3 ms·
I'm struggling to understand the difference between a mentally unwell person and a mentally unwell corporation or government. I don't think YouTube is mentally
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
I'm struggling to understand the difference between a mentally unwell person and a mentally unwell corporation or government.
I don't think YouTube is mentally unwell, but there have certainly been examples in the past of corporations acting in ways that resulted in the deaths of individuals - either through negligence (justified economically) or through rare but not nonexistent direct corporate violence.
Contemporary examples of murderous governments are trivially easy to find.
Why do we consider murderous individuals mentally ill, but not murderous groups of individuals once they're beyond a certain level of political and/or economic influence?
- pjc50 9y ago> Why do we consider murderous individuals mentally ill, but not murderous groups of individuals Other way round, surely? Recieving a diagnosis of mental illness is one of the few things that will save a murderer from punishment. There is a tendency for news and the public to reclassify certain kinds of crime as "mentally ill" when they can't, or don't want to understand, the motivations. Often it's a form of terrorism and radicalisation.
- wu-ikkyu 9y ago>Why do we consider murderous individuals mentally ill, but not murderous groups of individuals once they're beyond a certain level of political and/or economic influence? Because "might makes right" is an implicit virtue for many of the most powerful of people.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I'm struggling to understand the difference between a mentally unwell person and a mentally unwell corporation or government. Corporations and governments are collections whose concrete eleemtns are individuals. If corporations or governments act out of mental illness, it is the mental illness of one or more of the individuals comprising the collection. The aggregate might be subject to dysfunction distinct from but in some way analogous to individual mental illness, but that isn't mental illness, just a loosely analogous state. > Why do we consider murderous individuals mentally ill We generally don't, though mental illness is an explanation for some personal violence.
- freedomben 9y agoWRT corporate mental illness, I'm not convinced it's widespread mental illness rather than simply the way humans are combined with poor/unethical/apathetic/etc leadership. The vast majority of us just go along with whatever an "authority" tells us is right. The Milgram Experiment [1] illustrated this well. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment