4 ms·
I work in wireless telecom: Really doubtful "we don't know how to find them". The FCC's enforcement bureau has a set of vans equipped to find unauthorized trans
by walrus01 9y ago
I work in wireless telecom: Really doubtful "we don't know how to find them". The FCC's enforcement bureau has a set of vans equipped to find unauthorized transmitters. IMSI catchers must transmit and remain on the air. It would be very risky to operate, even briefly, a portable imsi catcher in a briefcase and move it around WA DC, nevermind one that remained in fixed locations for hours. The only other explanation I can think of is being operated from embassies with full diplomatic protections, but that runs the risk of the host county (USA) PNG'ing several staff with 24 hour notice as punishment.
Quick edit: Whole US federal agencies have their own TSCM (technical surveillance countermeasures) staff entirely separate from the FCC. It is a job position at the dept of state. Evolved from bug detection and removal in the analog days to now encompass just about everything that can leak data.
- subway 9y agoDepends on how much the devices cost to procure, and the budget of the party using them. Seems like these could be treated as "black-throws" given the right cost:budget ratio.
- vvanders 9y agoNot even that, if you want to use them as a MitM just broadcast the data you want and any arbitrary receiver will pick them up that can't be pinpointed. That's assuming you don't mind losing the transmitting hardware.
- subway 9y agoI think we're saying the same thing.
- beamatronic 9y agoI am not familiar with this term, “black-throw”, can you elaborate?
- subway 9y agoblackthrow or svartkast is a term for a device left behind in potentially hostile territory to continue operating until it is discovered or fails
- walrus01 9y agoFor example an imsi catcher spliced into 120vac power and stuffed up into a ceiling tile in a busy shopping mall. I bet that with a stepladder, a clipboard and two guys in high visibility vests, a set of electrician tools, you could do this at nearly any mall in America.
- subway 9y agoBonus points for installing a few near each other, configured to operate identically, but at different times.
- mschuster91 9y agoHow do you get the sniffed data, though? You're gonna need some form of high bandwidth uplink.
- OnMyPhone 9y agoOne option might be to have the sniffing device setup with a hidden wireless network (of some sort). Then when you walk around, sit in the food court eating, or if the device is close to the outside, sit somewhere out of sight of the cameras with a strong wifi antennae and grab whatever data. Unless they have some "free" wifi that the device could hop on to send it to some server somewhere. Using that and / or 4g would make it easier to find the device and, of course, the person though.
- bigiain 9y agoOpenBTS and Ettus USPR (software defined radios) have made it inexpensive enough for hobbyists to set up cellular base stations at Burningman. The difference between an open source base station, and a homebuilt stingray in negligible. While a grand or two's worth of radio hardware and however many weekends/evenings spent getting it all set up and the a software configured is _kind of_ expensive - it's effectively free at criminal org, corporate espionage, or state levels of action.
- int0x21 9y agoTry less than $200. LimeSDR Mini or a couple Motorola C123s running Osmocombb with a filter swap...or a hacked femtocell
- PeterisP 9y agoThe other explanation is very low power / short range e.g. femtocells. If a Stingray-like device is affecting a single building or the like, targeting a particular person, it likely won't be noticed by anyone.
- walrus01 9y agoSomething strong enough to get a whole building full of phones to ping it most certainly can be found by a $70,000 spectrum analyzers and trained RF engineer.
- bigiain 9y agoHell - I bet you could find that with a $12 RTL-SDR and a home built antenna plugged into your laptop - if you were curious and suspected there was one nearby...
- uabstraction 9y agoNever underestimate the amateur radio community. They hunt down radio pirates, emitters of interference, and hidden beacons for FUN! With the right antenna and a halfway decent receiver, it is not too difficult to hunt down the source of a transmission. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transmitter_hunting https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transmitter_hunting
- trhway 9y ago>It would be very risky to operate, even briefly, a portable imsi catcher in a briefcase and move it around WA DC, nevermind one that remained in fixed locations for hours. how about quick switching between several [semi-stationary or briefcase carried] catchers (by analogy with an old Russia/USSR anti-aircraft tactic of quickly switching between several radars to avoid being detected and locked-in by an anti-radar missile :).
- walrus01 9y agoTheoretically possible. Using current off the shelf tech, several imsi catchers could be networked together by normal LTE data networks with battle tested VPN crypto. Doable with any mifi type hotspot device or even just a modern phone and tethering. People with high end spectrum analyzers and directional antennas would struggle to locate a thing that only powers on for 1-2 minutes, and the relocated to a random location. If I were trying to find such things I would need three separate DF (direction finding) teams, and try to establish a pattern of behavior or movement on the part of the operators to narrow down the target areas. Could take weeks.
- bertjk 9y agoI'm not a wireless expert, but then wouldn't it also be theoretically possible to have a network of direction finders? Isn't direction finding also a repeatable set of steps that can benefit from automation?
- walrus01 9y agoYes, though DF can be much more efficient with directional (yagi, parabolic, horn) antennas. If fully automated by network the antennas connected to the spectrum analyzers need to be on two axis motorized platforms.
- cryptonector 9y agoIt would be easier to, you know, secure wireless communications to begin with. It's not like the Feds couldn't arrange to have stingrays that are properly keyed. (And there's always CALEA.) Yes, I know, it would only be easier for new kit, but it will take a long time to get it deployed. But every year we delay this makes the pain worse.
- blitmap 9y agoI'm laughing because that's how this discussion will go when posted here: We'll detail a method to catch rogue sting-rays, then brainstorm how to operate them with less risk.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoWell, yeah. That's standard operating procedure for Red/Blue team work. By knowing how to hack, one knows how to defend. But knowing how to defend also imparts the knowledge to hack.
- rsync 9y ago"It would be very risky to operate, even briefly, a portable imsi catcher in a briefcase and move it around WA DC, nevermind one that remained in fixed locations for hours." Even more so in 2018 where an IMSI catcher is only relevant/useful if you downgrade the target to 2G operation, which requires some kind of additional interference/jamming. Unless they are using "stingray" as some kind of generic term for "device you use to intercept mobile phones" and there are now 3G/LTE "stingrays". This would all be so simple to deal with if phones just displayed an "unlocked" or "downgraded" warning when operating in 2G or unencrypted mode ...
- walrus01 9y agoIMSI catchers exist for at least 3gpp release 12, which is one type of LTE. https://www.unwiredinsight.com/2014/highlights-of-3gpp-release-12 https://www.unwiredinsight.com/2014/highlights-of-3gpp-relea... https://www.google.ca/search?q=3gpp+release+12+imsi+catcher&oq=3gpp+release+12+imsi+catcher&aqs=chrome..69i57.10427j0j7&sourceid=chrome-mobile&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.ca/search?q=3gpp+release+12+imsi+catcher&...
- spartango 9y agoWhile there is extensive infrastructure for detecting active transmitting devices like Stingrays, there's no discussion (or tooling) around passive IMSI grabbers. These devices are significantly more limited (no IMEI or MSISDN, GSM-only), they remain pretty effective in areas/networks where GSM is still in place.
- walrus01 9y agohttps://mg.co.za/article/2016-09-01-00-meet-the-grabber-how-govt-and-criminals-can-spy-on-you-and-how-to-protect-yourself/ https://mg.co.za/article/2016-09-01-00-meet-the-grabber-how-... Verint engage gi2
- sorokod 9y agoI think it is reasonable to ask if the "feds" actually want to find those stingrays. Disinformation is a powerful tool.
- rainbowmverse 9y ago>> Evolved from bug detection and removal in the analog days to now encompass just about everything that can leak data. Relevant: http://www.cryptomuseum.com/covert/bugs/selectric/index.htm http://www.cryptomuseum.com/covert/bugs/selectric/index.htm
- greggarious 9y ago>It would be very risky to operate, even briefly, a portable imsi catcher in a briefcase and move it around WA DC, nevermind one that remained in fixed locations for hours. I'd assume if it was run from an embassy it's not risky at all actually - they can just tell the FCC to pound sand
- ilkan 9y agoThis doesn't sound like a technical problem. More like a government is being defunded, half the vans need repair, lack of senior management, no direction, other priorities, shortage of techs, hiring freeze, the remaining people only work from 9-5 and we don't pay overtime, type of problem.
- 616c 9y agoHow do I get into TSCM from convential appsec work? Is it EE guys and gals and smizmars?