3 ms·
The problem I usually have with redesigns is the people advocating a redesign seldom pitch it armed with data showing the redesign will be better. Show me quant
by ryandrake 9y ago
The problem I usually have with redesigns is the people advocating a redesign seldom pitch it armed with data showing the redesign will be better. Show me quantitatively that moving this button or changing that color or font size will move the needle on revenue, or engagement, or whatever the key metrics are.
At most software companies, if you want to add a feature, the burden is on you to estimate the value the feature will provide, and demonstrate how you will measure the value post release. How you draw the line from the feature to the value will be scrutinized. If the idea doesn’t stand up to it, it’s questionable why we need to invest in the feature.
This same scrutiny often doesn’t apply to redesigns. We are redesigning because it needs to look “fresh” or “modern”. It needs to “pop”. The old design looks old. So how do you measure “pop” in a way that’s not explainable by other product changes? (??) If it doesn’t quantitatively pop, do we go back to the old design? (the answer is always no) And the designers always get all bummed when you ask for this data. Look at all the criticism of Marissa Meyer having the gall to AB test 30 shades of blue. Why isn’t it ok to measure art?
I don’t think you’re an old man waving around your cane. This is an important question to ask because the effort blown on redesigns often could have otherwise been invested in things that would bring more value.