. You maybe not, but less mentally stable persons or those without any safety net? The US isn't known for good mental health care and also not for a safety net. Not everyone lives a privileged life.
- GVIrish 9y agoSorry but this is ridiculous. Someone decided that to respond to having video de-monetized on a website was justification for trying to kill people. How on earth is it reasonable to start down the path of 'well if she had talked to tech support...' Tier 1 support is now supposed to dissuade lunatics from murdering people? Are we supposed to construct our society around making sure that nothing, nowhere could possibly lead to a lunatic getting upset at some decision that could inconvenience them?
- mschuster91 9y ago> at some decision that could inconvenience them? Losing one's job is not just an "inconvenience". It is an inconvenience in a country with a social safety net. In a country like the US where job loss often enough means direct loss of health insurance and a place to live, losing a job can (and will) lead to homelessness and eventual death.
- GVIrish 9y agoWhere does it say that Youtube was the sole source of this woman's income? But let's say it was. People lose their jobs all the time and don't result to violence. It makes zero sense to assign blame to Youtube for the shooting even if them de-monetizing her took away her only source of income.
- mschuster91 9y ago> People lose their jobs all the time and don't result to violence. Oh, enough do. There's a reason why fired people get escorted by security.
- MikkoFinell 9y agoYeah you're right, and those people who got shot probably deserved it because they were probably racists or something.