3 ms·
It turns out that when an organization applies rules arbitrarily, they eventually piss off the wrong person.
by ravenstine 9y ago
It turns out that when an organization applies rules arbitrarily, they eventually piss off the wrong person.
- matthewbauer 9y agoSounds like you are blaming the victim.
- ben509 9y agoAs a general principal, there is no logical or moral reason why a victim should be beyond blame. The goal should be to judge the situation fairly; just as much as you don't want to automatically blame the victim, neither should you automatically find the victim blameless.
- anxrn 9y agoGive me one good reason why blaming a random Google employee lunching in the cafeteria is "fair". (Disclaimer: I witnessed the shooting today, so not quite unbiased)
- ravenstine 9y agoJust so we're clear, I'm not blaming a "random" Google employee, as you are suggesting. I don't want to downplay this tragedy, and I wouldn't say that anyone deserved it. It's horrible that you had to witness what happened, and I'm sorry to hear it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ben509 9y agoWe consider crimes against young children to be particularly bad precisely because they're genuinely blameless. Once you get past childhood, though, you're a moral agent making choices. If you work at a company, yeah, you are in a small part contributing to their actions and by continuing to work there, assenting to those actions. After all, a random Googler lunching in the cafeteria wants the prestige associated with all the good things Google does, that's got to come with some measure of blame for the bad things Google does. You can't have it both ways.
- anxrn 9y agoSo, wanting to work at a reputed place for software engineering == endorsing every single policy the company (a collection of over 70K individuals) might adopt? To the point that you should be expected to take a bullet for it?
- ravenstine 9y agoYouTube as a company is the victim? Even if it was, as opposed to the individual employees involved, victims can play a role in situations that come to be. Making an observation about this is not victim-blaming, nor does it absolve the aggressor.
- billysielu 9y agoBoth sides are victims though.
- coralreef 9y agoGenerally when you have any rules at all, you piss off people. Can't make everyone happy.
- ravenstine 9y agoThat's true, too. Do you think that unclear or arbitrary rules tend to aggravate individuals as often as rules that are clearly laid out, enforced evenly, and can be appealed?
- baud147258 9y agoFrom what I've seen in a forum where the rules are pretty much arbitrary (don't piss off the boss), such rules aggravate individuals just as much as clearly laid out rules. But in case of unclear or arbitrary rules, the appeal process is non-existent and the application uneven.
- transreal 9y agoNot justifying what she did, but YouTube's rules are non-transparent. The rules need to be published, and if there is room for doubt in them (which there always is), there needs to be a process to raise grievances. From what I've read other places, there is no one to talk to if you disagree with what YouTube has done, and they don't even tell you why.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]