3 ms·
>It's clear that in our modern era, with our extremely robust theories of physics, backed by extremely precise observations of the universe, that the religious
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
>It's clear that in our modern era, with our extremely robust theories of physics, backed by extremely precise observations of the universe, that the religious explanations of existence are false.
I think that's up for debate still.
- kreutz 9y agoWhat is the basis for debate? We have observable, testable, repeatable, data backed hypotheses on one hand and stories on the other.
- loupeabody 9y agoMonistic Idealism vs. Monistic Physicalism/Materialism
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- CryoLogic 9y agoI'd agree. I think it would be better to say: "Now that we have developed tools and processes for validating truths against falsehoods which seem to be accurate across all applications thus far - for a religion to exist it must violate one or more of the rules that are true elsewhere or bypass these rules entirely." So "false" vs "unprovable".
- lemagedurage 9y agoWell they're not hiding it. "Miracles" inherently bypass those rules.
- baddox 9y agoIt might be fairer to look at the scientifically falsifiable claims that are or were important to major religions and determine which of those have been scientifically falsified. Some conspicuous examples have certainly been falsified, like young earth creationism, but that certainly doesn’t mean that all of Christianity’s claims have been falsified.
- majewsky 9y ago> Some conspicuous examples have certainly been falsified, like young earth creationism The classic counter-argument is that God has created the world N years ago in a way that makes it appear older, in order to test our faith or sth like that. You cannot really disprove that. Scientists discard such theories because of Alder's Razor: "What cannot be settled by experiment is not worth debating." I think your misconception is that science is the method by which all truths can be discovered. That has not been shown. Science is merely a narrowed down version of philosophy (with restrictions on which tools and methods may be used) that is vastly better at finding a consistent and useful model of reality than average philosophy. This is why something like Occam's Razor (or Alder's Razor from above) is used by scientists. Occam does not say that the simpler hypothesis is always correct, but it suggests that you will usually be more productive when you work with simpler rather than more complex hypotheses.
- baddox 9y agoI don’t think that is a common counter-argument. The young earth creationism I’m aware of explicitly denies that God made things look as if the Earth was actually older, that humans evolved from other primates, etc. In the US, Answers in Genesis is probably the most prominent advocate of supposedly scientific arguments for a young earth. Here’s one article from them: https://answersingenesis.org/age-of-the-earth/ https://answersingenesis.org/age-of-the-earth/